Abstract:A detailed characterization of the chemical composition of complex substances, such as products of petroleum refining and environmental mixtures, is greatly needed in exposure assessment and manufacturing. The inherent complexity and variability in the composition of complex substances obfuscate the choices for their detailed analytical characterization. Yet, in lieu of exact chemical composition of complex substances, evaluation of the degree of similarity is a sensible path toward decision-making in environmental health regulations. Grouping of similar complex substances is a challenge that can be addressed via advanced analytical methods and streamlined data analysis and visualization techniques. Here, we propose a framework with unsupervised and supervised analyses to optimally group complex substances based on their analytical features. We test two data sets of complex oil-derived substances. The first data set is from gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) analysis of 20 Standard Reference Materials representing crude oils and oil refining products. The second data set consists of 15 samples of various gas oils analyzed using three analytical techniques: GC-MS, GC×GC-flame ionization detection (FID), and ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (IM-MS). We use hierarchical clustering using Pearson correlation as a similarity metric for the unsupervised analysis and build classification models using the Random Forest algorithm for the supervised analysis. We present a quantitative comparative assessment of clustering results via Fowlkes–Mallows index, and classification results via model accuracies in predicting the group of an unknown complex substance. We demonstrate the effect of (i) different grouping methodologies, (ii) data set size, and (iii) dimensionality reduction on the grouping quality, and (iv) different analytical techniques on the characterization of the complex substances. While the complexity and variability in chemical composition are an inherent feature of complex substances, we demonstrate how the choices of the data analysis and visualization methods can impact the communication of their characteristics to delineate sufficient similarity.

Molecular Reconstruction of Crude Oil: Novel Structure-Oriented Homologous Series Lumping with a Cloud Model

Molecular Reconstruction: Recent Progress Toward Composition Modeling of Petroleum Fractions

Molecular Reconstruction Model Based on Structure Oriented Lumping and Group Contribution Methods

An Aided Optimization Method for Molecular Reconstruction of Crude Oil Based on Pre-optimized Dataset

Eight Lumps Kinetic Model for Residual Oil Catalytic Cracking

Molecular Reconstruction Model for Petroleum Fractions Based on Structure Oriented Lumping

Molecular Reconstruction of Naphtha Via Limited Bulk Properties: Methods and Comparisons

Prediction of crude oil physical properties based on molecular compositional modeling approach

Combine Molecular Modeling with Optimization to Stretch Refinery Operation

Novel Naphtha Molecular Reconstruction Process Using a Self-Adaptive Cloud Model and Hybrid Genetic Algorithm–Particle Swarm Optimization Algorithm

Semiquantitative Molecular Characterization of Crude Oil

A data processing pipeline for petroleomics based on liquid chromatography-high resolution mass spectrometry

Recent Progress Toward Molecular-Level Kinetic Model for Complex Hydrocarbon Conversion Processes

Grouping of complex substances using analytical chemistry data: A framework for quantitative evaluation and visualization

Chemometric Classification of Crude Oils in Complex Petroleum Systems Using T-Distributed Stochastic Neighbor Embedding Machine Learning Algorithm

Modelling and Optimization Based on the Molecular Matrix for the Overall Refinery Operation

A numerical study of fluids desorption and phase behavior in shale oil reservoir using a chemical reaction model

A Method for Crude Oil Selection and Blending OptimizationBased on Improved Cuckoo Search Algorithm

SOME IMPROVEMENTS IN THE APPLICATION OF A CRUDE DISTILLATION MODEL

Quantitative Molecular Composition of Heavy Petroleum Fractions: A Case Study of Fluid Catalytic Cracking Decant Oil

Double-bond equivalence linear equations for structural interpretation of fossil hydrocarbons