A Dynamic Switching Dual-Path Group Consensus Feedback Mechanism with the Dynamic Hybrid Trust Network

Yuan Qin,Guoliang Li,Mi Zhang,Yulong Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4241182
2022-01-01
SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract:This paper focuses on the consensus-reaching process (CRP) under social networks. There has been ample research on CRP over these years; however, the existing literature on CRP has yet to study the problem of strategy choice for decision-makers (DMs). This paper argues that there are only two strategies for DMs in CRP: (a) adjusting their own opinions and (b) sticking to their own opinions. Based on this, this paper proposes a decision-making behavior-driven group consensus-reaching mechanism, i.e., a dynamic switching dual-path feedback mechanism based on a dynamic hybrid trust network. The proposed mechanism consists of two major parts: (a) a dynamic hybrid trust network among DMs; and (b) a dynamic switching dual-path feedback mechanism by comparing the self-confidence degrees (SCDs) of DMs and their average degrees of trust in others (AD-TIOs). We gain indirect trust among DMs through an innovative trust propagation and aggregation model in the first part. Then, we fuse the prior social relationship information and opinion similarity to obtain the hybrid trust network. The hybrid trust network can be dynamically and iteratively updated in the CRP, reflecting the changes in trust relationships among DMs. In the second part, DMs with inconsistent consensus are identified and provided with opinion or weight modification path selection suggestions based on their SCDs and AD-TIOs. The validity and flexibility of the proposed mechanism are verified through an actual investment decision case, related sensitivity analysis, and comparative studies.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?