Abstract:The objective of the present work is to examine from a new perspective the existence of causal factors not predicted by the classical theory that thirst and sodium appetite are two distinct motivations. For example, we ask why water deprivation induces sodium appetite, thirst is not "water appetite", and intracellular dehydration potentially causes sodium appetite. Contrary to the classical theory, we suggest that thirst first, and sodium appetite second, designate a temporal sequence underlying the same motivation. The single motivation becomes an "intervenient variable" a concept borrowed from the literature, fully explained in the text, between causes of dehydration (extracellular, intracellular, or both together), and respective behavioral responses subserved by hindbrain-dependent inhibition (e.g., lateral parabrachial nucleus) and forebrain facilitation (e.g., angiotensin II). A corollary is homology between rat sodium appetite and marine teleost thirst-like motivation that we name "protodipsia". The homology argument rests on similarities between behavior (salty water intake) and respective neuroanatomical as well as functional mechanisms. Tetrapod origin in a marine environment provides additional support for the homology. The single motivation hypothesis is also consistent with ingestive behaviors in nature given similarities (e.g., thirst producing brackish water intake) between the behavior of the laboratory rat and wild animals, rodents included. The hypotheses of single motivation and homology might explain why hyperosmotic rats, or eventually any other hyperosmotic tetrapod, shows paradoxical signs of sodium appetite. They might also explain how ingestive behaviors determined by dehydration and subserved by hindbrain inhibitory mechanisms contributed to tetrapod transition from sea to land.

Human Thirst Behavior Requires Transformation of Sensory Inputs by Intrinsic Brain Networks

Thirst regulates motivated behavior through modulation of brainwide neural population dynamics

Thirst neurons anticipate the homeostatic consequences of eating and drinking

Distinct Neural Representations of Hunger and Thirst in Neonatal Mice before the Emergence of Food- and Water-seeking Behaviors

Neural landscape diffusion resolves conflicts between needs across time

Anterior Cingulate Cortex Modulates the Affective-Motivative Dimension of Hyperosmolality-Induced Thirst

Thirst Is Associated with Suppression of Habenula Output and Active Stress Coping: Is there a Role for a Non-canonical Vasopressin-Glutamate Pathway?

Neurons for hunger and thirst transmit a negative-valence teaching signal

Human Cortical Responses to Water in the Mouth, and the Effects of Thirst.

Sensory representation and detection mechanisms of gut osmolality change

Regulation of Thirst and Vasopressin Release

Thirst as an ingestive behavior: A brief review on physiology and assessment

Control of fluid intake in dehydrated rats and evolution of sodium appetite

The trajectory of sensory pathways from the lamina terminalis to the insular and cingulate cortex: a neuroanatomical framework for the generation of thirst

Progress of Neural Circuits Mechanism Underlying Metabolic and Hedonic Feeding

Physiological Mechanisms for Thirst in the Nonhuman Primate

The cerebellum modulates thirst

The organum vasculosum of the lamina terminalis and subfornical organ: regulation of thirst

Evolution of the thirst mechanism in Homo: The need and limitations of thirst and hydration

Recent Advances in Neural Circuits for Taste Perception in Hunger

Neural Regulation of Feeding Behavior