Abstract:Growth-induced surface wrinkling in constrained bilayers comprising a thin film attached to a thick substrate is a canonical model for understanding pattern formation in many biological systems. While the bilayer model has received much prior attention, the nonlinear behaviour for arrangements with similar film and substrate properties, or substrate growth that outpaces film growth, remains poorly understood. This paper therefore focuses on these cases in which the substrate's elasticity dominates surface wrinkling. By combining analytical modelling and finite element simulations incorporating advanced path-following techniques, we characterise critical wrinkling states and explore the initial and advanced post-buckling behaviour for a wide range of film-to-substrate modulus and growth rate ratios. It is shown that the classical leading-order asymptotic expression for the critical strain is not of sufficient accuracy for film-to-substrate modulus ratios below 50, and higher order correction terms are presented. Leveraging a weakly nonlinear analytical model, we introduce a phase diagram categorising stable and unstable post-buckling regimes. Advanced path-following simulations are employed to unveil the evolution of wrinkling patterns, from initial sinusoidal instabilities to complex formations involving period doubling, quadrupling, and eventual surface creasing. These comprehensive phase diagrams, parameterised by film-to-substrate modulus and growth rate ratios, provide new insights into the rich dynamics of surface wrinkling. Finally, we demonstrate the existence of multi-stability in the advanced post-buckling regimes for bilayers experiencing substrate-dominated growth. This work contributes to the understanding of the mechanics underlying pattern formation in growing bilayers over the entire parameter regime, with potential implications for explaining biological morphogenesis and informing the development of novel diagnostic tools and artificial flexible electronic skins.

First-order and Second-Order Wrinkling of Thin Elastic Film Laminated on a Graded Substrate

Theoretical Predictions and Evolutions of Wrinkles in the Film-Intermediate Layer-Substrate Structure under Compression

Numerical Analysis on the Wrinkling Instability of a Stiff Film Adhering to an Elastic Substrate with a Graded Coating

Wrinkling Behavior of Variable Thickness Films Bonded to Elastic Substrates

Surface Wrinkling of an Elastic Graded Layer.

Wrinkling of Thin Films on a Microstructured Substrate

Generation of Buckling and Wrinkling in Elastic Films: the Effect of Initial Imperfection.

Computer Simulation of Thin Film Wrinkling on Elastic Substrate

Mechanism of Surface Wrinkle Modulation for a Stiff Film on Compliant Substrate

Buckling and Post-Buckling of A Stiff Film Resting on an Elastic Graded Substrate

Surface wrinkling of a film coated to a graded substrate

Surface effects on the wrinkles in a stiff thin film bonded to a compliant substrate

Wrinkling of differentially growing bilayers with similar film and substrate moduli

Mechanism of Three-Dimensional Surface Wrinkle Manipulation on a Compliant Substrate

Surface Wrinkling Patterns of Film–Substrate Systems with a Structured Interface

Buckling-driven Periodic Wrinkle Patterns in a Film-Lattice Structure

Nonlinear Analysis of Compressed Elastic Thin Films on Elastic Substrates: from Wrinkling to Buckle-Delamination

Design of Strain-Limiting Substrate Materials for Stretchable and Flexible Electronics

Buckling behaviour of a stiff thin film on a finite-thickness bi-layer substrate

Effects of substrate nonlinear deformation on the wrinkling pattern transition in hyperelastic bilayer systems †

Wrinkling of structured thin films via contrasted materials.