Abstract:The common spatial pattern (CSP) is a very effective feature extraction method in motor imagery based brain computer interface (BCI), but its performance depends on the selection of the optimal frequency band. Although a lot of research works have been proposed to improve CSP, most of these works have the problems of large computation costs and long feature extraction time. To this end, three new feature extraction methods based on CSP and a new feature selection method based on non-convex log regularization are proposed in this paper. Firstly, EEG signals are spatially filtered by CSP, and then three new feature extraction methods are proposed. We called them CSP-wavelet, CSP-WPD and CSP-FB, respectively. For CSP-Wavelet and CSP-WPD, the discrete wavelet transform (DWT) or wavelet packet decomposition (WPD) is used to decompose the spatially filtered signals, and then the energy and standard deviation of the wavelet coefficients are extracted as features. For CSP-FB, the spatially filtered signals are filtered into multiple bands by a filter bank (FB), and then the logarithm of variances of each band are extracted as features. Secondly, a sparse optimization method regularized with a non-convex log function is proposed for the feature selection, which we called LOG, and an optimization algorithm for LOG is given. Finally, ensemble learning is used for secondary feature selection and classification model construction. Combing feature extraction and feature selection methods, a total of three new EEG decoding methods are obtained, namely CSP-Wavelet+LOG, CSP-WPD+LOG, and CSP-FB+LOG. Four public motor imagery datasets are used to verify the performance of the proposed methods. Compared to existing methods, the proposed methods achieved the highest average classification accuracy of 88.86, 83.40, 81.53, and 80.83 in datasets 1–4, respectively. The feature extraction time of CSP-FB is the shortest. The experimental results show that the proposed methods can effectively improve the classification accuracy and reduce the feature extraction time. With comprehensive consideration of classification accuracy and feature extraction time, CSP-FB+LOG has the best performance and can be used for the real-time BCI system.

Learning Optimal Time-Frequency-Spatial Features by the CiSSA-CSP Method for Motor Imagery EEG Classification.

Learning Common Time-Frequency-Spatial Patterns for Motor Imagery Classification

Simultaneously Optimizing Spatial Spectral Features Based on Mutual Information for Eeg Classification

A Spatial-Frequency-temporal Optimized Feature Sparse Representation-Based Classification Method for Motor Imagery EEG Pattern Recognition

Optimal Channel-Based Sparse Time-Frequency Blocks Common Spatial Pattern Feature Extraction Method for Motor Imagery Classification

The CSP-Based New Features Plus Non-Convex Log Sparse Feature Selection for Motor Imagery EEG Classification

Temporally Constrained Sparse Group Spatial Patterns for Motor Imagery BCI

SCSP-3: A Spectrally Augmented Common Spatial Pattern Approach for Robust Motor Imagery-Based Brain–Computer Interface

EEG Classification by Filter Band Component Regularized Common Spatial Pattern for Motor Imagery.

Temporal Combination Pattern Optimization Based on Feature Selection Method for Motor Imagery BCIs.

Feature Extraction by Common Spatial Pattern in Frequency Domain for Motor Imagery Tasks Classification

Designing Robust Spatial Filter for Motor Imagery Electroencephalography Signal Classification in Brain-Computer Interface Systems

Class Discrepancy-Guided Sub-Band Filter-Based Common Spatial Pattern for Motor Imagery Classification

Optimal Channel and Frequency Band-Based Feature Selection for Motor Imagery Electroencephalogram Classification

Transformed common spatial pattern for motor imagery-based brain-computer interfaces

An Improved CSP Algorithm and Application in Motor Imagery Recognition

An Adaptive Common Spatial Pattern for EEG Signal Classification in Different Channel

Local Temporal Correlation Common Spatial Patterns for Single Trial EEG Classification During Motor Imagery.

Spatio-Temporally Regularized Common Spatial Patterns (Str-Csp) for Single-Trial Eeg Classification

Local Temporal Joint Recurrence Common Spatial Patterns for MI-based BCI

Spatiotemporal Feature Extraction Method Combining Common Spatial Pattern and Hybrid Spatial‐temporal Attention‐net in Motor Imagery–brain‐computer Interface System