Comparative analysis of perimembranous and high ventricular septal defects closure via an ultra-minimal trans-intercostal incision guided by transesophageal echocardiography in children
傅行鹏,叶菁菁,俞劲,张泽伟,尤海容,谈林华
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.cn101785-202212030-003
2023-01-01
Abstract:Objective:To explore the characteristics and prognoses of perimembranous and high ventricular septal defects (VSD) closure via a ultra-minimal trans-intercostal incision (i.e.left parasternal intercostal ultra-minimal incision≤1 cm) in children guided by transesophageal echocardiography (TEE) and provide references for such mini-invasive surgery.Methods:From January 2015 to December 2021, 344 cases of VSD closure via a left parasternal ultra-minimal trans-intercostal incision in children guided by TEE.According to the location of VSD, they were divided into two groups of perimembranous VSD (239/344, 69.5%) and high VSD (outflow tract & high membrane)(105/344, 30.5%). Operative procedures, operative duration, postoperative complications, prognoses and other relevant data of two groups were compared.Results:Among them, 229 cases (229/239, 95.8%) of perimembranous VSD and 100 cases (100/105, 95.2%) of high VSD were successfully occluded.No significant difference existed in success rate ( P>0.05). However, operative duration of perimembranous VSD was longer than that of high VSD ( P<0.05). In both groups, diameter of VSD was correlated positively with diameter of occluder, but not with operative duration.Among 239 cases of perimembranous VSD and 105 cases of high VSD, 12 cases (12/239, 5.0%) and 5 cases (5/105, 4.8%) were successfully re-occluded after adjusting or replacing occluder.No significant inter-group difference existed in success rate of re-occlusion ( P>0.05). A total of 10 children in perimembranous VSD group failed to occlude, including 7 cases (7/239, 2.9%) in which guide wire could not pass through VSD, 2 cases (2/239, 0.8%) in which occluder slipped off and 1 case of ventricular fibrillation.There were 5 cases of occlusion failure in high VSD group, including 1 case in which guide wire could not pass through VSD during operation (1/105, 1.0%), 1 case with occluder displacement during operation and 1 case post-operation (2/105, 1.9%), 1 case with aggravation of aortic regurgitation and 1 case with marked decrease in blood pressure.There was no significant inter-group difference in failure rate when guide wire could not pass through VSD and occluder slipped off or shifted( P>0.05). During a follow-up period of (1-4) days in perimembranous VSD group, there were 1 case of mild mitral regurgitation and 4 cases of mild-to-moderate tricuspid regurgitation.No change occurred during 6-month follow-ups.During a follow-up period of (1-4) days in high VSD group, one case developed right ventricular outflow tract obstruction and flow velocity declined during 6-month follow-ups.There were residual slight shunt ( n=19), pericardial effusion ( n=19) and pleural effusion ( n=4) in two groups.They were self-cured during 6-month follow-ups. Conclusion:Through a ultra-minimal trans-intercostal incision guided by TEE, perimembranous and high VSD closure offers a high success rate and an excellent postoperative recovery in children.Although operative duration of high VSD is shorter, diameter of VSD is not a sole influencing factor of operative duration.