On the Nature of Contracts in Online Auctions: Taking the Guiding Case No. 125 As a Reference Chinese Full Text

李学尧
2023-01-01
Abstract:In judicial practice,there are two standards for the coverage of the relevant provisions of the Auction Law,the subject element and the behavior element.The Guiding Case No.125 of the Supreme People’s Court adopted the act requirement theory and established the standard of "trust(auction)relationship" applied to the Auction Law.Although the gist of the judgment of the Guiding Case No.125is mainly aimed at the online judicial auction as a civil coercive measure,the standard of "trust(auction)relationship" has the reference significance of applying to the universal online auction behavior,solving whether it is applicable and how to apply the Auction Law.Even so,there will still be legal loopholes in the field of arbitrary auction-type online auctions,which are difficult to be solved by the interpretative approach:(1) auction contracts,including online auction contracts,are difficult to be included in the category of well-known contracts(such as commission contracts and intermediary contracts) in the Civil Code;(2) The broad provisions of the Electronic Commerce Law on electronic commerce make it difficult to adjust the online auction behavior.Based on the needs of maintaining market order,protecting the rights and interests of the parties and the proportional allocation of compliance responsibilities,we can further refer to the gatekeeper clause in Article 58 of the Personal Information Protection Law in judicial practice,and assign the responsibility of "gatekeeper" of network auction standardization to the relevant network trading platform providers.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?