The Moderating Effects of Trust and Felt Trust on the Nonlinear Relationship Between Compulsory Citizenship Behavior and Counterproductive Work Behavior
Haojie Song,Yueyang Li,Qiang Zhang,Yanyuan Cheng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/prbm.s413674
IF: 3.974
2023-07-06
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Haojie Song, 1 Yueyang Li, 1 Qiang Zhang, 2 Yanyuan Cheng 3 1 School of Business, Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou City, People's Republic of China; 2 Department of Health Policy & Management, Shenzhen Health Development Research and Data Management Center, Shenzhen City, People's Republic of China; 3 School of Labor and Human Resources, Renmin University of China, Beijing City, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Qiang Zhang, Department of Health Policy & Management, Shenzhen Health Development Research and Data Management Center, No.8 Yuanling of 5th Street, Futian District, Shenzhen City, Guangdong Province, 518028, People's Republic of China, Tel +86 0755 22209945, Email Purpose: This study explored the J-shaped effect of compulsory citizenship behavior on counterproductive work behavior of new generation employees, as well as the separate and joint moderating effects of trust and felt trust on the J-shaped relationship between compulsory citizenship behavior and counterproductive work behavior. Methods: Three waves of data were collected from 659 new generation employees in China. A self-report method was used to measure compulsory citizenship behavior, counterproductive work behavior, trust and felt trust. Then, based on the cognitive appraisal theory of stress and social information processing theory, a nonlinear model was constructed and tested. Results: (1) Compulsory citizenship behavior had a J-shaped effect on job performance. That is, when the compulsory citizenship behavior level was lower, the effect of compulsory citizenship behavior on counterproductive work behavior was not significant; but when it increased to medium and higher levels, the effect was significant and stronger. (2) The moderating effect of trust (employees' perceived trust in leader) or felt trust (employees' perception of being trusted by leader) was significant. That is, when trust or felt trust was lower, the J-shaped effect was stronger; conversely, the J-shaped effect was weak. (3) The joint moderating effect of trust and felt trust was significant. That is, when trust was high, the moderation effect of felt trust was significant; conversely, the moderation effect of felt trust was not significant. Conclusion: The results identify the nonlinear effect of compulsory citizenship behavior through exploring the J-shaped effect of compulsory citizenship behavior on counterproductive work behavior and the boundary conditions in the nonlinear relationship. Meanwhile, the study provide implications for organizations regarding how to manage employees' work behavior. Keywords: compulsory citizenship behavior, counterproductive work behavior, trust, felt trust As marketing competition grows, employees have to perform more and more extra-role behaviors beyond the formal specifications of their duties under organizational pressure. 1 The extra-role behavior that employees have to engage in against their will is called compulsory citizenship behavior. 2–4 Existing studies have found that unlike voluntary organizational citizenship behavior, which boosts organizational performance, 5 compulsory citizenship behavior may have an effect on employee's negative work behavior, such as inducing counterproductive work behavior, which is the serious negative work behavior employees take the initiative to harm organizational performance. 6 For example, based on the social exchange theory, compulsory citizenship behavior had an effect on counterproductive work behavior through emotional exhaustion; 7 according to the moral disengagement theory, compulsory citizenship behavior had an effect on counterproductive work behavior through moral disengagement. 8 However, some studies pointed out that even when employees had to engage in compulsory citizenship behavior, they still did not perform counterproductive work behavior to harm organizational performance. 9–11 Previous studies have laid a foundation for understanding the effect of compulsory citizenship behavior on counterproductive work behavior, but there is insufficient studies on how compulsory citizenship behavior impacts counterproductive work behavior, and the existing studies did not reach a consensus conclusion. There are still some gaps to bridge. Firstly, few studies explored the effect of compulsory citizenship behavior on new generation employees' negative work behavior. However, new generation employees have become the main workforce, and compared to old generation employees, they are more self-focused and tend to pursue more work autonomy. 12,13 Thus, when new generation employees engage in compulsory citizenship behavior, they may f -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary