A New Perspective on Wise Proactivity: Configural Effect of Proactivity Process

Liyuan Li,Xiangyu Gao,Xiaoming Zheng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2022.13241abstract
2022-01-01
Academy of Management Proceedings
Abstract:Proactivity literature has come to realize that employee proactivity is a process including a set of actions rather than a one-off action (e.g., Bindl et al., 2012; Parker et al., 2010). We provide a new perspective about when is proactivity wise by examining configural effect of four elements of proactivity process (envisioning, planning, enacting and reflecting, Bindl et al., 2012). Specifically, we explore what configurations of high or low level of such four elements be sufficient to employees’ high or low performance and well-being (i.e., high or low burnout and role overload). Further, we include contextual factors (environmental uncertainty and leader trust) by examining the configural effect of proactivity process and such contextual factors, to broaden our understanding about the effect of proactivity process configurations. Using fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) across two studies, we find 11 original configurations. Further, we identify 4 primary and robust configurations from them by combining fsQCA and regression analysis. The primary and important results we find are :(1) high enacting alone is not sufficient for producing high performance; (2) when the other three elements are low, no matter the envisioning is high or low will lead to low performance; (3) no proactivity process configurations could lead to low burnout or low role overload, but leader trust could well buffer the burnout and role overload caused by proactivity process. Our research contribute to proactivity literature by providing a new process perspective to better understand the effect of proactivity, revealing a synergistic effect of proactivity prcoess configurations and going beyond the traditional regression analysis. Besides, our research first explore the effect of proactivity process empirically, and find a new point to examine action regulation process.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?