How Old Are the Tibetan Ice Cores?
Shugui Hou
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1360/n972019-00189
2019-01-01
Chinese Science Bulletin (Chinese Version)
Abstract:Tibetan ice cores provide a wealth of information for past climatic and environmental conditions at different time scales. An accurate chronology is the essential first step and serves as the foundation for ice core research. However, dating ice cores drilled from high-elevation glaciers is always challenging, because seasonal signals used for annual layer counting become unidentifiable in the deeper (older) ice core sections due to rapid thinning of ice layers, and horizons with an identified absolute age are rare. In 1992, a 308.6 m ice core to bedrock was recovered from the Guliya ice cap in the west Kunlun Mountains on the northwestern Tibetan Plateau (TP). The Guliya ice core record has been widely cited (1001 times from the Google Scholar on 13 May 2019) since its publication in 1997. The ice at the depth of 290 m of the Guliya ice core was suggested to be more than 500 ka (thousand years). However, the age ranges of all other Tibetan ice cores (e.g. Dasuopu, East Rongbuk, Puruogangri and Dunde) fall within the Holocene. In 2012 and 2013, four ice cores to bedrock (216.6, 208.6, 135.8 and 133.8 m in length, respectively) were recovered from the Chongce ice cap similar to 30 km from the Guliya ice core drilling site. The Chongce ice core depth-age relationship was established by a two-parameter flow model calibrated by the C-14, Pb-210, tritium and beta-activity measurements. The results suggest that Chongce ice cores are likely of Holocene origin, consistent with other Tibetan ice cores except Guliya. A direct comparison of the depth profiles of stable isotopic between the Chongce and Guliya ice cores shows similar temporal patterns, and a highly significant positive correlation between the two profiles. These results seem to suggest that the Chongce and Guliya ice cores might be similar in age. Therefore, the original chronology of the Guliya ice core might be overestimated by similar to 2 orders of magnitude. This would further cast doubts on the previous climate reconstructions from the Guliya ice core, as well as the suggested asynchronous glaciation on the Tibetan Plateau based on the original Guliya chronology. In 2015, a new Guliya ice core to bedrock (309.73 m in length) was recovered close to the location of the 1992 Guliya core drilling site. Multiple measurements (including C-14, Cl-36, Be-10, delta O-18 of air in bubbles, and argon isotopic ratios) are planned for this new 2015 Guliya ice core in order to determine its age. Undoubtedly, such new research on the 2015 Guliya ice core is extremely important to resolve the huge discrepancy between the age ranges of the 1992 Guliya ice core and all other Tibetan ice cores.