Improving Learner Reflection for TESOL: Pedagogical Strategies to Support Reflective Learningli‐shihhuangroutledge, 2021. 248 Pp. ISBN 9780367371388

Yani Xu,Xiangmei Yang,Lianrui Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ijal.12427

2022-01-01

International Journal of Applied Linguistics

Abstract:The peer review history for this article is available at https://publons.com/publon/10.1111/ijal.12427

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Towards Understanding Teacher Mentoring, Learner WCF Beliefs, and Learner Revision Practices Through Peer Review Feedback: A Sociocultural Perspective

Yang Gao,Xiaochen Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.17323/jle.2022.15962

2022-12-26

Journal of language and Education

Abstract:Background. The existing literature has focused on learner perceptions or beliefs about peer review tasks over the recent decade. However, little has been known about the relationships among learner beliefs about written corrective feedback (WCF), related teacher mentoring process, and learner revision practices. Purpose. We thus aimed at addressing the gap by exploring how teacher mentoring and learner WCF beliefs may inform learner revision practices in the peer-reviewed process. Methods. In this mixed-method study, we included four Chinese EFL students majoring in English as the participants and collected their WCF belief survey data. We also collected their actual practice data through PeerCeptiv, an online writing and rewriting platform. In addition, we traced the teacher mentoring practices and interviewed the participants about their beliefs and practices in the peer review and back-evaluation process. Results. Through the mixed-methods design, we reported our major findings: the student participants believed empathy and resonance was the primary advantage of peer feedback, and teacher mentoring facilitated them in understanding and performing the peer review and revision tasks; we also found the student review process consisted of evaluating, resonating, learning, and reflecting practices and the student revision process included crediting, arguing, correcting, and polishing practices. Implications. From a sociocultural perspective, we centered our discussion on these research findings by claiming that scaffolding in different forms work together enhance learner performance and student beliefs appear in a complex manner with student actual revision practices. We also offered insights for future studies and practical implications for language teachers.
ESL/EFL Learners' Responses to Teacher Written Feedback: Reviewing a Recent Decade of Empirical Studies

Rong Yu,Luxin Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.735101

IF: 3.8

2021-10-29

Frontiers in Psychology

Abstract:Teacher written feedback (TWF) has long been regarded as a necessary pedagogical tool for improving the writing proficiency of ESL/EFL learners, while student responses to this feedback can often reflect its effectiveness. This paper reviews 64 articles appearing in high-ranking journals during 2010–2021 in terms of research methodology, theoretical framework and main findings. Analysis of these articles reveals few studies adopted any theoretical frameworks to examine learner responses to TWF and suggests a need for longitudinal naturalistic studies adopting mixed methods and some theoretical framework such as sociocultural theory of mind (SCT) to better explain learners' dynamic engagement in response to TWF. The main findings of these previous studies reveal the diverse responses among learners at different language proficiency levels and in various sociocultural contexts. The results of the review indicate that future research could take classroom-based mixed-method research design to investigate learner variables.

psychology, multidisciplinary
A qualitative inquiry into undergraduates’ learning from giving and receiving peer feedback in L2 writing: Insights from a case study

Zhenhao Cao,Shulin Yu,Jing Huang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.stueduc.2019.08.001

IF: 2.704

2019-12-01

Studies In Educational Evaluation

Abstract:Although previous research has elaborated on the ways that students can learn from giving or receiving feedback, few qualitative classroom-based studies have examined the ways that students can learn (or not learn) from acting as both a reviewer and a receiver in a feedback group. This qualitative case study focused on the peer feedback experiences and practices of five groups of Chinese EFL university students and explored their perceptions of learning from giving and receiving feedback and the factors that meditated their learning. Data were collected from multiple sources, including drafts of essays, peer feedback, semi-structured interviews, video recordings of peer feedback activities and stimulated recall sessions. The findings showed that the participants perceived different levels of learning from giving and receiving peer feedback and displayed four distinct patterns of value placement: benefit from both giving and receiving feedback, benefit from receiving feedback only, benefit from neither giving nor receiving feedback and benefit from giving feedback only. The participants' learning was mediated by four factors: engagement with evaluation criteria, motivation for peer feedback, within-group differences in writing ability and group dynamics. Situated in an authentic L2 writing context at the tertiary level, this study provides insights into the ways that students learn from (or do not learn from) giving and receiving feedback and the potential factors that promote or limit students' learning from the reciprocal peer feedback process.

education & educational research,psychology, educational
Feedback, feedback-on-feedback and re-feedback: effects of written dialogic peer feedback on English as a foreign language writing

Yuhuan Zhao,Fuhui Zhang,Christian D. Schunn,Ping He,Di Li,Yifan Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02602938.2023.2278017

IF: 4.4401

2023-11-23

Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education

Abstract:Dialogic peer feedback has been recommended and increasingly used in English as a foreign language writing context, yet the specific effects of peer-to-peer written dialogue about feedback remain under-researched. Using a quasi-experimental design, this empirical study investigated the effects of the presence/absence of written dialogue between the peer feedback provider and receiver on students' provision of feedback, adoption of received feedback, improvements in writing quality, and attitudes towards feedback dialogue across a four-week writing program. The study drew on several data sources including feedback texts, revision texts, a questionnaire survey and monthly reflection journals of forty-one students. Results showed that students involved in the written dialogue demonstrated a generally positive attitude towards it and outperformed those without such a process by generating more accurate adoption, focusing comments to a greater extent on higher-order dimensions of writing (unity, support and coherence), and implementing better revisions. The dialogic process enhanced students' feedback literacy and engagement by improving their understanding of feedback, their linguistic and subject knowledge, and their agentic clarification and negotiation of revisions.

education & educational research
Peer feedback and teacher feedback: a comparative study of revision effectiveness in writing instruction for EFL learners

Ying Cui,Christian D. Schunn,Xiaosong Gai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07294360.2021.1969541

2021-09-01

Abstract:This study investigated the revision effectiveness of peer feedback in comparison with teacher feedback, before and after a peer feedback training intervention that was designed to be implementable in large teaching load contexts and with EFL students. Fifty-six EFL students across two different class sections received teacher or peer feedback before and after training across five different writing assignments, with feedback conditions manipulated within and between class sections. Results show that EFL peer reviewers can provide more meaning-focused feedback than do teachers and that the impact of each piece of feedback on revision quality improves after training.

education & educational research
Incorporating Peer Response with Teacher Feedback in Teaching Writing to EFL Learners: A Literature Review

Yuyao Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5539/elt.v15n3p48

2022-02-25

English Language Teaching

Abstract:Peer response has gradually gained popularity in teaching English writing to English as a Foreign Language (EFL) learners in recently years. A number of researches have proved its advantages while Chinese English teachers are still doubting its validity and possibility. This paper aims to prove that incorporating peer response and teacher feedback is advantageous to EFL learners’ English writing. It would start with the explanation of some key terms and then first examine the benefits of peer response to verify the necessity of introducing it to an English writing class for EFL learners. Then drawbacks of teacher feedback would be argued with the certification that it is corresponding to some advantages of peer response. Finally, the contribution of using peer response and teacher feedback together would be discussed to further attest the argument mentioned above. At the end of the paper, a conclusion will be made to generally summarize what has been discussed and how this relates to being a language professional. Hopefully, it could be informative and constructive for Chinese English teachers to take a closer step into the theoretical base of this teaching strategy which has been established by former researchers and seek for the possibility of its implementation in the real-setting classroom in EFL context.
Understanding the learning process of peer feedback activity: An ethnographic study of Exploratory Practice

Chunxian Zheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1362168811426248

IF: 3.401

2012-01-01

Language Teaching Research

Abstract:This ethnographic study attempts to find, reveal and understand the learning possibilities, from the social learning perspective, in the process of peer feedback activity in a College English classroom for non-English majors in China. The study reveals the nature of Exploratory Practice (EP), and the investigation is guided by EP principles, aiming at exploring the viability of the practice in this specific teaching and learning context. Through classroom observation, discourse analysis, discussion, interviews and drafts of students’ writing, the study finds five group cooperative patterns, represented by the five patterns of discursive interaction: collaborative, expert–novice, dominant–dominant, dominant–passive and passive–passive. Wherein the former two patterns witness the obvious reciprocal nature, the latter three seem not to. The subsequent classroom discussion reveals a general conformability of the teacher and students’ understanding of the virtues and problems of the activity, and the broadening of the teacher’s understanding in this social process. Meanwhile through discussion and interview, the practitioners reached a consensus that the teacher’s tutoring is necessary to turn the problems into possible learning opportunities where the learners act as the learning agents. The study also discussed the possible ways of the teacher’s tutoring in the activity in a specific context.

education & educational research,linguistics
A review of the ESL/EFL learners’ gains from online peer feedback on English writing

Siyi Cao,Siruo Zhou,Yong Luo,Tao Wang,Tongquan Zhou,Yizhong Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.1035803

IF: 3.8

2022-10-26

Frontiers in Psychology

Abstract:Peer feedback is essential in writing English as a Second/Foreign Language (ESL/EFL). Traditionally, offline PF was more widely favored but nowadays online peer feedback (OPF) has become frequent in ESL/EFL learners’ daily writing. This study is undertaken to probe into the gains of using OPF in ESL/EFL writing on the basis of 37 research articles published in core journals from 2012 till 2022. In order to accurately cover the previous researches, we capitalize on three methods to evaluate and analyze the data, i.e., database search, citation search and manual search. Results show that from the perspective of the ESL/EFL learners’ gains, the OPF is basically divided into two categories (cognitive OPF and affective OPF), involving eight aspects in all: face-based strategies, revision-based comments, writing performance, learning environment, reflection/critical thinking/responsibility, writing emotion, motivation, and attitudes; and OPF can be well supported by a set of theories like Process-oriented Writing Theory, Collaborative Learning Theory, Interactionist Theory of L2 Acquisition and Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory. By comparison, the gains from OPF outperform those from offline PF in many dimensions (e.g., face-based strategies), despite some overlaps (e.g., the shift of the role) that were revealed in several investigations. Based on the past studies, we propose some pedagogical implications on OPF from ESL/EFL writing, including accenting the “student-centered” teaching strategy, providing students with OPF on the basis of incremental knowledge, adopting OPF regularly in ESL/EFL writing activities to shape personalities and outlooks and putting OPF into its full play with recourse to abundant internet-based vehicles. This review is desired to provide a guideline for both the peer feedback practice and the upcoming scholarly researches with respect to EFL/ESL writing.

psychology, multidisciplinary
Integrating reflection into a mobile-assisted reading program for learning English as a second language in China

Fei Wang,Takaya Yuizono,Tzu-Yang Wang,Eunyong Kim,Yaqin Lu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2022.1067523

2023-01-18

Frontiers in Education

Abstract:The application of mobile technology in language education is gaining increasing momentum for its potential benefits, and scholars cast attention to issues such as learner motivation, learning effects and learner behaviors in the mobile learning process. Reflection is an essential part in learning as it can record learner behaviors, cultivate self-awareness of knowledge construction, facilitate cognitive growth, and promote academic achievement. Despite of the wide approval of reflection, not much study has been done concerning the application of reflection in mobile language learning process. Therefore, this study aims to investigate students' perception of a mobile-assisted reading program facilitated with reflective activities as well as their preferences for reflection modes adopted. The participants were 60 students from two classes in a Chinese college. Students read passages on mobile applications and completed a reflection in one mode every two weeks. Four modes (paper journal reflection, e-journal reflection, audio reflection, and collaborative reflection) were adopted in the study. The study lasted approximately nine weeks. At the end of the program, all students were required to complete an anonymous questionnaire concerning their learning perception. In addition, ten students were selected randomly to attend a semi-structured interview. A pretest and a posttest were conducted to observe students' language gains. A combination of quantitative and qualitative analysis was conducted with the data obtained. Results showed students generally approved of the effect of this mobile-assisted reading and their reading proficiency improved significantly after the program. In addition, most students favored reflective practices as a good way to stimulate interest, deepen understanding and promote reflective and summarizing abilities, but they didn't consider it a good method to monitor the learning process in the mobile-assisted reading program. As for the preference for reflection mode, most students favored traditional paper reflection and audio reflection, while collaborative reflection and e-journal reflection received the least support. The findings provided implications for educators and app designers. For educators, based on the understanding of students' age, learning experience, and possible preferences, they may create a good reflective environment with technical and instructional support, and then provide two or three popular modes for students to reflect on whatever they read. For app developers, some preferable reflection modes facilitated with stimulative measures may be offered to cater to more learners to conduct reflective activities.
Assessing reflection in English enhancement courses: teachers’ views and development of a holistic framework

Ken Lau

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02602938.2015.1048424

2015-05-29

Abstract:The debate about whether and how reflection should/can be assessed has so far yielded inconclusive findings. This paper intends to revisit and further this controversial issue within a specific disciplinary context: the assessment of reflection in English enhancement courses within a second-language environment. Students across majors taking the language enhancement courses in question are often required to provide written or verbal evidence to demonstrate their abilities to reflect, and in turn enhance their linguistic repertoires. However, a potential problem arises when the assessment of ‘reflection’ at times may become the assessment of learners’ English language proficiency, thus casting doubts about the validity and reliability of incorporating reflection as an assessment tool in our context. Drawing on analyses of seven English enhancement courses with a reflection component, and semi-structured interviews with 22 faculty members who had had the experience of assessing reflection, and/or developing assessment criteria for evaluating the quality of students’ reflection, their perceptions of assessing reflection fairly and the challenges encountered during the assessment process were brought to the surface. A holistic framework is proposed to address the challenges encountered, particularly with respect to the differences in emphasis that faculty members place on content vs. language.

education & educational research
Feedback seeking and student reflective feedback literacy: a sociocultural discourse analysis

David Carless,Stephanie Young

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-023-01146-1

2023-11-25

Higher Education

Abstract:A significant and somewhat under-exploited aspect of feedback literacy research lies in students’ feedback-seeking behaviors. This research charts progress in oral feedback seeking by means of a three-year longitudinal inquiry focused on the feedback literacy development of an undergraduate co-author. The study is framed through sociocultural learning theories and the notion of feedback encounters to illustrate how social and relational feedback interactions encourage meaning-making and feedback uptake. Data comprise the student’s reflective journal of feedback experiences; regular documented interactions between the two co-researchers; digitally recorded and transcribed feedback encounters over four consecutive semesters; and teacher feedback on completed assignments. Sociocultural discourse analysis is deployed to uncover how the student and her teachers used talk to co-construct shared thinking about assignment work-in-progress. Features of the selected feedback encounters include interthinking and the interweaving of cumulative and exploratory talk. Reflecting on feedback-seeking experiences over time stimulated student feedback literacy development through progress in preparing for, participating in, following up, and working with emotions in feedback encounters. Originality and significance lie in drawing conceptual linkages between feedback seeking, reflection, and the development of student feedback literacy and in exemplifying innovative ways of conducting feedback research on the student experience of feedback. We introduce the concept of student reflective feedback literacy to represent considered analysis of feedback evidence and experiences informing ongoing efforts to seek, make sense of, and use feedback. Incorporating within the curriculum sustained opportunities for student reflections about feedback carries the potential to develop student feedback literacy and merits further investigation.

education & educational research
Supporting reflection in technology-enhanced learning

Külli Kori,Margus Pedaste,Äli Leijen,Mario Mäeots

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2013.11.003

IF: 10.207

2014-01-01

Educational Research Review

Abstract:Reflection has been regarded as a process that leads to deeper learning and a more complex and integrated knowledge structure. Various studies argue that reflection is more effective when given specific support. Technology-enhanced learning environments are recognised as effective facilitators that support students’ learning. This study reviews the reflection support that research papers from the past six years (2007–2012) have introduced in the context of technology-enhanced learning. Three support types are distinguished: technical tools, technical tools with predefined guidance, and technical tools with human interaction guidance. Most of the analysed articles relied on empirical evidence about the effectiveness of reflection support. Some articles gave only argumentative discussion to justify how reflection should be supported. It was showed that all these types of support could have a positive effect on reflection; however, not all the studies found positive effect.

education & educational research
Teaching Chinese as a second or foreign language to non-Chinese learners in mainland China (2014–2018)

Yang Gong,Xuesong Gao,Boning Lyu,Yang (Frank) Gong,Xuesong (Andy) Gao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0261444819000387

2020-02-24

Language Teaching

Abstract:This review involved 60 articles chosen from 336 empirical studies identified in five leading journals on the learning and teaching of Chinese as a second or foreign language in mainland China during the period 2014–2018. The selected studies document Chinese researchers' efforts to improve the teaching and learning of the Chinese language in terms of language pedagogy, language learning and teacher development. We contend that these studies on the teaching and learning of Chinese as a second or foreign language (CSL/CFL) can contribute to the advancement of second/foreign language education theories even though they were largely conducted to address local needs and interests in the Chinese context. Unfortunately, the impact of these studies on international language education research and pedagogical development remains limited and peripheral. For this reason, this review concludes with recommendations for Chinese researchers and journal editors in the field of Chinese language teaching and learning research on how to promote quality empirical research and enhance their contributions to second/foreign language education research.

education & educational research,linguistics
Incorporating peer feedback in writing instruction: examining its effects on Chinese English-as-a-foreign-language (EFL) learners’ writing performance

Zhiqing Xu,Lawrence Jun Zhang,Judy M. Parr

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/iral-2021-0078

2022-02-09

International Review of Applied Linguistics in Language Teaching

Abstract:Abstract Peer feedback has been widely employed in writing instruction in various contexts. However, studies into its effects on improving students’ writing performance, particularly its long-term effects, are under-represented. To fill the research gap, we adopted a pre-, post-, and delayed post-test quasi-experimental design to investigate the long-term effects of a peer feedback intervention. Two intact classes of EFL students from a Chinese university were recruited, with one class participating in peer feedback activities and the other class receiving collective feedback from their teacher for one semester. Their compositions for the pre-, post-, delayed post-tests were compared in terms of the overall text quality, content, organization, complexity, accuracy, and fluency (CAF). The results show that the experimental group participants made significant improvements in the overall text quality, content, organization, and accuracy in the post-test and they retained the improvements 12 weeks after the intervention. In addition, they outperformed their counterparts receiving collective feedback in the overall text quality and organization in the post- and delayed post-tests, and in accuracy only in the delayed post-test. Results suggest that peer feedback could help Chinese EFL learners make progress in writing.
Examining the Current State of Reflective Teaching Practices Among Newly Appointed Primary School Teachers

Yanshuang Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26689/jcer.v7i12.5819

2023-12-25

Journal of Contemporary Educational Research

Abstract:This study focused on three newly appointed primary school teachers in City D as research subjects. Utilizing research methods such as interviews, text analysis, and observation, the findings revealed that these teachers exhibited a substantial grasp of teaching reflection. The predominant emphasis in their teaching reflection levels was observed at the technical reasonable reflection and practical action reflection stages. To enhance the reflection levels of these novice teachers, it is recommended to foster their professional ethics, institute a diverse training system, and enhance the school’s infrastructure and institutional support systems.
College English Language Teaching Reform and EFL Lecturers’ Reflection on Teaching: A Case Study in China

Zhiyong Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.22158/jecs.v6n2p93

2022-05-09

Journal of Education and Culture Studies

Abstract:With the rapid development of newly improved colleges and universities across China, there was a commensurate need for English as a Foreign Language teaching and learning (EFL). As a result, China’s Ministry of Education initiated the College English Language Teaching Reform (CELTR) to improve English language teaching and learning at tertiary institutions in the country. The purpose of this article was to look into EFL lecturers’ perceptions of the CELTR and see how much the CELTR had improved their teaching reflection, which in turn influenced the CELTR’s effect and implementation. A total of 92 EFL lecturers from a newly renovated university in Nanyang City, Central China, participated in the study. Purposive sampling was used to obtain data for the study, which included a questionnaire and semi-structured interviews with eight EFL lecturers. The findings revealed that EFL lecturers had a reasonable degree of awareness and knowledge of the CELTR, that lecturers’ reflection on teaching had improved slightly since the CELTR was implemented, and that EFL lecturers’ intents and use of reflection on teaching had increased under the CELTR. They used many ways to undertake reflection on teaching. The findings revealed that EFL lecturers constantly reflected on their teaching contents, methods, and events during the CELTR implementation process in order to improve their teaching practice and better meet the students’ specific needs, and they believed that reflection on teaching could not be separated from teaching practice.
New Business Formation and Regional Development: A Survey and Assessment of the Evidence

M. Fritsch

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1858745

2011-05-01

Abstract:This paper reviews the current state of knowledge about the effect of new business formation on regional development. After a brief sketch of the origins of research on this issue, the main results of different lines of inquiry are discussed. Main issues are the development of start-up cohorts, the relative magnitude of direct and indirect effects, and results by type of entry and by industry, as well as differences in the effects that have been found for different types of regions. After interpreting the results based on a common framework, I put forward a number of important questions for further research and draw some conclusions for entrepreneurship policy.
Examining the effects of self-regulated learning-based teacher feedback on English-as-a-foreign-language learners’ self-regulated writing strategies and writing performance

Li Francoise Yang,Yanhong Liu,Zhiqing Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.1027266

IF: 3.8

2022-11-08

Frontiers in Psychology

Abstract:The current study examines the effect of teacher feedback on fostering self-regulated English-as-a-foreign-language (EFL) writers. Adopting a quasi-experimental design, this study was conducted among seventy students from two parallel intact English writing classes at the tertiary level. While conventional feedback at the level of task was used in the control group, feedback at the level of process and self-regulation with supplementary activities was adopted for the treatment group. This SRL-based feedback intervention lasted one semester. Students took a pre-test, an immediate and a delayed post-test to measure their improvement in English writing performance, as well as their use of writing strategies for self-regulated learning (SRL), with a questionnaire. The results reveal that the SRL-based feedback intervention had a positive impact on EFL student writers’ writing performance as well as their reported use of SRL writing strategies. While the analytic writing scores for the subcategories of organisation, vocabulary and content significantly increased over time for the treatment group, there was little change in language use. ANCOVA analyses suggest significantly positive results for the treatment group in the improvement of SRL writing strategies with goal-oriented monitoring, knowledge rehearsal, feedback handling, and interest enhancement, and the intervention also developed the use of SRL strategies for text processing, idea planning, motivational self-talk, and emotional control.

psychology, multidisciplinary
The development of student feedback literacy: the influences of teacher feedback on peer feedback

Ye Han,Yueting Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02602938.2019.1689545

2019-11-18

Abstract:Although the concept of student feedback literacy has drawn increasing attention in higher education, empirical research on this matter is still in its infancy. In the area of peer feedback, little research has investigated the role of teacher follow-up feedback on peer feedback in the development of student feedback literacy. To address the research gap, a multiple-case study of three Chinese master's students enrolled in an academic writing course was conducted, drawing on the students' drafts with peer feedback, teacher written feedback on that peer feedback, semi-structured interviews, retrospective verbal reports, observation field notes and class documents. Three students' epistemological and practical knowledge about, attitudes towards, and self-efficacy beliefs in peer feedback were found to improve at different paces and to different degrees. However, considerable individual variations were observed with two high-achieving, highly motivated participants becoming more feedback-literate than their under-achieving, minimally motivated peer. Teacher feedback on peer feedback was found to have distinct impacts on individual students, depending on learner factors including language ability, beliefs and motivation. These findings suggest that teacher feedback on peer feedback, if consistently provided and compatible with learner factors, can scaffold both cognitive and social-affective aspects of student feedback literacy.

education & educational research
Attitudes Towards Peer Review and Reaction to Peer Feedback in Chinese EFL Writing Classrooms

Meihua Liu,Yanhui Chai

2009-01-01

Abstract:Writing is a major skill that EFL students need to develop. And the realities of the school setting often cause a student to believe only writing for teachers to be writing that “counts” because teachers are often considered authority figures and the people who give grades (Earls, 1987). Thus, students may be more willing to revise their compositions according to teacher feedback. But for teachers to review each student’s paper throughout the drafting process is painfully time consuming. It is especially so with Chinese EFL teachers and learners (Qi, 2004; Wang, 2004). To ease the pain, some suggest that peer review is a good choice which can be applied to the foreign language classroom at any level (Byrd, 1994). Though numerous studies show that peer review is effective in improving student writing (Althauser & Darnall, 2001; Bean, 1996; Byrd, 1994; DiPardo & Freedman, 1988; Mendonca & Johnson, 1994), this issue has not been adequately researched in China. Situated in a Chinese university EFL writing class, the present study sought to examine students’ attitudes toward and reaction to peer review.

Improving Learner Reflection for TESOL: Pedagogical Strategies to Support Reflective Learningli‐shihhuangroutledge, 2021. 248 Pp. ISBN 9780367371388

Towards Understanding Teacher Mentoring, Learner WCF Beliefs, and Learner Revision Practices Through Peer Review Feedback: A Sociocultural Perspective

ESL/EFL Learners' Responses to Teacher Written Feedback: Reviewing a Recent Decade of Empirical Studies

A qualitative inquiry into undergraduates’ learning from giving and receiving peer feedback in L2 writing: Insights from a case study

Feedback, feedback-on-feedback and re-feedback: effects of written dialogic peer feedback on English as a foreign language writing

Peer feedback and teacher feedback: a comparative study of revision effectiveness in writing instruction for EFL learners

Incorporating Peer Response with Teacher Feedback in Teaching Writing to EFL Learners: A Literature Review

Understanding the learning process of peer feedback activity: An ethnographic study of Exploratory Practice

A review of the ESL/EFL learners’ gains from online peer feedback on English writing

Integrating reflection into a mobile-assisted reading program for learning English as a second language in China

Assessing reflection in English enhancement courses: teachers’ views and development of a holistic framework

Feedback seeking and student reflective feedback literacy: a sociocultural discourse analysis

Supporting reflection in technology-enhanced learning

Teaching Chinese as a second or foreign language to non-Chinese learners in mainland China (2014–2018)

Incorporating peer feedback in writing instruction: examining its effects on Chinese English-as-a-foreign-language (EFL) learners’ writing performance

Examining the Current State of Reflective Teaching Practices Among Newly Appointed Primary School Teachers

College English Language Teaching Reform and EFL Lecturers’ Reflection on Teaching: A Case Study in China

New Business Formation and Regional Development: A Survey and Assessment of the Evidence

Examining the effects of self-regulated learning-based teacher feedback on English-as-a-foreign-language learners’ self-regulated writing strategies and writing performance

The development of student feedback literacy: the influences of teacher feedback on peer feedback

Attitudes Towards Peer Review and Reaction to Peer Feedback in Chinese EFL Writing Classrooms