Depressive Symptoms and Culture in Chinese Patients

Jikun Wang,Xudong Zhao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0020764011431797
2013-01-01
International Journal of Social Psychiatry
Abstract:Depression is a very common mental disorder around the world, but the way that depression is discussed may vary in different cultures. Experiences of depression are shaped by culture, as are decisions about treatment, doctor–patient interactions and so on (Kleinman, 2004). Therefore, some conditions of depression are universal and some are culturally distinct. Some factors that are protective in one culture may be risk factors in another. Considerable evidence has accumulated to show that culture and ethnic background are related to the outcomes of treating depression (Ryder et al., 2008). Additionally, the experience of Chinese depressed patients is more physical than psychological. For instance, many Chinese depressed patients report symptoms of pain, dizziness and fatigue rather than feeling sad, and the balance of biological and cultural factors may be associated with the onset of post-natal depression. Chinese depressed patients tend to emphasize somatic symptoms, which is a key finding of cultural psychopathology (Ryder et al., 2008). Some research has proposed that Chinese depressed patients focus on somatic symptoms as part of the patient role (Yen, Robins, & Lin, 2000), while western samples tend to emphasize psychological symptoms. One possible explanation could be that mental disorders are stigmatized in Chinese societies, and depressed patients may inhabit the patient role in society by using somatization without bearing the burden of stigma (Chung & Wong, 2004). Furthermore, the variations in processing and expressing affect may result in symptom presentation due to cultural differences (Sayar, Kirmayer, & Taillefer, 2003). A clear emotional expression may be a trait associated with healthy functioning in western societies. A preference for indirect thinking and expressing style in China would not be pathological and fit with cultural variation. Chinese depressed patients reported greater perceived stigma than did North American patients, and stigma was associated with general symptom reporting in both samples (Ryder et al., 2008). Chinese depressed patients reported higher scores on alexithymia, positively associated with somatic symptoms in both samples (Ryder et al., 2008). This study suggests that somatic symptoms are noticed by patients who do not frequently emphasize their internal emotional state, while western culture emphasizes the personal experience and interpersonal communication of emotion. Nowadays, there is a growing population of migrants around the world. Better understanding of depression in different cultures will help clinicians to improve the identification and treatment of depression. Depressed patients and their families can benefit from that.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?