Abstract:This paper presents an expository reverse-mathematical analysis of two fundamental theorems in commutative algebra: Hilbert's Nullstellensatz and Basis Theorem. In addition to its profound significance in commutative algebra and algebraic geometry, the Basis Theorem is also historically notable for its nonconstructive proof. The Nullstellensatz, on the other hand, is noteworthy as it establishes a fundamental connection between the more algebraic notion of ideals and the more geometric notion of varieties. We explore the conscious shift from computational to conceptual approaches in mathematical argumentation, contextualizing Hilbert's contributions. We formalize the relative constructivity of these theorems using the framework of reverse mathematics, although we do not presuppose familiarity with reverse mathematics. Drawing from contemporary mathematical literature, we analyze the Basis Theorem's reliance on nonconstructive methods versus the more constructive nature of the Nullstellensatz. Our study employs the standard tools of reverse mathematics, in particular subsystems of second-order arithmetic, to outline the minimal set-existence axioms required for these theorems. We review results showing that certain formulations of the Nullstellensatz are provable in the weak axiom system of $\mathsf{RCA}_0$, while the Basis Theorem requires stronger axioms, such as $\Sigma^0_2$-Induction. Consequently, we position these theorems separately within the Friedman-Simpson hierarchy. This analysis contributes to a deeper understanding of the foundational requirements for these pivotal results in algebra.

A Gr\"{o}bner Basis Approach to Combinatorial Nullstellensatz

A Gröbner Basis Approach to Combinatorial Nullstellensatz

Combinatorial Nullstellensatz Techniques

Dimension-free matricial Nullstellensätze for noncommutative polynomials

Motivated exposition of combinatorial Nullstellensatz

Gröbner bases and final polynomials

A Reverse Mathematical Analysis of Hilbert's Nullstellensatz and Basis Theorem

Projective Nullstellensatz for not necessarily algebraically closed fields

The extra basis in noncommuting variables

Signature Gröbner bases, bases of syzygies and cofactor reconstruction in the free algebra

Fine multidegrees, universal Grobner bases, and matrix Schubert varieties

On Hilbert-Poincaré series of affine semi-regular polynomial sequences and related Gröbner bases

Noncommutative Gröbner Bases and Ext groups; Application to the Steenrod Algebra

A new conception for computing gröbner basis and its applications

The Number of Gröbner Bases in Finite Fields

Gr{ö}bner Basis over Semigroup Algebras: Algorithms and Applications for Sparse Polynomial Systems

Gröbner bases, resolutions, and the Lefschetz properties for powers of a general linear form in the squarefree algebra

Cohen-Macaulay, Gorenstein and complete intersection conditions by marked bases

Sparse Nullstellensatz, resultants and determinants of complexes

Gröbner-Shirshov bases and linear bases for free differential type algebras over algebras

Gröbner--Shirshov bases for commutative dialgebras