Analysis of Concept Construction and Scale Development of Employee Zhengchong Behaviour in Family Firms in Jiangsu Province of China
Zejun Ma,Ming Fan,Chenhui Ouyang,Jialu Su,Mengyun Wu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/PRBM.S380050
IF: 3.974
2022-09-22
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Zejun Ma, 1 Ming Fan, 1 Chenhui Ouyang, 1 Jialu Su, 1 Mengyun Wu 2 1 School of Management, Jiangsu University, Zhenjiang, People's Republic of China; 2 School of Finance & Economics, Jiangsu University, Zhenjiang, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Mengyun Wu, Tel +86 15905288730, Email Purpose: Some scholars have explored the connotation and structural elements of employee zhengchong behaviour based on Taiwan's local enterprises, providing results with reference significance. However, there is a lack of accurate measurement scales. How to treat employee zhengchong behaviour (striving for a favour) and effectively deconstruct it is very important to the sustainable development of family firms. Methods: Semistructured interviews were conducted with 62 employees of private enterprises, and the structural dimension of employee zhengchong behaviour was explored with the help of grounded theory. The researchers designed two questionnaires, collected 278 and 331 valid questionnaires in the two surveys, compiled the corresponding measurement scale, and tested it. Results: Employee zhengchong behaviour under differential leadership was a multidimensional structure with rich connotations consisting of four dimensions: showing abilities, collaborating and sharing, excluding outsiders, and ingratiating upwards. The scale includes 16 items. Conclusion: This study enriches the relevant theories while providing a decision reference for family firm leaders to guide employee zhengchong behaviour to reasonably improve firm performance. Keywords: family firms, differential leadership, grounded theory, scale development Whether in developed countries or developing countries, family firms are surviving and developing tenaciously. Due to the influence of traditional culture, Chinese family firms are more susceptible to the psychological influence of "insiders" and "outsiders" and adopt different treatment methods for different employees. 1 Leadership has long been considered a critical factor in achieving team and organizational goals. 2 Leadership style affects and guides the choice of employee behaviour and significantly impacts the survival and development of enterprises. 3 Previous studies have shown that the particularism or rule by man in Chinese culture urges leaders to give more favouritism to their preferred subordinates and adopt different leadership behaviours. 4 This unique leadership style is called differential leadership, which is particularly common in family firms. 5 Many scholars believe that this leadership style is rooted in Confucian thought and Legalist thought in Chinese traditional culture. It has a unique role in management practice and a profound impact on the operation of Chinese family firms. 6 Differential leadership divides employees into "insiders" and "outsiders". "Insiders" refers to the employees seeking favour from their managers and becoming favoured subordinates, while "outsiders" do not do such things. Then, the former are seen as those with high performance and job satisfaction. As a result, the differential treatment by leaders results in uneven resource distribution, leading team members to compete to improve their status by seeking favour from their leaders. Huang, 7 a scholar from Taiwan Province, put forward the concept of zhengchong behaviour to explore such interactive behaviour among employees and defined zhengchong behaviour as the phenomenon in which employees fawn on leaders and woo or crowd out colleagues to gain the favour of leaders. "Competing" is purposeful behaviour, while "favour" refers to the gifts and attention from leaders to employees. To compete for resources or rights, employees adopt different strategies in the process of zhengchong , which may not only promote the improvement of their own or team performance but also lead to the depletion of internal resources. Take the family firm "True Kung Fu" as an example (the leading enterprise in China's fast-food industry); the struggle between "insiders" caused by "defamiliarization" has led to poor business management. 8–10 In contrast, "Fangtai" (a well-known kitchenware brand in China), as a typical successful representative of a family firm, adheres to the management concept of meritocracy and continues to promote the enthusiasm of all employees. 11 For enterprises, the organizational phenomenon of zhengchong behaviour has a significant impact on their long-term development, especially in the atmosphere of differential leadership. The in-depth discussion of zhengchong behavi -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary