Abstract:The transverse current (j_H) due to anomalous Hall effect (AHE) is usually assumed to be perpendicular to the magnetization (m) in ferromagnetic materials, which governs the experiments in spintronics. Generally, this assumption is derived from a continuum model, where the crystal's discrete symmetry is effectively represented by the concept of an effective mass from the band structure. In this paper, we calculate the spin transport through the nonmagnetic metal (NM) | ferromagnetic metal (FM) interfaces and find that the corresponding Hall current is generally not perpendicular to m with only a few exceptions at high symmetry crystal orientations. The calculation illustrates the breakdown of j_H={\theta}m{\times}j_c, where {\theta} denotes the anomalous Hall angle and j_c represents the injecting charge current. An analytical formula based on the discrete symmetry of the solid can describe this effect well. In this framework, the leading order corresponds to the conventional AHE, while higher-order terms account for deviations in the Hall current. Additionally, we identify the presence of a chiral anomalous Hall effect (CAHE) at interface with odd rotational symmetry (e.g., C_{3v}) and the higher-order terms can even dominate the AHE by constructing superlattices. The general existence of hidden chirality in spin transport is also revealed, with a specific focus on interface chirality (IC). Our results highlight the significance of discrete atomic positions in solids for spin transport, which extends beyond the conventional continuum model. Moreover, considering the important application of the AHE in spintronics and the wide existence of the interfaces in the devices, the breakdown of j_H={\theta}m{\times}j_c suggests that all experimental measurements related to the AHE should be re-evaluated.

Intrinsic Anomalous Spin Hall Effect

The origin of intrinsic anomalous spin Hall effect

Spin Hall effect emerging from a chiral magnetic lattice without spin-orbit coupling

Field-linear Anomalous Hall Effect and Berry Curvature Induced by Spin Chirality in the Kagome Antiferromagnet Mn3Sn

Large intrinsic anomalous Hall effect in half-metallic ferromagnet Co3Sn2S2 with magnetic Weyl fermions

Giant Nonlinear Anomalous Hall Effect Induced by Spin-Dependent Band Structure Evolution

Anomalous spin Hall effects in Dresselhaus (110) quantum wells

Anomalous Hall Effect in MnAl/W Bilayers: Modification from Strong Spin Hall Effect of W

On the angular dependence of anomalous Hall current

Anomalous Spin–orbit Torques in Magnetic Single-Layer Films

Antiferromagnetic Inverse Spin Hall Effect

Anomalous Hall Effect Induced by a Pure Longitudinal Spin Injection

Intrinsic Spin Hall Conductivity of the Semimetals MoTe2 and WTe2

Spin Hall Conductivity and Anomalous Hall Conductivity in Full Heusler Compounds

Intrinsically Enhanced Anomalous Hall Conductivity and Hall Angle in Sb-doped Magnetic Weyl Semimetal Co3Sn2S2

Evaluation of spin diffusion length and spin Hall angle of antiferromagnetic Weyl semimetal Mn$_3$Sn

33% Giant Anomalous Hall Current Driven by both Intrinsic and Extrinsic Contributions in Magnetic Weyl Semimetal Co3Sn2S2

Intrinsic spin Hall effect from spin quantum metric

Extrinsic spin Hall effects measured with lateral spin valve structures

Spin Hall Effects Without Spin Currents in Magnetic Insulators

Anomalous Hall effect sensitive to magnetic monopoles and skyrmion helicity in spin-orbit coupled systems