Creep mechanisms of U720Li disc superalloy at intermediate temperature
Y. Yuan,Y.F. Gu,C.Y. Cui,T. Osada,T. Tetsui,T. Yokokawa,H. Harada
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2011.03.034
2011-01-01
Abstract:Highlights ► Crept microstructures of U720Li at 725 °C/630 MPa have been investigated by TEM. ► Orowan looping process combining dislocation slip and climb and partial dislocations shearing precipitates were the main creep mechanisms. ► Grain boundary sliding occurred at last creep stage. ► Three methods were suggested to improve the creep property at relatively high temperature. Abstract The microstructures of U720Li disc superalloy have been investigated by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) before and after creep test at 725 °C/630 MPa. The evolution of the crept microstructures was marked as three different stages (I, II and III) corresponding to gradually increased strain 0.1%, 5% and 27%, respectively. At stage I, dislocations bypassed secondary γ ′ via Orowan loops. At stage II, partial dislocations started to shear secondary γ ′, leaving stacking fault (SF) behind and microtwins formed in part of grains. At stage III, grain boundary sliding occurred due to very large strain and increased effective stress. The results indicated that the creep mechanisms of U720Li at 725 °C/630 MPa evolved with gradually increased strain. Orowan looping process combining dislocation slip and climb and partial dislocations shearing precipitates were the main creep mechanisms. It is suggested that decreasing the interparticle spacing of secondary γ ′, strengthening secondary γ ′ and decreasing stacking fault energy (SFE) of γ matrix may be effective methods to improve the creep property at relatively higher temperatures. Keywords Ni based superalloy Cast and wrought Creep mechanism Transmission electron microscopy 1 Introduction Ni-based superalloys are important high temperature structural materials for turbine blades and discs. Since the development of aviation industry requires high-efficiency engine and lower emission of CO 2 and NO x , the challenge for Ni-based superalloys is to elevate service temperature and to improve high temperature mechanical properties [1] . Creep resistance is a major concern for disc superalloy due to its service condition. The creep behavior of disc alloys at 650–700 °C has been studied by numerous researchers [2–8] . Udimet 720Li (U720Li) is of great interest for producing turbine discs with large diameter owing to its superior creep strength and industrial maturity. The creep mechanisms of U720Li in the stress/temperature regime 450–900 MPa/650–700 °C has been investigated by several authors [9–11] . Their results indicate that dislocation climb around precipitates is the main creep mechanism at low applied stress and Orowan dislocation bending or precipitates cutting is the dominant mode at high applied stress. However, the creep mechanism of U720Li at temperatures above 700 °C has not been well documented. At National Institute for Materials Science (NIMS), we have been developing new advanced disc superalloy for application at temperatures up to 725 °C. Therefore, to find the inferior aspects of U720Li at relatively higher service temperatures is beneficial to develop new advanced disc superalloys. Disc superalloy consists of γ matrix and dispersed γ ′ precipitates. For a specified alloy, the interaction between dislocations and the γ ′ precipitates during creep may involve three different processes depending on microstructure, temperature and loading [2,4,8,12] , i.e. dislocations bypass the precipitates via Orowan process, cooperative climbing, and shearing process [13,14] . For the last case, the dislocations cutting the precipitates with Burgers vector a /2〈1 1 0〉 ( a is lattice parameter of γ matrix), a /6〈1 1 2〉, a /3〈1 1 2〉 will produce anti-phase boundary (APB), complex stacking fault (CSF), superlattice extrinsic stacking fault (SESF) or superlattice intrinsic stacking fault (SISF) in the γ ′ precipitates, respectively. At intermediate temperature, roughly 650–800 °C, deformation mechanism appears to be more complex, for example, planar slip and fault formation both in the γ ′ precipitates alone and also continuously in both matrix and γ ′ precipitates [15] . Most remarkably, deformation microtwinning in Rene 88DT at low strain or strain rate (790–838 MPa/650 °C) has been reported by several authors [3,15,16] within this intermediate temperature regime. Usually, deformation twins form under high strain or high strain rate at low temperature in the metals or alloys with low SFE. In present work, we have studied the microstructures of U720Li before and after creep test at 725 °C/630 MPa. Based on the experimental observation, we discussed the relevant creep mechanisms and the methods which can be employed to improve the creep property at relatively high temperature. 2 Experiment The detailed process of preparing U720Li alloy ingots can be found elsewhere [17] . The pancake-shaped disc was subjected to the standard heat treatment (1100 °C/4 h/oil quench, then aging at 650 °C/24 h/air cooling +760 °C/16 h/air cooling), then creep sample was machined from the heat-treated disc. Constant load tensile experiment was performed at 725 °C/630 MPa. TEM discs with thickness of around 300 μm were mechanically cut at different positions perpendicular to the stress axis from crept sample. TEM samples at different positions were corresponding to various strains. The discs were manually ground to 50 μm and perforated by twin-jet electro-polisher at 40 V and 0 °C. The electrolyte consisted of 50 ml perchloric acid, 100 ml ethanol and 300 ml 2-butoxyethanol. The microstructures of specimens were investigated using a JEM 4010 TEM operated at 400 kV. 3 Results and discussion 3.1 Creep curve Fig. 1 illustrates the creep curve of U720Li at 725 °C/630 MPa. The curve of Fig. 1 (a) shows a character of secondary and tertiary creep. The interrupted curve, Fig. 1 (b), indicates the primary stage is very short. Most of the creep strain was accumulated during the accelerating creep. The creep time to 0.2% strain was only 1.1 h. Under this deformation condition, the creep life of U720Li was relatively short, less than 40 h. 3.2 Microstructure before creep test The nominal composition of U720Li is listed in Table 1 . Before creep test, U720Li consisted of matrix ( γ phase) and precipitates ( γ ′ phase), shown in Fig. 2 . The secondary γ ′ precipitates with uniform size around 100 nm can be observed in TEM dark field image Fig. 2 (b). Also very fine tertiary γ ′ precipitates are present in Fig. 2 (b), as indicated by the arrows. According to our previous results [18] , U720Li has grain size of about 10 μm and 45% volume fraction of γ ′ precipitates. 3.3 Microstructure after creep test The evolution of the crept microstructures was studied by selecting specimens at different positions along stress axis. After TEM investigation of the crept microstructures, we marked three typical stages with distinctive character, named stage I, II and III, corresponding to the gradually increased strain 0.1%, 5% and 27%, respectively. The creep strain was estimated from the reduction of cross section area with respect to the original value before creep. At stage I, the activities of the matrix perfect dislocation with Burgers vector of a /2〈1 1 0〉 were dominant, as seen in Fig. 3 (a) . The sinuous shape of the matrix dislocations is typical character of slip and climb combination around the secondary γ ′ precipitates. Lots of dislocation looping process can be observed in Fig. 3 (b), the dislocations proceeded by Orowan looping process and left the loops around the precipitates, as indicated by the white arrows. The Orowan bowing stress τ can be estimated by Gb / L . Here, G is shear modulus, b is Burgers vector, L is average spacing of secondary γ ′ precipitates, which is measured to be roughly 45 nm in Fig. 2 (b). By substituting G = 69.5 GPa, b = 0.25 nm, τ is calculated to be 386 MPa. This stress level is comparable with the applied stress 630 MPa considering the effect of Schmid factor. The easy motion of matrix perfect dislocations associated with large strain. So Orowan looping mechanism combining slip and climb processes may be responsible for the fast creep rate. Orowan-type mechanism have been observed during creep of Udimet 720 at 650 °C/750 MPa [2] , Rene 88 DT at 650 °C/972 MPa [3] , Rene 95 at 650 °C/850 MPa [4] and NR3 at 700 °C/700 MPa [5] . Compared our creep test condition 725 °C/630 MPa with these references, the temperature is higher whereas the stress is lower. The lower stress may be balanced by the elevated temperature. The results of tensile tests showed that the yield stress of U720Li decreased from 1054 MPa at 650 °C to 981 MPa at 725 °C. The stress of dislocation nucleation and propagation decreases with increasing temperature. Primary γ ′ was mainly sheared by partial dislocation, leaving SF behind, as shown in Fig. 3 (c). Fig. 3 (d) is image under two-beam condition, the ( 0 2 − 0 ) operating vector points toward the dark fringe of SF in DF image and outmost dark fringes are present in BF image. Diffraction condition is insetted at top right. According to the rule used to determine the character of SF [19] , the nature of SF in γ ′ phase is extrinsic. Single matrix dislocation a /2〈1 1 0〉 cutting the γ ′ precipitates will create APB of high energy. The a /2〈1 1 0〉 dislocation could dissociate into a /6〈1 1 2〉 and a /3〈1 1 2〉 partial dislocations. The latter then sheared the γ ′ precipitate and created a SESF within the γ ′ precipitate [20] . The primary γ ′ precipitate had large size, shearing by SESF is energetically favorable than that by APB cutting. Another interesting point is extrinsic SF observed in tension. It has been demonstrated that the applied stresses will favor SISF formation in tension and SESF formation in compression when the single crystal superalloy testing along [0 0 1] [21] . Obviously, it is not true in polycrystalline disc alloy. At stage II, numerous isolated SFs were observed besides the sinuous dislocations, as shown in Fig. 4 . The different feature at this stage was that partial dislocations started to shear the secondary γ ′, leaving SFs behind. There are two factors that affect dislocation dissociation at γ /secondary γ ′ interface. First, the interaction of dislocations became stronger due to increased dislocation density. Secondly, the effective applied stress increased due to reduction of cross section area. The partial dislocation shearing process of secondary and primary γ ′ may be similar. In some grains, as shown in Fig. 5 , deformation microtwins crossing over the grain were observed. The phenomenon of microtwins formed only in part of grains indicates the crystallographic orientation has important influence on twinning process [22] . For most of cases, microtwinning took place on one primary {1 1 1} plane. At stage III, the dislocation density in U720Li was very high, as seen in Fig. 6 (a). The dark field TEM image illustrates lots of partial dislocations shearing secondary γ ′precipitate. The SFs had developed on two different {1 1 1} slip planes. As strain continued to increase, more and more secondary γ ′ precipitates were sheared by partial dislocations. Numerous shearing processes accelerated creep rate and shortened the total creep life. Note that, in Fig. 6 (b), the twinning plane shown by dash line was not straight but distorted, which indicates that grain boundary sliding occurred at tertiary creep stage. 3.4 Deformation mechanisms during creep Our observation demonstrated that the creep mechanisms of U720Li at 725 °C/630 MPa evolved with gradually increased strain. Orowan process combining slip and climb of a /2〈1 1 0〉 matrix dislocation was dominant mechanism at initial stage, which is the typical character of power law creep. When the dislocation density was low, single a /2〈1 1 0〉 matrix dislocations did not penetrate secondary γ ′ but looping around it via Orowan process. Due to the high APB energy, cutting the γ ′ particle by perfect dislocation is more difficult than shearing by partial dislocation. As strain increased, the interaction of dislocations became stronger due to high density of dislocations and the increased effective stress. So, the matrix dislocations could dissociate at the γ /secondary γ ′ precipitate interface, then the dissociated a /3〈1 1 2〉 partial dislocations sheared the secondary γ ′ precipitates. According to the model proposed by Kozar et al. [23] , increasing APB and volume fraction of tertiary γ ′ can enhance the yield strength. It has also been reported that increased volume fraction of tertiary γ ′ can cause the transition of creep mechanism from isolated faulting to microtwinning [3] . From already reported results, APB energy and volume fraction of tertiary γ ′ are closely associated with different creep mechanisms. In our experiments, the Orowan bowing and shearing of secondary γ ′ were observed. However, the interaction of dislocation with tertiary γ ′ was not clearly observed due to the complex contrast. So the contribution of tertiary γ ′ to creep strength is still unknown. Our investigation indicates that at least two methods can be used to improve the creep life of steady state. One is decreasing the interparticle spacing of secondary γ ′, another is strengthening secondary γ ′, for example, increasing APB energy by controlling chemical composition. The former will increase the Orowan bowing stress, the latter will increase the critical resolved shear stress to drive the dislocation that shears secondary γ ′. Jackson and Reed [12] believe the ‘standard’ heat treatment leaves U720Li in the overaged condition, so improvement of heat treatment may optimize the distribution of γ ′ precipitates and enhance the creep resistance at higher temperature. As strain continued to increase, the deformation microtwins formed in part of grains and mainly on one primary {1 1 1} plane. The interaction of the dislocations as well as the dislocations with grain boundary increased dramatically, the stress concentration occurred and resulted in the local deformation twinning. At later deformation stage, grain boundary sliding took place due to very large strain and increased effective stress. Compared with already reported creep mechanism of U720Li in references [9–11] , partial dislocation shearing secondary γ ′ precipitates is significantly different. This creep mechanism is closely associated with deformation temperature. Since stage I and II account for most of the creep time, so we believe Orowan looping process combining dislocation slip and climb and partial dislocations shearing precipitates were the main creep mechanisms at 725 °C/630 MPa. 3.5 SFE of the γ matrix SFE is an important factor that affects the dissociation of the perfect dislocation. With the simulation of microscopic phase field [24] , the perfect matrix dislocation a /2〈1 1 0〉 does not dissociate into Shockley partials as the SFE of matrix increase from 10 to 100 mJ/m 2 . High resolution TEM method was employed to determine the SFE of the γ matrix in U720Li. The details can be found in our another manuscript [25] . The average SFE of γ matrix in U720Li was 35.9 ± 3.7 mJ/m 2 . It has been reported that the SFE of the γ matrix in superalloys ranges from 20 to 30 mJ/m 2 [26,27] . Apparently, the γ SFE of U720Li is relatively higher. It means the matrix dislocation is difficult to split into partial dislocation, which is consistent with the existence of numerous perfect dislocations observed in the matrix. The relatively higher SFE also facilitated the cross-slip of dislocations rather than planar slip. For lower SFE, the perfect matrix dislocation may be easier to dissociate into Shockley partials. One Shockley partial dislocation cutting through the γ ′ precipitate will cause the formation of CSF with high energy, and then high applied stress is needed to move the Shockley partial dislocation. Another case is two closely packed Shockley partial dislocations on adjacent {1 1 1} plane penetrating the γ ′ precipitate, then the reordering process occurs in order to restore the L1 2 structure [28] . The reordering process needs the assistance of vacancy diffusion, which is a thermally activated process. These two mechanisms may reduce the creep rate. So decreasing the SFE of γ matrix may be another important method to improve the creep property. 4 Conclusion The creep test of commercial disc superalloys U720Li was conducted at 725 °C/630 MPa. U720Li consists of γ matrix and γ ′ precipitates before creep test. After investigation of the crept samples, the microstructures were marked as three different stages (I, II and III) corresponding to gradually increased strain 0.1%, 5% and 27%, respectively. The creep mechanisms of U720Li at 725 °C/630 MPa evolved with gradually increased strain. At stage I, Orowan process combining slip and climb of a /2〈1 1 0〉 matrix dislocation was dominant mechanism, which is the typical character of power law creep. Dislocations bypassed secondary γ ′ via Orowan loops. At stage II, partial dislocations started to shear secondary γ ′ and microtwins formed in part of grains. At stage III, grain boundary sliding occured due to very large strain and increased effective stress. Orowan looping process combining dislocation slip and climb and partial dislocations shearing precipitates were the main creep mechanisms for U720Li at 725 °C/630 MPa. Decreasing the interparticle spacing of secondary γ ′, strengthening secondary γ ′ and decreasing the SFE of γ matrix may be effective methods to improve the creep property at relatively higher temperature. Acknowledgements The authors thank Prof. L.C. Qin at University of North Carolina, USA., for discussion and help to conduct high resolution TEM experiments. Y. Yuan is indebted to Dr. T. Nagai and Dr. K. Ogawa for the lecture of JEM 2100F and JEM 4010 at National Institute for Materials Science, Japan. References [1] J.Y. Guédou I. Augustins-Lecallier L. Nazé P. Caron D. Locq Roger C. Reed Kenneth A. Green Pierre Caron Timothy P. Gabb Michael G. Fahrmann Eric S. Huron Shiela A. Woodard Superalloys 2008 Warrendale Pennsylvania, U.S.A 21 30 [2] S.D. Goff R. Couturier L. Guétaz H. Burlet Mater. Sci. Eng. A 387–389 2004 599 603 [3] G.B. Viswanathan P.M. Sarosi M.F. Henry D.D. Whitis W.W. Milligan M.J. Mills Acta Mater. 53 2005 3041 3057 [4] P.R. Bhowal E.F. Wright E.L. Raymond Metall. Trans. A 21 1990 1709 1717 [5] D. Locq M. Marty Caron P T.M. Pollock R.D. Kissinger R.R. Bowman K.A. Green M. Mclean S. Olson J.J. Schirra Superalloys 2000 Seven Springs PA, USA 395 403 [6] S. Tian J. Xie X.M. Zhou B.J. Qian J.W. Lun L.L. Yu W.X. Wang Mater. Sci. Eng. A 528 2011 2076 2084 [7] S. Raujol F. Pettinari D. Locq P. Caron A. Coujou N. Clément Mater. Sci. Eng. A 387–389 2004 678 682 [8] D. Locq P. Caron S. Rajoul F. Pettinari-Sturmel A. Coujou N. Clement K.A. Green T.M. Pollock H. Harada T.E. Howson R.C. Reed J.J. Schirra S. Walston Superalloys 2004 Seven Springs PA, U.S.A. 179 187 [9] A.R.S. Ponter H. Chen M.R. Willis W.J. Evans Fatigue Fract. Eng. Mater. Struct. 27 2004 305 318 [10] X. Xiao L.Z. Zhou J.T. Guo Acta Metall. Sin. 37 2001 1159 1164 [11] V. Lupinc M. Maldini L.Z. Zhou J.T. Guo Acta Metall. Sin. 18 2005 65 73 [12] M.P. Jackson R.C. Reed Mater. Sci. Eng. A 259 1999 85 97 [13] A.J. Huis in’t veld G. Boom P.M. Bronsveld J. Th. M. De Hosson Scripta Metall. 19 1985 1123 1128 [14] E. Nembach G. Neite Prog. Mater. Sci. 29 1985 177 319 [15] G.B. Viswanathan S. Karthikeyan P.M. Sarosi R.R. Unocic M.J. Mills Phil. Mag. 86 2006 4823 4840 [16] R.R. Unocic G.B. Viswanathan P.M. Sarosi S. Karthikeyan J. Lia M.J. Mills Mater. Sci. Eng. A 483–484 2008 25 32 [17] Y.F. Gu T. Fukuda C. Cui H. Harada A. Mitsuhashi T. Yokokawa J. Fujioka Y. Koizumi T. Kobayashi Metall. Mater. Trans. A 40 2009 3047 3050 [18] Y.F. Gu C. Cui H. Harada T. Fukuda D. Ping A. Mitsuhashi K. Kato T. Kobayashi J. Fujioka Roger C. Reed Kenneth A. Green Pierre Caron Timothy P. Gabb Michael G. Fahrmann Eric S. Huron Shiela A. Woodard Superalloys 2008 Warrendale Pennsylvania, U.S.A 53 61 [19] J. Van Landuyt R. Gevers S. Amelinckx Phys. Stat. Sol. 18 1966 167 172 [20] Y.H. Zhang Q.Z. Chen D.M. Knowles Mater. Sci. Technol. 17 2001 1551 1555 [21] D.M. Knowles Q.Z. Chen Mater. Sci. Eng. A 340 2003 88 102 [22] W.Z. Han Z.F. Zhang S.D. Wu S.X. Li Phil. Mag. 88 2008 3011 3029 [23] R.W. Kozar A. Suzuki W.W. Milligan J.J. Schirra M.F. Savage T.M. Pollock Metall. Mater. Trans. A 40 2009 1588 1603 [24] R. Unocic L. Kovarik C. Shen Sarosi S Y Wang J. Li S. Ghosh M. Mills Roger C. Reed Kenneth A. Green Pierre Caron Timothy P. Gabb Michael G. Fahrmann Eric S. Huron Shiela A. Woodard Superalloys 2008 Warrendale Pennsylvania, U.S.A. 377 385 [25] Y. Yuan, Y.F. Gu, C.Y. Cui, T. Osada, T. Yokokawa, Y. Koizumi, H. Harada, J. Mater. Res., under revision. [26] F. Diologent P. Caron Mater. Sci. Eng. A 385 2004 245 257 [27] S. Ma L. Carroll T.M. Pollock Acta Mater. 55 2007 5802 5812 [28] L. Kovarik R.R. Unocic J. Li P. Sarosi C. Shen Y. Wang M.J. Mills Prog. Mater. Sci. 54 2009 839 873