What defines the "value" of robotic surgery for patients with gastrointestinal cancers? Perspectives from a U.S. Cancer Center

Naruhiko Ikoma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/ags3.12792

2024-03-22

Annals of Gastroenterological Surgery

Abstract:Robotic surgery has rapidly gained traction in treating gastrointestinal cancers due to its advanced technology and minimally invasive approach; yet evidence of its superiority over traditional methods remains limited. To demonstrate the patient‐centric value of robotic surgery for cancer operations, surgeons and researchers should prioritize factors such as maintaining or improving oncological quality, promoting quicker functional recovery, reducing opioid use, and enhancing quality of life post‐surgery. This article provides a comprehensive overview of the health economics and value‐based care considerations in the context of robotic surgery for gastrointestinal cancers. The use of robotic surgery has experienced rapid growth across diverse medical conditions, with a notable emphasis on gastrointestinal cancers. The advanced technologies incorporated into robotic surgery platforms have played a pivotal role in enabling the safe performance of complex procedures, including gastrectomy and pancreatectomy, through a minimally invasive approach. However, there exists a noteworthy gap in high‐level evidence demonstrating that robotic surgery for gastric and pancreatic cancers has substantial benefits compared to traditional open or laparoscopic methods. The primary impediment hindering the broader implementation of robotic surgery is its cost. The escalating healthcare expenses in the United States have prompted healthcare providers and payors to explore patient‐centered, value‐based healthcare models and reimbursement systems that embrace cost‐effectiveness. Thus, it is important to determine what defines the value of robotic surgery. It must either maintain or enhance oncological quality and improve complication rates compared to open procedures. Moreover, its true value should be apparent in patients' expedited recovery and improved quality of life. Another essential aspect of robotic surgery's value lies in minimizing or even eliminating opioid use, even after major operations, offering considerable benefits to the broader public health landscape. A quicker return to oncological therapy has the potential to improve overall oncological outcomes, while a speedier return to work not only alleviates individual financial distress but also positively impacts societal productivity. In this article, we comprehensively review and summarize the current landscape of health economics and value‐based care, with a focus on robotic surgery for gastrointestinal cancers.

gastroenterology & hepatology