Adapted Beamforming: A Robust and Flexible Approach for Removing Various Types of Artifacts from TMS–EEG Data

Johanna Metsomaa,Yufei Song,Tuomas P. Mutanen,Pedro C. Gordon,Ulf Ziemann,Christoph Zrenner,Julio C. Hernandez-Pavon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10548-024-01044-4

IF: 4.275

2024-04-12

Brain Topography

Abstract:Electroencephalogram (EEG) recorded as response to transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) can be highly informative of cortical reactivity and connectivity. Reliable EEG interpretation requires artifact removal as the TMS-evoked EEG can contain high-amplitude artifacts. Several methods have been proposed to uncover clean neuronal EEG responses. In practice, determining which method to select for different types of artifacts is often difficult. Here, we used a unified data cleaning framework based on beamforming to improve the algorithm selection and adaptation to the recorded signals. Beamforming properties are well understood, so they can be used to yield customized methods for EEG cleaning based on prior knowledge of the artifacts and the data. The beamforming implementations also cover, but are not limited to, the popular TMS–EEG cleaning methods: independent component analysis (ICA), signal-space projection (SSP), signal-space-projection-source-informed-reconstruction method (SSP–SIR), the source-estimate-utilizing noise-discarding algorithm (SOUND), data-driven Wiener filter (DDWiener), and the multiple-source approach. In addition to these established methods, beamforming provides a flexible way to derive novel artifact suppression algorithms by considering the properties of the recorded data. With simulated and measured TMS–EEG data, we show how to adapt the beamforming-based cleaning to different data and artifact types, namely TMS-evoked muscle artifacts, ocular artifacts, TMS-related peripheral responses, and channel noise. Importantly, beamforming implementations are fast to execute: We demonstrate how the SOUND algorithm becomes orders of magnitudes faster via beamforming. Overall, the beamforming-based spatial filtering framework can greatly enhance the selection, adaptability, and speed of EEG artifact removal.

neurosciences,clinical neurology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of effectively removing various types of artifacts in studies combining transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) and electroencephalography (EEG). TMS-EEG technology can provide valuable information about cortical reactivity and connectivity, but the presence of high-amplitude artifacts in TMS-induced EEG signals poses a challenge for reliable EEG interpretation. Although several methods have been proposed to clear these artifacts, choosing the appropriate method to handle different types of artifacts in practical applications is often very difficult. To solve this problem, the paper proposes a unified data cleaning framework based on beamforming, aimed at improving algorithm selection and adaptability to recorded signals. This method leverages the known advantages of beamforming characteristics and can customize EEG cleaning methods based on prior knowledge of artifacts and data. Additionally, the paper demonstrates how to adapt the beamforming cleaning method to different types of data and artifacts, such as TMS-induced muscle artifacts, eye movement artifacts, TMS-related peripheral nervous system responses, and channel noise, through simulations and actual TMS-EEG data. Importantly, the paper also points out that through beamforming, the execution speed of certain existing cleaning algorithms (such as the SOUND algorithm) can be increased by several orders of magnitude, significantly enhancing processing efficiency while maintaining cleaning effectiveness.

Adapted Beamforming: A Robust and Flexible Approach for Removing Various Types of Artifacts from TMS–EEG Data

Advanced Artifact Removal for Automated TMS-EEG Data Processing

ARTIST: A fully automated artifact rejection algorithm for single‐pulse TMS‐EEG data

Data-driven beamforming technique to attenuate ballistocardiogram artefacts in electroencephalography-functional magnetic resonance imaging without detecting cardiac pulses in electrocardiography recordings

Designing and comparing cleaning pipelines for TMS-EEG data: a theoretical overview and practical example

EEG Artifact Removal in TMS Studies of Cortical Speech Areas

EEG is better when cleaning effectively targets artifacts

Artifacts Removing Techniques on EEG Waveforms

Removal of Ocular and Muscular Artifacts from Multi-channel EEG Using Improved Spatial-Frequency Filtering

Auditory Fine-Tuned Suppressor of TMS-Clicks (TMS-Click AFTS): A Novel, Perceptually Driven/Tuned Approach for the Reduction in AEP Artifacts in TMS-EEG Studies

State-of-the-art EEG artifact removal evaluation

Real-time ballistocardiographic artifact reduction using the k-teager energy operator detector and multi-channel referenced adaptive noise cancelling.

Evaluation of algorithms for correction of transcranial magnetic stimulation induced artifacts in electroencephalograms

Characterization and real-time removal of motion artifacts from EEG signals

Efficient Rejection of Artifacts for Short-Term Few-Channel EEG Based on Fast Adaptive Multidimensional Sub-Bands Blind Source Separation

EEG artifact removal—state-of-the-art and guidelines

A Method of Removing Ocular Artifacts from EEG Using Discrete Wavelet Transform and Kalman Filtering.

Automatic Identification and Removal of Ocular Artifacts in EEG--improved Adaptive Predictor Filtering for Portable Applications.

Removal of Ocular Artifacts in EEG—An Improved Approach Combining DWT and ANC for Portable Applications

Focal artifact removal from ongoing EEG--a hybrid approach based on spatially-constrained ICA and wavelet de-noising

A simulation study: comparing independent component analysis and signal-space projection – source-informed reconstruction for rejecting muscle artifacts evoked by transcranial magnetic stimulation