Blastocyst Culture of Human Suboptimal Embryos Does Not Improve Clinical Outcomes
Y.-F. Gu,C.-F. Lu,F. Gong,G.-X. Lu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2009.07.1617
IF: 6.7
2009-01-01
Fertility and Sterility
Abstract:OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to evaluate whether blastocyst culture of human suboptimal embryos could help for embryo selection and improve clinical outcomes.DESIGN: Retrospective study.MATERIALS AND METHODS: The inclusion criteria were patients who had only suboptimal embryos (all embryos ≤6-cell or embryo fragments >10%) on Day 3. In Day 3 transfer group, embryos were selected and transferred on Day 3. In blastocyst culture group, embryos were cultured to Day 5 and transferred if reached blastocyst stage. Embryos were cultured in Vitrolife G5 series culture media at 37.5°C, 6% CO2, 5% O2. The mean age of patients was not significantly different between the groups (32.3 VS. 32.0 years). Clinical pregnancy, ongoing pregnancy and implantation rate were compared between the groups using χ Test.RESULTS: In Day 3 transfer group, 241 embryos of 114 patients (2.1 embryos /patient) were transferred, 59 were implanted (24.5%), clinical pregnancy was confirmed in 44 patients (38.6%), and ongoing pregnancy was defined in 40 patients (35.1%; miscarriage=1, ectopic pregnancy=3). In blastocyst culture group, 421 embryos of 106 patients were cultured to Day 5, 88 reached blastocyst (20.9%), and 18 blastocysts were scored ≥ 3BB (Gardener's grading criteria) (4.3%). Fifty-seven cycles (53.8%) were cancelled because of unavailability of blastocysts. Eighty-four blastocysts of 49 patients (1.7 embryos /patient) were transferred, 15 were implanted (17.9%), and clinical pregnancy and ongoing pregnancy was confirmed in 12 patients (11.3% per oocyte retrieval, 24.5% per embryo transfer). The mean number of transferred embryos (P=0.001), clinical pregnancy and ongoing pregnancy rate per oocyte retrieval (P<0.001) were significantly higher in Day 3 transfer group.CONCLUSIONS: Human embryos with suboptimal morphology showed limited developmental potential. Extended in vitro culture has more adverse stress on them, which can lead to developmental arrest. Blastocyst culture of suboptimal embryos does not improve clinical outcomes. OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to evaluate whether blastocyst culture of human suboptimal embryos could help for embryo selection and improve clinical outcomes. DESIGN: Retrospective study. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The inclusion criteria were patients who had only suboptimal embryos (all embryos ≤6-cell or embryo fragments >10%) on Day 3. In Day 3 transfer group, embryos were selected and transferred on Day 3. In blastocyst culture group, embryos were cultured to Day 5 and transferred if reached blastocyst stage. Embryos were cultured in Vitrolife G5 series culture media at 37.5°C, 6% CO2, 5% O2. The mean age of patients was not significantly different between the groups (32.3 VS. 32.0 years). Clinical pregnancy, ongoing pregnancy and implantation rate were compared between the groups using χ Test. RESULTS: In Day 3 transfer group, 241 embryos of 114 patients (2.1 embryos /patient) were transferred, 59 were implanted (24.5%), clinical pregnancy was confirmed in 44 patients (38.6%), and ongoing pregnancy was defined in 40 patients (35.1%; miscarriage=1, ectopic pregnancy=3). In blastocyst culture group, 421 embryos of 106 patients were cultured to Day 5, 88 reached blastocyst (20.9%), and 18 blastocysts were scored ≥ 3BB (Gardener's grading criteria) (4.3%). Fifty-seven cycles (53.8%) were cancelled because of unavailability of blastocysts. Eighty-four blastocysts of 49 patients (1.7 embryos /patient) were transferred, 15 were implanted (17.9%), and clinical pregnancy and ongoing pregnancy was confirmed in 12 patients (11.3% per oocyte retrieval, 24.5% per embryo transfer). The mean number of transferred embryos (P=0.001), clinical pregnancy and ongoing pregnancy rate per oocyte retrieval (P<0.001) were significantly higher in Day 3 transfer group. CONCLUSIONS: Human embryos with suboptimal morphology showed limited developmental potential. Extended in vitro culture has more adverse stress on them, which can lead to developmental arrest. Blastocyst culture of suboptimal embryos does not improve clinical outcomes.