Neutrino fog for dark matter-electron scattering experiments

Ben Carew,Ashlee R. Caddell,Tarak Nath Maity,Ciaran A. J. O’Hare

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.109.083016

IF: 5.407

2024-04-13

Physical Review D

Abstract:The search for sub-GeV dark matter via scattering on electrons has ramped up in the last few years. Like in the case of dark matter scattering on nuclei, electron-recoil-based searches also face an ultimate background in the form of neutrinos. The so-called "neutrino fog" refers to the range of open dark matter parameter space where the background of neutrinos can potentially prevent a conclusive discovery claim of a dark matter signal from being made. In this study, we map the neutrino fog for a range of electron recoil experiments based on silicon, germanium, xenon, and argon targets. In analogy to the nuclear recoil case, we also calculate the "edge" to the neutrino fog, which can be used as a visual guide to determine where neutrinos become an important background—this boundary excludes some parts of the key theory milestones used to motivate these experiments. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.109.083016 Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI. Funded by SCOAP 3 . Published by the American Physical Society

astronomy & astrophysics,physics, particles & fields

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the "neutrino background" problem faced in low - quality (in the MeV - GeV range) dark matter scattering experiments with electrons. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to map out the so - called "neutrino fog" boundaries in electron - recoil experiments using silicon, germanium, xenon, and argon as target materials. Here, the "neutrino fog" refers to the region in the dark matter parameter space where the neutrino background may hinder making a clear discovery statement of the dark matter signal.

### Main problems
1. **The influence of the neutrino background**:
- The neutrino background is the ultimate background in dark matter experiments, especially for dark matter detection experiments based on electron - recoil. Since nuclear - recoil events produced by solar neutrinos and neutrinos from other sources are very close to the dark matter signal in the energy spectrum, it is extremely difficult to distinguish between the two.

2. **The definition and mapping of the "neutrino fog"**:
- The paper aims to map out the "neutrino fog" boundaries in electron - recoil experiments with different target materials (silicon, germanium, xenon, and argon). This boundary can help researchers determine in which regions of the parameter space the neutrino background becomes an important background interference, thus affecting the identification of the dark matter signal.

### Solutions
1. **Experiment selection**:
- The paper selected several typical experimental devices, including solid - state semiconductor detectors (such as silicon - and germanium - based detectors) and liquid - inert - gas detectors (such as liquid - xenon and liquid - argon two - phase time - projection chambers).

2. **Theoretical models**:
- Codes such as DarkELF and AMPSCI were used to calculate the event rate of dark matter - electron scattering. These codes take into account factors such as atomic form factors, momentum transfer, and the dark matter velocity distribution.
- For neutrino scattering, the differential cross - section of coherent elastic neutrino - nucleon scattering (CE νNS) was used, and the uncertainty of the neutrino flux and the ionization yield of the target material were considered.

3. **Statistical analysis**:
- The likelihood ratio test method (profile likelihood ratio test) was used to evaluate the existence of the dark matter signal. By maximizing the likelihood function, the likelihood ratio test statistic \( q_0 \) was constructed and calculated using the Asimov data set approximation method.

### Results
- The paper mapped out the "neutrino fog" boundaries of different target materials (silicon, germanium, liquid xenon, and liquid argon) and showed the positions of these boundaries in the dark matter parameter space. These results are helpful for guiding the design and optimization of future experiments to reduce the influence of the neutrino background and improve the sensitivity of dark matter detection.

### Formula summary
1. **The event rate of dark matter - electron scattering**:
\[
\frac{d\sigma}{dE_e} = \bar{\sigma}_e \frac{1}{2m_e} \int dv f(v) \frac{v}{v} \int_{q_-}^{q_+} dq q |F_{DM}(q)|^2 K_{njl}(E_e, q)
\]
where \( q_- \) and \( q_+ \) are the limits of momentum transfer, which are determined by energy and the dark matter velocity.

2. **The event rate of neutrino - nucleon scattering**:
\[
\frac{d\sigma}{dE_r} = \frac{G_F^2}{4\pi} \frac{Q_W^2 m_N}{(1 - \frac{m_N E_r}{2E_\nu^2})} F^2(E_r)
\]
where \( G_F \) is the Fermi coupling constant, \( Q_W \) is the weak nuclear hypercharge, and \( F(E_r) \) is the Helm form factor.

Through these methods and models, the paper successfully mapped out the "neutrino fog" boundaries of different target materials, providing an important reference for future dark matter detection experiments.