Tamara Backhouse,Yun-Hee Jeon,Anne Killett,Jessica Green,Mizanur Khondoker,Eneida Mioshi
Abstract:Abstract Background and objectives Personal care interactions can provide vital opportunities for caregivers to engage with a person living with advanced dementia. However, interactions may also be a contentious experience, what makes this so is not fully understood. We aimed to examine features of personal care interactions between caregivers and people with advanced dementia to understand how care may be improved. Research design and methods This was a naturalistic observation study using one-off video-recorded observations of personal care interactions between fourteen people with advanced dementia and twelve caregivers (n=7 care-home staff, n=5 family carers) in the UK (total observation time 03:01:52). Observations were analysed with observational video coding to determine the frequency of actions of people with dementia and qualitative content analysis for in-depth examination. Results Refusals of care were present in 32% of video sections. Active engagement of people with dementia was observed in 66% of sections. Rare contentious interactional components were characterised by the person with dementia appearing to show uneasiness and caregivers being flustered and uncertain. However, caregivers typically emanated a nurturing attentiveness, were attuned to the person and skilled in seamlessly supporting them through care activities. Discussion and implications Findings draw on real-world empirical evidence to reinvigorate the notion of person-centredness in dementia care. The findings provide much needed insight into practical ways to improve care interactions for people with advanced dementia and enhance their personhood. Appropriate training/guidance for caregivers could support positive personal care experiences for both the person with dementia and caregiver.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of how to improve the quality of care in personal care interactions for patients with advanced dementia, in order to enhance their quality of life and dignity. Specifically, the study aims to understand the characteristics of these interactions by observing personal care interactions between caregivers (including family caregivers and nursing home staff) and patients with advanced dementia, thereby identifying ways to improve care.
### Research Background and Objectives
- **Background**: Patients with advanced dementia often experience severe memory loss, difficulty in movement, communication barriers, and behavioral changes. These symptoms necessitate assistance in daily living activities (such as washing, eating, and toileting). However, these care interactions may sometimes be unwelcome by the patients, even triggering refusal or resistance behaviors, causing stress and distress for both patients and caregivers.
- **Objectives**: The study aims to analyze the specific characteristics of care interactions through natural observation, particularly those components that are successful and controversial, to provide practical recommendations for improving care quality.
### Research Methods
- **Design and Methods**: This is a natural observation study using one-time video recordings to observe personal care interactions between 14 patients with advanced dementia and 12 caregivers (7 nursing home staff and 5 family caregivers), with a total observation time of 3 hours, 1 minute, and 52 seconds. The observation data were processed through video coding and qualitative content analysis.
- **Results**:
- In 32% of the video segments, patients exhibited refusal behaviors towards care.
- In 66% of the video segments, patients actively participated in care activities.
- Caregivers generally showed care and attention, were able to soothe patients, and guided them to complete care activities smoothly.
- Controversial interaction components were fewer, mainly manifesting as patients showing unease, and caregivers appearing flustered and uncertain.
### Discussion and Significance
- **Findings**: The study results provide empirical evidence supporting the patient-centered care philosophy. Through specific interaction methods, caregivers can better communicate and interact with patients with advanced dementia, thereby improving care quality and patients' quality of life.
- **Practical Application**: The study results can be used to develop training resources for caregivers, helping them better meet patients' needs in daily care, reduce conflicts and stress, and enhance the care experience.
### Keywords
- Family caregivers; long-term care; activities of daily living; personality; social care
Overall, the paper provides specific recommendations and practical guidance for improving the quality of care for patients with advanced dementia through empirical research.