Equality Scale-Based and Sound Horizon-Based Analysis of the Hubble Tension

Zhihuan Zhou,Yuhao Mu,Gang Liu,Lixin Xu,Jianbo Lu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.107.063536

2023-01-01

Abstract:The Hubble horizon at matter-radiation equality (k(eq)(-1)) and the sound horizon at the last scattering surface [r(s)(z(*))] provides an interesting consistency check for the standard Lambda Cold Dark Matter (Lambda CDM) model and its extensions. It is well known that the reduction of r(s) can be compensated by the increase of H-0, while the same is true for the standard rulers k(eq). Adding extra radiational component to the early Universe can reduce k(eq). The addition of early dark energy (EDE), however, tends to increase keq. We perform k(eq)- and r(s)-based analyses in both the EDE model and the Wess-Zumino dark radiation (WZDR) model. In the latter case, we find Delta H-0 = 0.4 between the r(s)- and k(eq)-based datasets, while in the former case, we find Delta H-0 = 1.2. This result suggests that the dark radiation scenario is more consistent in the fit of the two standard rulers (k(eq) and r(s)). As a forecast analyses, we fit the two models with a mock k(eq) prior derived from Planck best-fit Lambda CDM model. Compared with the best-fit H-0 in baseline Lambda CDM model, we find Delta H-0 = 1.1 for the WZDR model and Delta H-0 = -2.4 for EDE model.