Abstract:Background Research suggests that teachers’ views of their students’ capabilities matter when attempting to accomplish instructional reform, particularly in settings serving historically marginalized groups of students. However, to date, this issue has received minimal attention in the scholarship and practice of mathematics instructional reform. Purpose This study offers a large-scale snapshot of middle-grades teachers’ views of their students’ mathematical capabilities in the context of instructional reform. It contributes to the field's understanding of the learning demands for teachers inherent in achieving a vision of high-quality mathematics instruction and suggests potentially critical foci for professional learning opportunities. Setting The study took place in two large urban districts pursuing ambitious reform in middle-grades mathematics. Participants Participants included 122 middle-grades mathematics teachers. Research Design The study consisted of a qualitative analysis of semistructured interviews conducted with each of 122 teachers regarding their perspectives on the district's reform efforts, including their views of their students’ mathematical capabilities in relation to the reform. Conceptually, we approached our analysis of teachers’ views of their students’ mathematical capabilities by attending to how they framed a common problem of practice—students facing difficulty in mathematics—diagnostically (i.e., how they explained the source of students’ difficulty) and prognostically (i.e., what they described doing to support students facing difficulty). Analysis also focused on patterns in the relations between teachers’ diagnostic and prognostic framings. Findings On the whole, most teachers did not view all of their students as capable of participating in rigorous mathematical activity. Most teachers attributed at least some of their students’ difficulty to inherent traits of the students or deficits in their families or communities, and most described lowering the cognitive demand of an activity if they perceived that students were facing difficulty. Moreover, our analysis of the relations between teachers’ diagnostic and prognostic framing revealed that even when teachers explained students’ difficulty in terms of instructional opportunities, thereby taking responsibility for their students’ learning, they did not necessarily respond in ways that would enable students to participate substantially in rigorous mathematical activity. Conclusions Findings suggest that a significant challenge in accomplishing ambitious reform entails supporting shifts in how teachers view their students’ capabilities along two dimensions: how teachers explain the source of students’ difficulties in mathematics and how they address such difficulties. Implications for designing professional learning opportunities to support productive shifts in teachers’ views of their students’ capabilities are discussed.

The impact of mathematics teachers’ professional competence on instructional quality and students’ mathematics learning outcomes

How do students' attitudes and mathematics teachers' self-efficacy impact students' achievement in mathematics?

Three Foci of Mathematic Teachers' Considerations in Evaluation of School Students' Achievements

Impacts of classroom teaching practices on students’ mathematics learning interest, mathematics self-efficacy and mathematics test achievements: a secondary analysis of Shanghai data from the international video study Global Teaching InSights

A Comparative Study of High School Students' Math Achievement and Attitudes: Do Math Teacher Qualifications Matter?

Relationship between pre-service mathematics teachers’ knowledge, beliefs and instructional practices in China

Classroom Quality and Adolescent Student Engagement and Performance in Mathematics: A Multi-Method and Multi-Informant Approach

The significance of mathematical knowledge in teaching elementary methods courses: perspectives of mathematics teacher educators

Does School-Level Instructional Quality Matter for School Mathematics Performance? Comparing Teacher Data across Seven Countries

Middle school mathematics pre-service teachers’ content knowledge, confidence and self-efficacy

Research on the Cognition of Pre-service High School Mathematics Teachers for Implementing Mathematical Abstract Literacy

Growth of professional noticing of mathematics teachers: a comparative study of Chinese teachers noticing with different teaching experiences

The Impact of Mathematics Teacher Quality on Student Achievement in Oman and Taiwan

Students’ Perceived Mathematics Teacher Competence: Longitudinal Associations with Learning Outcomes and Choice of College Major

Teachers’ Views of Students’ Mathematical Capabilities: Challenges and Possibilities for Ambitious Reform

Understanding Students’ Mathematical Thinking for Effective Teaching: A Comparison Between Expert and Nonexpert Chinese Elementary Mathematics Teachers

Capturing the subject-specific quality of mathematics instruction: How do expert judgments relate to students' assessments of the quality of their own learning and understanding?

Understanding Chinese mathematics teaching: how secondary mathematics teachers’ beliefs and knowledge influence their teaching in mainland China

What Constitutes Effective Mathematics Instruction: A Comparison of Chinese Expert and Novice Teachers’ Views

Towards a Framework of Mathematical Competencies in China

Analysis of Factors Influencing the Quality of Teaching Mathematics and Applied Mathematics under the Orientation of OBE Philosophy