Abstract:Background The integrated health management system (IHMS), which unites all health care–related institutions under a health-centered organizational framework, is of great significance to China in promoting the hierarchical treatment system and improving the new health care reform. China’s IHMS policy consists of multiple policies at different levels and at different times; however, there is a lack of comprehensive interpretation and analysis of these policies, which is not conducive to the further development of the IHMS in China. Objective This study aims to comprehensively analyze and understand the characteristics, development, and evolution of China’s IHMS policy to inform the design and improvement of the system. Methods We followed the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines to collect 152 policy documents. With the perspective of policy tools and policy orientation as the core, a comprehensive 6D framework including policy level, policy nature, release time, policy tools, stakeholders, and policy orientation was established by combining the content of policy texts. These dimensions were then analyzed using content analysis. Results First, we found that, regarding the coordination of policy tools and stakeholders, China’s IHMS policy was more inclined to use environment-based policy tools (1089/1929, 56.45%), which suggests a need for further balance in the internal structure of policy tools. Attention to different actors varied, and the participation of physicians and residents needs further improvement (65/2019, 3.22% and 11/2019, 0.54%, respectively). Second, in terms of level differences, Shanghai’s IHMS policy used fewer demand-based policy tools (43/483, 8.9%), whereas the national IHMS policy and those of other provinces and cities used fewer supply-based tools (61/357, 17.1% and 248/357, 69.5%, respectively). The national IHMS strategy placed more emphasis on the construction of smart health care (including digital health; 10/275, 3.6%), whereas Shanghai was a leader in the development of healthy community and healthy China (9/158, 5.7% and 4/158, 2.5%, respectively). Third, in terms of time evolution, the various policy tools showed an increasing and then decreasing trend from 2014 to 2021, with relatively more use of environment-based policy tools and less use of demand-based policy tools in the last 3 years. The growth of China’s IHMS policy can be divided into 3 stages: the disease-centered period (2014-2017), the e-health technology development period (2017-2019), and the health-centered period (2018-2021). Conclusions Policy makers should make several adjustments, such as coordinating policy tools and the uneven relationships among stakeholders; grasping key policy priorities in the context of local characteristics; and focusing on horizontal, multidimensional integration of health resources starting from the community. This study expands the objects of policy research and improves the framework for policy analysis. The findings provide some possible lessons for future policy formulation and optimization.

Study on the Change of Cooperative Network Relationship of Medical and Health Management Institutions in China Based on Policy Text Analysis

Policies Associated with the Implementation of Hierarchical Medical System across Different Provinces of the Mainland of China: a Comparative Study

Institutional Change of Farmer Cooperative Economic Organization in the Perspective of Policy Network

Collaboration of issuing agencies and topic evolution of health informatisation policies in China

Research on the Network Evolution of Shanghai's Medical and Elderly Care Integration Policy

Understanding the Integrated Health Management System Policy in China From Multiple Perspectives: Systematic Review and Content Analysis

Research on the Structural Characteristics and Evolution of China’s Medical and Health Innovation Cooperation Network Based on the Chinese Medical Science and Technology Awards

China's Cooperative Medical System: Its Historical Transformations and the Trend of Development

The Impact of Expanded Health System Reform on Governmental Contributions and Individual Copayments in the New Chinese Rural Cooperative Medical System

Public Administration In China: Toward The Network Model

Evolution analysis on 10-year policies of the New Rural Cooperative Medical System in rural China

A Path Dependence Analysis of Hospital Dominance in China (1949-2018): Lessons for Primary Care Strengthening.

Strategy Changes in Child Health Development:A Content Analysis on the National Program of Action for Child Health Development and the Five-Year Plan for National Economic and Social Development

A Social Network Analysis of Changes in China’s Education Policy Information Transmission System (1978–2013)

The development and reform of public health in China from 1949 to 2019

Analysis of clinical research publication patterns to characterize the cooperation among China’s “double first-class” construction medical universities: based on social network analysis

Analysis on the Cooperation Mechanism between CDC and Medical Community at County Level in China: From the Perspective of Evolutionary Game Theory

Changes in chronic disease management among community health centers (CHCs) in China: Has health reform improved CHC ability?

Health poverty alleviation in China from the perspective of historical institutionalism: policy changes and driving factors

Promoting the Integration of Elderly Healthcare and Elderly Nursing: Evidence from the Chinese Government

Management Capacity And Health Insurance: The Case Of The New Cooperative Medical Scheme In Six Counties In Rural China