The Early Warning Mechanism of Public Health Emergencies Through Whistleblowing: A Perspective Based on Considering the Uncertainty of Risk Perception
Ruining Ma,Jida Liu,Shi An
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/RMHP.S400251
2023-03-31
Risk Management and Healthcare Policy
Abstract:Ruining Ma, &ast Jida Liu, &ast Shi An School of Management, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin, People's Republic of China &astThese authors contributed equally to this work Correspondence: Jida Liu, School of Management, Harbin Institute of Technology, No. 92 West Dazhi Street, Nangang District, Harbin, 150001, People's Republic of China, Email Purpose: During the early warning period of public health emergencies, the information released by whistleblowers on the risk posed by the given event can reduce uncertainty in the public's risk perception and help governments take timely actions to contain the large-scale dissemination of risk. The purpose of this study is to give full play to whistleblowers and draw attention to the risk events, forming a pluralistic model of the risk governance during the early warning period of public health emergencies. Methods: We construct an evolutionary game model of the early warning of public health emergencies through whistleblowing that involves the government, whistleblowers, and the public, discussing the mechanism of interaction between these subjects under the uncertainty of risk perception. Furthermore, we use numerical simulations to analyze the influence of changes in the relevant parameters on the evolutionary trajectory of the subjects' behaviors. Results: The results of the research are obtained by numerical simulation of the evolutionary game model. The results show that the public's cooperation with the government encourages the latter to take a positive guidance strategy. Increasing the reward for whistleblowers within an acceptable cost, strengthening the propaganda of the mechanism and the higher level of risk perception of the government and whistleblowers will promote whistleblowers' vocalization actively. When the government's reward for whistleblowers is lower, the whistleblowers choose negative vocalization with the improvement of the public's risk perception. If there is no mandatory guidance from the government at this point, the public is prone to passively cooperating with the government owing to a lack of risk-related information. Conclusion: Establishing an early warning mechanism through whistleblowing is important for containing risk in the early warning period of public health emergencies. Building the whistleblowing mechanism in daily work can improve the effectiveness of the mechanism and enhance the public's risk perception better when the public health emergencies arise. Keywords: public health emergencies, early warning through whistleblowing, risk prevention, uncertainty in perception, evolutionary game Such public health emergencies as SARS, Influenza A, MERS, and Ebola virus disease have broken out frequently in the 21st century. They pose a significant threat to public health and safety and present a daunting challenge to national governance and social resilience. 1–3 COVID-19, which emerged in late 2019 and spread rapidly across the globe, has been recognized as a "Public Health Emergency of International Concern" by the World Health Organization. 4–6 In response to the sudden public health crisis, the Chinese government made quick decisions and enacted measures, including emergency lockdowns, the establishment of makeshift hospitals, the timely dissemination of information about the pandemic, instructions to the public to take effective preventive measures, and mandatory public vaccination. These measures significantly helped contain the spread of the pandemic in China. 7,8 The government's attitude during the early warning period of a public health crisis and the public's behavioral choices when exposed to risk are important to the development of the crisis for the future. Both play a decisive role in mitigating losses and preventing crises from evolving. Uncertainty, vagueness, dynamics, complexity, and derivatization are common features of public health emergencies. People do not have access to a sufficient amount of information during the early warning period, where which makes it difficult for them to accurately assess the risk at hand and adopt appropriate preventive actions. This can have far-reaching negative impacts on social stability, the ecological environment, and citizens' health. 9 In addition to relying on accurate surveillance-based information, risk assessment for public health emergencies should consider the basic pattern of development of an epidemic under specific conditions. In particular, the exchange of knowledge among subjects while giving full play to the technical advantages offered by experts is important. Whistleblowers, such as frontline healthcare staff, can help improve the public perception of risk and encourage people to take -Abstract Truncated-
health care sciences & services,health policy & services