The Double-Edged Sword Effect of Illegitimate Tasks on Employee Creativity: Positive and Negative Coping Perspectives
Xinwen He,Yunjian Zheng,Ye Wei
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/prbm.s444960
IF: 3.974
2024-02-14
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Xinwen He, 1 Yunjian Zheng, 1 Ye Wei 2 1 School of Management, Minzu University of China, Beijing, People's Republic of China; 2 School of Economics and Management, Guangxi University of Science and Technology, Liuzhou, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Yunjian Zheng, School of Management, Minzu University of China, 27 Zhongguancun South Street, Haidian District, Beijing, 100081, People's Republic of China, Tel +86 15857086287, Email Purpose: The purpose of our study is to explore how employees respond to illegitimate tasks and the impact it will have on employee creativity, as well as to explore the important boundary conditions for weakening the negative impact of illegitimate tasks and enhancing its positive impact. Methods: We collected 271 pairs of employee-supervisor valid matching data through three rounds of surveys, and conducted statistical analysis and hypothesis testing using SPSS 26.0 and AMOS 24.0 statistical analysis tools. Results: The results show that both job crafting and work withdrawal play a mediating role between illegitimate tasks and employee creativity, and the negative mediating role of work withdrawal is stronger than the positive mediating role of job crafting; supervisor developmental feedback not only positively moderates the relationship between illegitimate tasks and job crafting but also enhances the positive mediating role of job crafting; supervisor developmental feedback not only negatively moderates the link between illegitimate tasks and work withdrawal but also weakens the negative mediating role of work withdrawal. Conclusion: Drawing on Conservation of Resources theory and Stress-as-Offense-to-Self theory, we reveal that employees will adopt job crafting and work withdrawal in response to illegitimate tasks from positive and negative coping perspectives and how it will positively and negatively affect employee creativity, respectively. Meanwhile, we find that supervisor developmental feedback is a boundary condition for reducing the negative impact of illegitimate tasks and promoting their positive impact. In addition, we provide implications for organizations to weigh the pros and cons of illegitimate tasks and improve employee creativity. Keywords: illegitimate tasks, job crafting, work withdrawal, supervisor developmental feedback, employee creativity In the era of VUCA (Volatile, Uncertain, Complex and Ambiguous), innovation has become a practical choice for enterprises seeking to expand their competitive edge. Employee creativity, as a fundamental source of innovation, permeates various aspects such as product development, market services, and process innovation, and is a crucial force in achieving corporate goals and maintaining competitive advantages. 1,2 Consequently, identifying the key factors that influence and enhance employee creativity has become a focus of attention in both academia and industry. While existing research has highlighted positive factors such as positive leadership style, 3 proactive personality, 1 and innovative organizational climate 4 are positive drivers that enhance employee creativity, there has been relatively limited exploration on how employees cope with negative factors within the organization and the impact of these negative factors on employee creativity. Therefore, it is particularly necessary to start with negative contextual factors, such as illegitimate tasks, and explore their impact mechanisms on employee creativity. Illegitimate tasks are those that violate the reasonable expectations of employees. 5 According to a survey by Semmer et al, approximately 30% of the task lists provided by 159 respondents were considered illegitimate tasks. 5 The survey results of Zhao et al also indicate that Chinese employees experience illegitimate tasks. 6 Thus, illegitimate tasks are a common phenomenon in organizations, and scholars have gradually become aware of its existence. They have begun to explore how employees respond to illegitimate tasks and the impact it will have on employee behavior. Existing research often views illegitimate tasks as a hindrance stressor, suggesting that employees may adopt negative strategies to cope with illegitimate tasks, thereby positively affecting their work-family conflict, 7,8 counterproductive work behavior, 6 and job burnout, 9 while negatively affecting their well-being, 10 service performance, 11 and innovative behavior. 12 However, do employees necessarily respond negatively to illegitimate tasks? Regarding the above question, some scholars argue that current research has overlooked the potential bright side of illeg -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary