Comparison Between Double- and Single-bundle Arthroscopic Anterior Cructiate Ligament Reconstruction Using Bonepatellar Tendon-bone Allograft
Jiang Dong,Ao Yingfang,Xie Xing,江东,敖英芳,谢兴,龚熹,陈连旭,罗浩,王永健,余家阔,于长隆,王健全,崔国庆,胡跃林,田得祥
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-6604.2011.12.011
2011-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the mid-term clinical results of arthroscopic double-bundle anterior cruciate ligament(ACL) reconstruction with bone-patellar tendon-bone(BPTB) allograft.Methods The study was carried on 61 patients with broken ACL,who received arthroscopic ACL reconstruction by using BPTB between July 2003 and July 2007.According to the operation and graft types,the patients were divided into 3 groups: BPTB double-bundle allograft group(20 patients),BPTB single-bundle allograft group(21 patients),and BPTB single-bundle autograft group(20 patients).Median follow-up were(41.6±3.0),(42.3±3.9),and(42.5±2.7) months respectively in the 3 groups.At the follow-up,the clinical outcome of the patients was evaluated by assessing the International Knee Documentation Committee(IKDC) 2000 subjective scores,Lysholm scores,Tegner scores,anterior knee pain,routine KT-2000 and back-pushing KT-2000 side-to-side difference,thigh circumference difference and Biodex isokinetic dynamometer system.Results No significant difference was found in terms of the IKDC2000 scores,Lysholm scores,Tegner scores,thigh circumference difference,muscle strength and routine KT-2000 side-to-side difference(P>0.05).The Pivot-shift positive rate(5%,1/20) of the BPTB double-bundle allograft group was 1/6 of that of the BPTB single-bundle allograft group(29%,6/21) and 1/4 of that of the BPTB single-bundle autograft group(20%,4/20).Compared to the single-bundle groups,significant less back-pushing KT-2000 anterior laxity at 30°(median: 15 dl-0.5 mm,20 dl-0.5 mm,and 30 dl-0.9 mm) was revealed in the BPTB double-bundle allograft group(P<0.05).The BPTB double-bundle allograft group(15%,3/20) and the BPTB single-bundle allograft group(10%,2/21) showed significant less anterior knee pain than that of the BPTB single-bundle autograft group(75%,15/20,χ2=24.201,P=0.000).Conclusions The double-bundle ACL reconstruction with BPTB allograft showed better total A-P stability,rotatory stability and less donor site morbidity.It is an alternative of primary doubule-bundle ACL reconstruction for the patients with wider intercondylar fossa.