Abstract:Inconsistency in pairwise comparison judgements is often perceived as an unwanted phenomenon and researchers have proposed a number of techniques to either reduce it or to correct it. We take a viewpoint that this inconsistency unleashes different mindsets of the decision maker(s) that should be taken into account when generating recommendations as decision support. With this aim we consider the spanning trees analysis which is a recently emerging idea for use with the pairwise comparison approach that represents the plurality of mindsets (in terms of a plurality of vectors corresponding to different spanning trees). Until now, the multiplicity of the vectors supplied by the spanning trees approach have been amalgamated into a single preference vector, losing the information about the plurality of mindsets. To preserve this information, we propose a novel methodology taking an approach similar to Stochastic Multi-criteria Acceptability Analysis. Considering all the rankings of alternatives corresponding to the different mindsets, our methodology gives the probability that an alternative attains a given ranking position as well as the probability that an alternative is preferred to another one. Since the exponential number of spanning trees makes their enumeration prohibitive, we propose computing approximate probabilities using statistical sampling of the spanning trees. Our approach is also appealing because it can be applied also to incomplete sets of pairwise comparisons. We demonstrate its usefulness with a didactic example as well as with an application to a real-life case of selecting a Telecom backbone infrastructure for rural areas.

Cyclic Sequential Process of Pairwise Comparisons with Application to Multi-Criteria Decision Making.

Hesitant Fuzzy Multi-Attribute Decision Making Based on Binary Connection Number of Set Pair Analysis

Prospect Theory Model for Multiple Criteria Decision Making Alternative with Interval Number

Supporting decisions by unleashing multiple mindsets using pairwise comparisons method

A Study of Decision Process in MCDM Problems with Large Number of Criteria

Estimating priorities from relative deviations in pairwise comparison matrices

A Proportional Fuzzy Elimination and Choice Translating Reality II Method for Multicriteria Decision-Making Problems: A Robust New Methodology for Practical Applications

Multi-criteria Decision Making Based on Relative Measures

The incomplete Analytic Hierarchy Process and Bradley-Terry model: (in)consistency and information retrieval

Incomplete linguistic q-rung orthopair fuzzy preference relations and their application to multi-criteria decision making

A New Approach to Multiple Criteria Decision-Making Using the Dice Similarity Measure under Fermatean Fuzzy Environments

On using pairwise comparison in the analytic hierarchy process: Validity is goal while consistency is means

An Improved TOPSIS Method for Multi-Criteria Decision Making Based on Hesitant Fuzzy Β Neighborhood

Application of tropical optimization for solving multicriteria problems of pairwise comparisons using log-Chebyshev approximation

Research on the Satisfaction Degree and Criteria Weight Obtaining for Multiple Criteria Decision Making Problem

MAGDM Linear-Programming Models with Distinct Uncertain Preference Structures.

Deriving priorities from pairwise comparison matrices with a novel consistency index

Intuitionistic Linguistic Stochastic Multi-criteria Decision-making Method based on Prospect Theory

An Alternative Consensus Model of Additive Preference Relations for Group Decision Making Based on the Ordinal Consistency

A New Approach for Multicriteria Group Decision Making under Interval Type-2 Fuzzy Environment

INTUITIONISTIC FUZZY PRIORITIZED OPERATORS AND THEIR APPLICATION IN MULTI-CRITERIA GROUP DECISION MAKING