Does Concealing Gender Identity Help Women Win the Competition? an Empirical Investigation into Online Video Games

Xinlei (Jack) Chen,Xiaohua Zeng,Cheng Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1287/mksc.2022.1393

2022-01-01

Marketing Science

Abstract:This paper examines how gender stereotypes affect gender equality by exploring the two-dimensional gender identities in online video games.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Why Do Women Pretend to Be Men? Female Gender Swapping in Online Games

Liling Zhou,Ning Han,Zeran Xu,Corlyn Brian,Siraj Hussain

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.810954

IF: 3.8

2022-05-12

Frontiers in Psychology

Abstract:This research explored the influencing factors of gender swapping among female players in online games and their impact on online gaming behavior. Based on an online survey of 3,658 female players in China, we found that perceived benefits and the Tanbi tendency, a psychological indulgence in enjoying novels, comics, or series on love and sex between attractive males, were the most important factors for female players to employ male avatars. Sexual orientation, perceived anonymity, and perceived tolerance also had a significant influence on gender swapping. Different from the practical benefits perceived by men who use female avatars in online games, the perceived benefit for female players who use male avatars was to avoid gender discrimination. In order to obtain more freedom and fairer treatment, they chose male avatars for a better experience. Female players with a higher degree of gender swapping showed a stronger aggressiveness and dominant “hyper-masculinity” behavior tendency in the game. Though online virtual worlds may be a convenient place for females to experience gender equality through gender swapping, the findings of this study suggest that gender swapping in games may, to some extent, perpetuate or even reinforce gender stereotypes in the real world.

psychology, multidisciplinary
Gender Differences in the Effect of Communication on College Students' Online Decisions

Chunlei Chai,Xun Wu,Danni Shen,Dan Li,Kejun Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2016.07.012

IF: 9.9

2016-01-01

Computers in Human Behavior

Abstract:This study focuses on gender differences in the influence of online communication on e-commerce purchase decision strategies. From the literature, we deduce a new theoretical model based on three foundational theories and design a 2 ∗ 2 mixed factorial experiment to test the influence of online communication in cases with and without online communication. This involves analyzing screen-recording data to check the effect of shopping behavior initiation, and using questionnaire research to test differences in the user experience before and after such communication. Finally, we concluded that the influence of online communication differs between men and women, and the influence is largely positive to both males and females.
Uncovering Gender Stereotypes in Video Game Character Designs: A Multi-Modal Analysis of Honor of Kings

Bingqing Liu,Kyrie Zhixuan Zhou,Danlei Zhu,Jaihyun Park

2023-11-24

Abstract:In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive analysis of gender stereotypes in the character design of Honor of Kings, a popular multiplayer online battle arena (MOBA) game in China. We probe gender stereotypes through the lens of role assignments, visual designs, spoken lines, and background stories, combining qualitative analysis and text mining based on the moral foundation theory. Male heroes are commonly designed as masculine fighters with power and female heroes as feminine "ornaments" with ideal looks. We contribute with a culture-aware and multi-modal understanding of gender stereotypes in games, leveraging text-, visual-, and role-based evidence.

Human-Computer Interaction,Computers and Society
Gender and the Beauty Contest Game

Botao Qin

2019-01-01

Abstract:This paper uses a beauty contest game to test the gender differences in strategic reasoning. Using both a non-monetary incentive treatment and a monetary incentives treatment in China, I find there are differences in strategic reasoning.However, the differences disappear with the increase of stakes.
Are There Gender Differences in Strategic Reasoning? Evidence from a Beauty Contest Game in China

Botao Qin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4111987

2022-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:This paper uses a beauty contest game to test the gender differences in strategic reasoning. I conducted two experiments in China: one in a classroom setting with student subjects and the other online with the general population. In the first experiment, I found evidence of gender differences in strategic reasoning: males entered significantly lower numbers in the low-stake treatment and were more likely to be high-strategic types than females in both the non-monetary incentive treatment and the low-stake treatment. I did not find a gender difference in the high-stake treatment. In addition, subjects with higher course grades entered significantly lower numbers in all treatments with monetary incentives. In the second experiment, no gender differences were observed; this paper will explain the possible reasons behind the different findings.
Aggression in online gaming: the role of online disinhibition, social dominance orientation, moral disengagement and gender traits among Chinese university students

Wenxuan Gan,Zichao Chen,Zhusheng Wu,Xia Huang,Fang Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2024.1459696

IF: 5.2

2024-11-07

Frontiers in Public Health

Abstract:Introduction: Aggressive behaviors in the online gaming world are frequent and have far-reaching negative effects. Method: To explore the factors and mechanisms of aggressive in games, we surveyed 945 university students using a framework of social dominance orientation, online disinhibition, moral disengagement, and aggression in gaming, and examined the moderating role of gender traits. Results: We found no direct relationship between online disinhibition and aggression in gaming; however, through the mediating role of moral disengagement, online disinhibition indirectly affected aggression in gaming behavior and enhanced social dominance orientation. Social dominance orientation predicted both moral disengagement and aggression in gaming behaviors, and the mediating effect of moral disengagement was confirmed through the indirect influence of moral disengagement on aggression in gaming behavior. Moreover, the moral disengagement mechanism significantly predicted aggression in gaming behavior. Furthermore, femininity and androgyny moderated both social dominance orientation toward moral disengagement and aggression in gaming, while masculinity and androgyny moderated the path from online disinhibition to social dominance orientation. Regarding the path from moral disengagement to aggression, all gender trait moderations were significant. Discussion: This study reveals the role of the moral disengagement mechanism in the process of game-related aggression, providing theoretical support for the explanation of aggressive behavior, which applies to players of any gender. Moreover, this study confirms the moderating role of gender. Unlike biological sex, gender traits are malleable; androgynous traits offer greater adaptability in various environments. Thus, prevention and intervention efforts against online aggression should include strengthening moral education and properly guiding and fostering androgynous gender traits.

public, environmental & occupational health
The Role of Social Presence in Relationships Among Gender Stereotypes, Sexism, and In-Game Sexual Harassment Among Young Korean Gamers

Hyun Jung Oh,Mi Yeon Choi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1089/cyber.2022.0265

2023-05-25

Abstract:Despite the rapidly increasing number of female gamers worldwide, female players are still experiencing discrimination, stereotyping, and objectification in digital games. The present study examined the relationships among gender stereotypes, sexism, and sexual harassment in online games, and further investigated how enhanced social presence contributes to intensifying the effects of gender stereotypes and sexism on sexual harassment. An online survey was conducted among 521 young male Korean gamers who regularly play two genres of online games: role-playing games and first-person shooter games. The results of moderated-mediation analyses using Hayes PROCESS macro models confirmed that gender stereotypes had significant effects on hostile and benevolent in-game sexism. A significant interaction was also observed between in-game sexism and social presence in predicting sexual harassment in online games. The findings from this study confirm the role of social presence as an amplifier that reinforces gender stereotypes and discrimination in competitive and violent online game environments.

psychology, social
Freed or Trapped: Gaming Pleasures and Expression of Gender Identities in World of Warcraft among Chinese Players

Qiaolei Jiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.30958/ajmmc.4.2.4

2018-01-01

Athens Journal of Mass Media and Communications

Abstract:Information communication technologies hold an ambivalent place for gender identities in cyber space. In this sense, the ways that online game players make meaning of, respond to, and take pleasure in gaming lead to insights into how online games might serve as spaces for the enactment of new forms of gender identities. This study focuses on a bourgeoning communication phenomenon concerning MMORPG. Through a case study of World of Warcraft (WoW) guided by Uses and Gratifications theory, the paper explores gaming (dis)pleasures and expression of gender identities. Based on the data collected from virtual ethnography, which mainly included participant observation and in-depth interviews of 22 WoW players, the study takes a snapshot of the ways in which gender identities are constructed in WoW. The findings show that diverse options seem not to lead to a corresponding mobility or fluidity in terms of how gender can be performed in the game, even with "ladyboy" as an interesting phenomenon in gameplay. The paper argues that players’ preferences and orientations toward gendered characters reflect their interplay with gaming rules, dominant narratives and relationships in real life, as well as the enactment in role-playing and image-based interfaces. Although some female players have to derive pleasures from a male perspective, there are some alternative consumptions of the masculine genre like WoW.
Research on the Display of Female Elements by Chinese Online Game Female Players on the Social Media Platform Xiaohongshu

Yun Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54691/bcpssh.v21i.3653

2023-02-15

BCP Social Sciences & Humanities

Abstract:With the progress of science and technology, games have become a common entertainment item. Traditionally, the vast majority of games have been designed for men. However, in recent years, women are no longer a marginal group among the game audience. They are active in different game communities, especially Xiaohongshu platform. Compared with other game communities, the posts of female users on Xiaohongshu show different characteristics and tendencies. This research first uses the participant observation method to select the posts of three games and the search results of the keyword “online games”. Through analysis, it is concluded that the content of Xiaohongshu game community is mostly casual games, and users are used to combining their personal life with games when creating and sharing contents. However, this also exposed some disadvantages including one-sided content and imperfect system and search mechanism, which requires Xiaohongshu to develop more complete measures and create more activities to enrich the content of the platform. This research is aimed at making the design of game manufacturers and the development of game communities more meet the needs of female consumers by studying the content shared by female players in Xiaohongshu game community, emphasizing the status of women in the game field, and fill the gap of feminism about games.

English Else
Exploring the Impact of Gender on Character Mechanics in Multiplayer Online Battle Arena (MOBA) Games

Kieran Hicks,C. Headleand,Beth Davies

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/CW49994.2020.00018

2020-09-01

Abstract:Frequently, game characters have abilities that conform to the expectations of their gender, this correlation between character abilities and gender has not been fully explored. Previous research has identified that throughout various media, females are represented as secondary and submissive characters, this representation can affect the way that women are treated in real life. This impact has been found to influence their decision to pursue studies in a Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) field. In this research, we intended to explore whether the gender of a character has an impact on their in-game mechanics and abilities. Our research finds that there are differences here, namely, male characters are more likely to have abilities which enable them to be self-sufficient, whereas female characters have more abilities for aiding other champions in-game, inherently placing them into a submissive role. This paper provides insights on gender representation in Multiplayer Online Battle Arena (MOBA) games from a novel perspective and discusses the impact on in-game experiences.

Sociology,Computer Science
Understanding Gaming Perceptions and Experiences in a Women's College Community

Orit Shaer,Lauren Westendorf,Nicholas A. Knouf,Claudia Pederson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3025453.3025623

2017-05-02

Abstract:Recent trends in gaming diversification have shown that women are both an increasingly significant pool of consumers and game producers, and regular victims of misogynistic harassment. Such observations stress the importance of investigating the complex relationships of women and gaming. In this paper, we draw upon perspectives from Feminist HCI to extend the current knowledge of issues in gaming that are specific to women. We present results from a mixed-methods study with 327 participants who are students and alumnae of a women's college. Our findings shed light on the complex relationships of women with games, with other gamers, and with gaming culture and industry. The results also indicate that in some cases gender-related negative experiences of gaming have lasting impact on the participation and self-confidence of young women. We conclude by discussing the implications of our findings for the design of games, game development education, and for the study of gaming.
Gendered Conversation in a Social Game-Streaming Platform

Supun Nakandala,Giovanni Luca Ciampaglia,Norman Makoto Su,Yong-Yeol Ahn

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1611.06459

2016-11-23

Abstract:Online social media and games are increasingly replacing offline social activities. Social media is now an indispensable mode of communication; online gaming is not only a genuine social activity but also a popular spectator sport. With support for anonymity and larger audiences, online interaction shrinks social and geographical barriers. Despite such benefits, social disparities such as gender inequality persist in online social media. In particular, online gaming communities have been criticized for persistent gender disparities and objectification. As gaming evolves into a social platform, persistence of gender disparity is a pressing question. Yet, there are few large-scale, systematic studies of gender inequality and objectification in social gaming platforms. Here we analyze more than one billion chat messages from Twitch, a social game-streaming platform, to study how the gender of streamers is associated with the nature of conversation. Using a combination of computational text analysis methods, we show that gendered conversation and objectification is prevalent in chats. Female streamers receive significantly more objectifying comments while male streamers receive more game-related comments. This difference is more pronounced for popular streamers. There also exists a large number of users who post only on female or male streams. Employing a neural vector-space embedding (paragraph vector) method, we analyze gendered chat messages and create prediction models that (i) identify the gender of streamers based on messages posted in the channel and (ii) identify the gender a viewer prefers to watch based on their chat messages. Our findings suggest that disparities in social game-streaming platforms is a nuanced phenomenon that involves the gender of streamers as well as those who produce gendered and game-related conversation.

Social and Information Networks,Computation and Language,Computers and Society
Applying the multi-threat framework of stereotype threat in the context of digital gaming

Charlotte R Pennington,Linda K Kaye,Joseph J McCann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0192137

IF: 3.7

2018-02-14

PLoS ONE

Abstract:Females often report experiencing stigmatisation pertaining to their competency in digital gaming communities. Employing the principles of the multi-threat framework of stereotype threat, the current research examined the impact of gender-related stereotypes on females' gaming performance and related self-perceptions. In Experiment 1, 90 females were assigned to one of three conditions in which they were primed that their performance would be either diagnostic of their personal (self-as-target) or gender group's ability (group-as-target) or would be non-diagnostic of gaming ability (control). In Experiment 2, 90 females were primed that their performance would be judged by a group of other females (in-group source) or males (out-group source), or would be non-diagnostic of ability (control). Participants then completed a casual gaming task, as well as measures of competence beliefs, self-efficacy and self-esteem. Findings from Experiment 1 indicate that neither a self-as-target nor a group-as-target stereotype affected significantly gaming performance, or game-related self-efficacy, self-esteem and competency beliefs. Findings from Experiment 2 reveal further that females' gaming performance and associated self-perceptions were not impacted significantly by an in-group or out-group source of stereotype threat. The discussion turns to potential explanations for these findings, proposing that females may not perceive negative gender-gaming stereotypes to be an accurate representation of their personal or social group's gaming ability. We also discuss the implications of the experimental design and difficulty, as well as the potential for domain identification to moderate performance outcomes under stereotype threat.
Gender bias in team-building activities in China

Yun Lou,Xuanhui Liu,Pei Chen,Kejun Zhang,Lingyun Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/gm-04-2020-0116

2021-07-13

Gender in Management: An International Journal

Abstract:Purpose The purpose of this study is to explore how gender influences peer assessment in team-building activities in China. Design/methodology/approach A nine-player Werewolf game was adopted to conduct the experiment. Nine abilities were defined to evaluate players’ performances. Before the game, players filled out a self-assessment questionnaire (five-point Likert scale). After the game, players evaluated other game members’ performances using the same questionnaire. Data were analyzed using linear regression. Findings The results showed that gender bias clearly existed in team-building activities, with men more likely to receive better peer assessment than women. In addition, when women presented themselves as actively as men did, they received less favorable evaluations than men, whereas their failures were more likely to be exaggerated. Practical implications This study may help build harmonious teams for gender equality, and we give practical suggestions respectively from the perspective of female employees, their managers, and their companies. Originality/value Given the importance of team-building activities in teamwork, fair evaluations of team-building performances are essential. However, gender influences on peer assessment in team-building activities in China remain unclear. This study adds new and important knowledge to research on gender bias in teams.
Female Video Game Players and the Protective Effect of Feminist Identity Against Internalized Misogyny

Keiko M. McCullough,Y. Joel Wong,Natalie J. Stevenson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11199-019-01055-7

2019-06-03

Sex Roles

Abstract:Video games often contain sexist content that may be connected to negative consequences for female video game players, such as internalizing negative attitudes and beliefs about women. However, aspects of feminist identification may prevent such negative outcomes from occurring. The present study investigated the relationships among time spent playing video games, internalized misogyny, and the synthesis dimension of feminist identity, which is characterized by embracing the positive aspects of being a woman and incorporating feminine attributes into one's own unique personality. A total of 319 U.S. female video game players completed measures of media usage, internalized misogyny, and feminist identity. The authors tested a moderation model in which gaming predicted internalized misogyny and synthesis moderated this relationship. Gaming was positively associated with internalized misogyny at lower, but not higher, levels of synthesis. Thus, those who value the positive aspects of womanhood and have thoughtful and realistic perceptions of gender may be resistant to internalizing some harmful beliefs about women perpetuated in games. The present study provides evidence for the potential negative influence of cumulative video game exposure for some women and the protective effect of feminist identity synthesis. Counselors and activists should do work aimed at critically evaluating and challenging gendered messages in video games and affirming women's gender identities and feminine attributes. Game developers must consider the impact of their content on players and strive to create female characters that are agentic, complex, and competent. Conversely, gamers should avoid supporting games with depthless depictions of women.

psychology, social,womens studies, developmental
Gender, Competition, and Performance: International Evidence

Kai Li,Qiyuan Peng,Rui Shen,Gabriel Wong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s0022109024000255

IF: 4.337

2024-04-02

Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis

Abstract://static.cambridge.org/content/id/urn%3Acambridge.org%3Aid%3Aarticle%3AS0022109024000255/resource/name/firstPage-pdf-S0022109024000255a.jpg

economics,business, finance
To Be or Not to Be a Female Gamer: A Qualitative Exploration of Female Gamer Identity

Daria J Kuss,Anne Marie Kristensen,A Jess Williams,Olatz Lopez-Fernandez

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph19031169

2022-01-21

Abstract:The literature on online gaming has generally focused on male gamers and has been dominated by negative aspects of gaming. The present study addresses the gender gap in this field by exploring experiences of female gamers further by unravelling several positive experiences alongside some potentially harmful tendencies connected to gaming, including female gamers' wishes and ambitions for their future gaming. A total of 20 female adult gamers across Europe were interviewed and results were analysed using thematic analysis. Four main themes were identified: (i) to be or not to be a (female) gamer; (ii) improving social skills and levelling up on mental health; (iii) not always a healthy escape; and (iv) there is more to explore. The present study is one of few empirical studies regarding the construction of self-image, and experiences of female gamers. It has showed participants have a history as gamers from adolescence, but still face problems derived from the stigmatised internal gender self-image. Externally, female gamer stigmatisation may result in sexism, gender violence, harassment, and objectification. Additionally, females may decide against identifying as gamers, engaging in social gaming interaction, or hold back from online gaming in general, thereby missing out on the opportunities for recreation as well as social and psychological benefits that gaming brings. There is, therefore, urgent need for more research and actions to promote change, equity, education, and security for female gamers as well as their male counterparts. Game developers would benefit from understanding this large gamer demographic better and tailoring games for women specifically.
Sexist games=sexist gamers? A longitudinal study on the relationship between video game use and sexist attitudes

Johannes Breuer,Rachel Kowert,Ruth Festl,Thorsten Quandt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1089/cyber.2014.0492

Abstract:From the oversexualized characters in fighting games, such as Dead or Alive or Ninja Gaiden, to the overuse of the damsel in distress trope in popular titles, such as the Super Mario series, the under- and misrepresentation of females in video games has been well documented in several content analyses. Cultivation theory suggests that long-term exposure to media content can affect perceptions of social realities in a way that they become more similar to the representations in the media and, in turn, impact one's beliefs and attitudes. Previous studies on video games and cultivation have often been cross-sectional or experimental, and the limited longitudinal work in this area has only considered time intervals of up to 1 month. Additionally, previous work in this area has focused on the effects of violent content and relied on self-selected or convenience samples composed mostly of adolescents or college students. Enlisting a 3 year longitudinal design, the present study assessed the relationship between video game use and sexist attitudes, using data from a representative sample of German players aged 14 and older (N=824). Controlling for age and education, it was found that sexist attitudes--measured with a brief scale assessing beliefs about gender roles in society--were not related to the amount of daily video game use or preference for specific genres for both female and male players. Implications for research on sexism in video games and cultivation effects of video games in general are discussed.
Women's Self-Objectification Under Competition When They Believe Sex Is Power

Xijing Wang,Hao Chen,Zhansheng Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-022-02335-2

Abstract:Competitions are ubiquitous and their psychological consequences for women have not received sufficient attention. For this research, we tested whether competition, in either work settings or a broader form of competition for resources, would interact with the sex is power belief to result in self-objectification among women. This prediction was confirmed by a series of studies (N = 1416), including correlational studies, a quasi-experiment, and fully controlled experiments, with samples including company employees, MBA students with work experience, college students currently competing in a job market, and Mechanical Turkers. Competition (or a sense of competition) as a feature of the working environment (Study 1), a real state in life (Study 2), or a temporarily activated state (Studies 3-5) resulted in self-objectification among women who believe sex is power (Study 1) or who enter such a mindset (Studies 2-5). This effect further impaired the pursuit of personal growth (Studies 4 and 5).
Does Competitive Experience Affect Gender Difference in Economic Preference and Academic Performance

Yi Lu,Xinzheng Shi,Songfa Zhong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2717473

2016-01-01

Abstract:This study examines whether competitive experience affects gender difference in the economic preference and academic performance. By utilizing the provincial differences in college admission rates as an indication of competitive experience for students, we assess the effects on risk preference, trust preference, and academic performance. We find that after experiencing more competitive environment, females are more risk averse and less trustful, and perform better in more competitive environment, compared with their male counterparts. Our study suggests that observed gender differences may partially reflect the effects of schooling environment rather than inherent gender traits.

Does Concealing Gender Identity Help Women Win the Competition? an Empirical Investigation into Online Video Games

Why Do Women Pretend to Be Men? Female Gender Swapping in Online Games

Gender Differences in the Effect of Communication on College Students' Online Decisions

Uncovering Gender Stereotypes in Video Game Character Designs: A Multi-Modal Analysis of Honor of Kings

Gender and the Beauty Contest Game

Are There Gender Differences in Strategic Reasoning? Evidence from a Beauty Contest Game in China

Aggression in online gaming: the role of online disinhibition, social dominance orientation, moral disengagement and gender traits among Chinese university students

The Role of Social Presence in Relationships Among Gender Stereotypes, Sexism, and In-Game Sexual Harassment Among Young Korean Gamers

Freed or Trapped: Gaming Pleasures and Expression of Gender Identities in World of Warcraft among Chinese Players

Research on the Display of Female Elements by Chinese Online Game Female Players on the Social Media Platform Xiaohongshu

Exploring the Impact of Gender on Character Mechanics in Multiplayer Online Battle Arena (MOBA) Games

Understanding Gaming Perceptions and Experiences in a Women's College Community

Gendered Conversation in a Social Game-Streaming Platform

Applying the multi-threat framework of stereotype threat in the context of digital gaming

Gender bias in team-building activities in China

Female Video Game Players and the Protective Effect of Feminist Identity Against Internalized Misogyny

Gender, Competition, and Performance: International Evidence

To Be or Not to Be a Female Gamer: A Qualitative Exploration of Female Gamer Identity

Sexist games=sexist gamers? A longitudinal study on the relationship between video game use and sexist attitudes

Women's Self-Objectification Under Competition When They Believe Sex Is Power

Does Competitive Experience Affect Gender Difference in Economic Preference and Academic Performance