A Small Clue Made of Fragmented Pieces
Minhyung Lee,Jinyoung Min,Junyeong Lee,Chanhee Kwak,Hanbyeol Stella Choi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3624714
IF: 22.7
2024-03-26
Communications of the ACM
Abstract:When online intermediaries provide a space for individuals to comment and share their opinions, the hope or expectation is to facilitate civic engagement. However, although civic engagement is achieved to a certain extent, uncivil behaviors, such as aggressively attacking opposing opinions, producing malicious comments and rumors, and even expressing insults and threatening comments, have also increased. Cyberbullying, cyber-sexual harassment, and online hate speech are only a few of the uncivil behaviors expressed via malicious comments. This behavior is performed mostly in anonymous environments, where people are less concerned about the real-life impact of online behavior. According to an analysis of online comments, 53.3% of anonymous comments include hateful and aggressive language, while only 28.7% of real-name comments are uncivil. 33 Anonymous interactions that inherently lack an understanding of their social context can lead to destructive behaviors, which could have extreme consequences. The negative implications of malicious online comments can be more serious for celebrities who must face many unknown individuals. For example, violent comments based on unconfirmed rumors have led to the deaths of K-pop stars. 8 Despite the victims' requests to refrain from making such comments, the production of offensive content continues behind the mask of anonymity. Uncivil comments are sometimes found in unexpected places. In response to an online article regarding miners trapped in a Chilean mine, the following comments were found: "These guys are frauds" and "We're just trying to make the world a better place one brainwashed, ignorant idiot at a time." 39 Key Insights The commenting function of online intermediaries and digital platforms is expected to facilitate civic engagement via healthy discussion and the sharing of diverse perspectives. However, while anonymous online spaces can encourage civil discussion, they can also nurture uncivil behaviors, including the posting of malicious comments. Several attempts have been made to resolve this issue, especially by decreasing anonymity; however, these solutions have often been less effective than expected or have had controversial consequences, such as limiting the freedom of speech. An online comment-history disclosure system provides users with access to their accumulated comment histories; helping them to perceive their digital identity is built upon their past behaviors can effectively induce digital citizenship behaviors while retaining their anonymity. As these cases demonstrate, uncivil comments can degrade and skew public discourse and even further develop into violent threats. Even if these threats are not realized, abusive comments can cause enormous psychological harm, including fear, stress, depression, and feelings of inferiority. 15 Furthermore, malicious online comments can intimidate individuals who have already expressed their opinions, potentially discouraging them from participating in further discourse, thereby significantly limiting civic engagement. Uncivil comments can degrade and skew public discourse and even further develop into violent threats. Furthermore, the harmful effects of uncivil online behaviors are magnified since individuals tend to generate more aggressive comments in an anonymous online environment. 31 With the growing number of Internet users, the number of individuals posting malicious comments can easily become large enough to distort the direction and consequences of public discourse. How Anonymity Induces Uncivil Behavior When people perceive anonymity online, they tend to be more willing to express their opinions, even on controversial and sensitive issues, such as abortion. 37 The mere possibility of eliminating anonymity can decrease both the number of posts as well as the amount of dialogue that occurs in online communities. 23 When people perceive anonymity online, they tend to be more willing to express their opinions, even on controversial and sensitive issues. However, while anonymity enables individuals to share their opinions, it also allows them to express their opinions in an uncivil manner. For example, on The Washington Post website, which provides anonymity to commenters, uncivil online behavior is a significantly common occurrence. 32 The quality of comments on online articles decreases under anonymity and increases when the degree of anonymity decreases. 30 Individuals are more likely -Abstract Truncated-
computer science, theory & methods, software engineering, hardware & architecture