Abstract:The geometric optimisation of crystal structures is a procedure widely used in Chemistry that changes the geometrical placement of the particles inside a structure. It is called structural relaxation and constitutes a local minimization problem with a non-convex objective function whose domain complexity increases along with the number of particles involved. In this work we study the performance of the two most popular first order optimisation methods, Gradient Descent and Conjugate Gradient, in structural relaxation. The respective pseudocodes can be found in Section 6. Although frequently employed, there is a lack of their study in this context from an algorithmic point of view. In order to accurately define the problem, we provide a thorough derivation of all necessary formulae related to the crystal structure energy function and the function's differentiation. We run each algorithm in combination with a constant step size, which provides a benchmark for the methods' analysis and direct comparison. We also design dynamic step size rules and study how these improve the two algorithms' performance. Our results show that there is a trade-off between convergence rate and the possibility of an experiment to succeed, hence we construct a function to assign utility to each method based on our respective preference. The function is built according to a recently introduced model of preference indication concerning algorithms with deadline and their run time. Finally, building on all our insights from the experimental results, we provide algorithmic recipes that best correspond to each of the presented preferences and select one recipe as the optimal for equally weighted preferences.

Global optimization in the discrete and variable-dimension conformational space: The case of crystal with the strongest atomic cohesion

Crystal structure prediction by combining graph network and optimization algorithm

Prediction of Two‐dimensional Materials by the Global Optimization Approach

Optimization of Coulomb Energies in Gigantic Configurational Spaces of Multi-Element Ionic Crystals

Optimality guarantees for crystal structure prediction

Crystal structure prediction by combining graph network and Bayesian optimization

Effective optimization of atomic decoration in giant and superstructurally ordered crystals with machine learning

Contact map based crystal structure prediction using global optimization

Crystal structure prediction via combining graph network and Bayesian optimization

Adaptive Constraint Integration for Simultaneously Optimizing Crystal Structures with Multiple Targeted Properties

Bayesian optimization of atomic structures with prior probabilities from universal interatomic potentials

Latent Conservative Objective Models for Data-Driven Crystal Structure Prediction

Mathematical Crystal Chemistry

Enhancing crystal structure prediction by combining computational and experimental data via graph networks

Large-scale machine-learning-assisted exploration of the whole materials space

Accelerating crystal structure search through active learning with neural networks for rapid relaxations

First Order Methods for Geometric Optimization of Crystal Structures

Atomic Structure Optimization with Machine-Learning Enabled Interpolation between Chemical Elements

Quantitative Chemistry and the Discrete Geometry of Conformal Atom-Thin Crystals

Crystal-LSBO: Automated Design of De Novo Crystals with Latent Space Bayesian Optimization

Predicting Molecular Ground-State Conformation via Conformation Optimization