Abstract:We consider a model for the resilience analysis of interconnected critical infrastructures (ICIs) that describes the dependencies among the subsystems within the ICIs and their time-varying behavior. The model response is a function of uncertain inputs comprising ICIs design parameters and failure magnitudes of vulnerable elements in the system, etc. In this methodological paper, we present a systematic approach based on an innovative blend of methods to perform a sensitivity analysis for identifying the most relevant variables affecting the system resilience at different stages, during a disruptive event. The methods considered include the following: the use of the graphical representation of Cusunoro curves for a visualization of the impact of an input on the resilience metric and an understanding of whether the associated dependence is monotonic, increasing, or decreasing; the introduction of an ensemble of indicators related to different properties of the resilience metric to allow the prioritization of variable importance and avoid false negatives, meaning to regard a variable as non-influential when, instead, it plays a relevant role in the determination of the model response; the calculation of first-order variance-based sensitivity indices to have an appreciation on the relevance of interactions when inputs are independent; and a data approach to visually identify relevant second-order interactions. All the sensitivity methods considered are performed on a provided sample, and do not require additional model evaluations. They allow the analyst to post-process the data to extract, simultaneously, several desirable insights. The systematic approach proposed to apply these methods allows us to identify the model input variables and parameters that are not very relevant, while it enables the identification of the relevant ones which allows prioritizing interventions on the vulnerable elements of the system for its resilience at different stages during a disruptive event. Given the methodological nature of the work, a simplified infrastructure model describing an interconnected gas network and electric power grid is taken as case study: this allows us to show that the approach is straightforward to understand and implement, and the results obtained show the usefulness of the approach in providing meaningful insights that can be used by stakeholders and decision makers to inform strategies for the improvement of system resilience. By the application of the simplified ICIs model to the case study, it is shown that the approach can be straightforwardly implemented to identify the most relevant variables on system resilience and obtain the most important subsystems. The key factors which affect system resilience in multiple initial failures scenarios are found; this allows us to identify the key resilience improvement measurements, and their priorities.

The human factor in the disaster resilience modeling of critical infrastructure systems

A Systematic Review on Power System Resilience from the Perspective of Generation, Network, and Load

Incorporating the Human Factor in Modeling the Operational Resilience of Interdependent Infrastructure Systems

Assessment Methods of Network Resilience for Cyber-Human-Physical Systems

Resilience of Critical Infrastructure Systems: A Systematic Literature Review of Measurement Frameworks

Review on modeling the societal impact of infrastructure disruptions due to disasters

The development of resilience research in critical infrastructure systems: A bibliometric perspective

Multiplex networks in resilience modeling of critical infrastructure systems: A systematic review

Cyber-physical-social interdependencies and organizational resilience: A review of water, transportation, and cyber infrastructure systems and processes

Assessment of the Impact of Interdependencies on the Resilience of Networked Critical Infrastructure Systems

State of the research in community resilience: progress and challenges

A Systematic Approach of Global Sensitivity Analysis and Its Application to a Model for the Quantification of Resilience of Interconnected Critical Infrastructures

Resilience analysis of cyber-physical systems: A review of models and methods

Managing disaster risk associated with critical infrastructure systems: a system-level conceptual framework for research and policy guidance

Resilience of critical structures, infrastructures and communities

The Methodologies and Main Challenges of Assessment the Multi-Hazard Interaction and Risk Management Associated with Roads Infrastructures and Dam Safety: A Review

Proposal for Holistic Assessment of Urban System Resilience to Natural Disasters

Enhancing urban system resilience to earthquake disasters: Impact of interdependence and resource allocation

The State of Art of Community Resilience of Physical Infrastructures

Resilient critical infrastructures: An innovative methodological perspective for critical infrastructure (CI) integrated assessment models by inducing digital technologies during multi-hazard incidents