Abstract:The Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) is one of the most well-studied combinatorial optimization problems. Best heuristics for solving the TSP known today are Lin-Kernighan (LK) local search methods. Recently, Multi-Neighborhood Search (MNS) has been proposed and was demonstrated to outperform Variable Neighborhood Search based methods on the TSP. While LK performs a variable k-opt based search operation, MNS is able to carry out multiple 2-, 3-, or 4-opt moves at once, which are discovered by a highly efficient scan of the current solution. Apart from LK and MNS, many other modern heuristics for TSPs can be found in the relevant literature. However, existing studies rarely use robust statistics for the heuristic algorithms in comparison, let alone investigate their progress over time. This leads to flawed comparisons of simple end-of-run statistics and inappropriate or even incorrect conclusions. In this paper, we thoroughly compare LK and MNS as well as their hybrid versions with Evolutionary Algorithms (EAs) and Population-based Ant Colony Optimization (PACO). This work, to the best of our knowledge, is the first statistically sound comparison of the two efficient heuristics as well as their hybrids with EAs and PACO over time based on a large-scale experimental study. We not only show that hybrid PACO-MNS and PACO-LK are both very efficient, but also find that the full runtime behavior comparison provides deeper and clearer insights whereas a focus of final results could indeed have led to a deceitful conclusion.

Algorithm for Solving Traveling Salesman Problem Based on Self-Organizing Mapping Network

An Expanding Self-Organizing Neural Network for the Traveling Salesman Problem

An Efficient Self-Organizing Map Designed by Genetic Algorithms for the Traveling Salesman Problem

Kohonen Self-Organizing Map Based Route Planning: A Revisit

Agent-based Self-organized Constructive Heuristics for Travelling Salesman Problem

Optimization and Improvement of Genetic Algorithms Solving Traveling Salesman Problem

A Novel Globally Convergent Hybrid Evolutionary Algorithm For Traveling Salesman Problems

A New High-Efficiency Global Optimization Algorithm for Solving Traveling Salesman Problem

A Columnar Competitive Model for Solving Multi-Traveling Salesman Problem

Double-winner SOM and Its Application to TSP

Travel the Same Path: A Novel TSP Solving Strategy

Topologically Ordered Self Organizing Map for Optimal Allocation of Urban Emergency Mobile Power Supply

A Deep Reinforcement Learning Based Real-Time Solution Policy for the Traveling Salesman Problem

Graph Neural Network Guided Local Search for the Traveling Salesperson Problem

A Novel Grasp Based on Mixed K-Opt Method for the Traveling Salesman Problem

Solving Traveling Salesman Problems Based on Artificial Cooperative Search Algorithm

Simulated Annealing with Probabilistic Neighborhood for Traveling Salesman Problems

A Parallel Ensemble of Metaheuristic Solvers for the Traveling Salesman Problem

Local search for the Traveling Salesman Problem: A comparative study

Self-organized Combinatorial Optimization