Frontiers: Framing Price Increase As Discount: A New Manipulation of Reference Price

Sungsik Park,Man Xie,Jinhong Xie

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1287/mksc.2022.1402

2023-01-01

Marketing Science

Abstract:This paper investigates a newly observed pricing practice by which a seller frames a price premium as a discount by simultaneously increasing the price and introducing a list price.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

When “More” Seems Like Less: Differential Price Framing Increases the Choice Share of Higher-Priced Options

Thomas Allard,David J. Hardisty,Dale Griffin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0022243719851490

IF: 6.1

2019-07-11

Journal of Marketing Research

Abstract:Four experiments supported by six supplemental studies show that premium but higher-priced products (e.g., direct flights, larger-capacity data storage devices) are more popular when the additional cost is made explicit using differential price framing (DPF; e.g., “for $20 more”) rather than being left implicit, as in standard inclusive price framing (IPF; e.g., “for $60 total”). The DPF effect is driven by pricing focalism: relative to IPF, DPF creates a focus on the price difference, which, because it is smaller than the total price, leads to lower perceived expensiveness and thus greater choice share for the premium option. This price framing effect is robust to displaying the total cost of the purchase, bad deals, and easy-to-compute price differences, and it appears to be uniquely effective in pricing contexts. However, DPF effects are reduced among consumers who adopt a slow and effortful decision process. These findings have implications for research on price partitioning, the design of effective pricing strategy, the sources of expensiveness perceptions in the marketplace, and consumer welfare.

business
The Illusion of Double‐Discount: Using Reference Points in Promotion Framing

Han Gong,Jianxiong Huang,Kim Huat Goh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/jcpy.1102

IF: 4.551

2019-01-01

Journal of Consumer Psychology

Abstract:Double‐discount is an effective format for promoting purchase decisions. However, extant literature has overlooked how temporal order of discounts applied affects consumers’ purchase decisions. In this paper, we show that the sequence of discount magnitude (e.g., 10% followed by 40% vs. 40% followed by 10%) leads to biases in consumer judgment and influences the perceived appeal and purchase intention of the deal. We term this the double‐discount sequence effect. Using four experiments, we showed that double‐discount in an ascending sequence (e.g., taking 10% off, then an additional 40% off) is preferable over that in a descending sequence. We also found that discount application sequence—but not the presentation order—matters to consumers. Consumers anchor on the first discount they encounter and evaluate the second discount with respect to this first one.
Amount-Off Or Percent-Off? The Influence Of Framing Effect On Consumers' Purchase Decisions For Online Bargains

Zhao Da-Ying,Sun Wen-Jun,Xiao Lei

2016-01-01

Abstract:Price discount has been extensively employed by practitioners as a popular promotional tool both in the online and offline marketplace. However, research literature recognized price discount as a double blade: deeper reductions are perceived more favorably, they are also considered to be more skeptical, which lowering the overall appeal of the deal. Behavioral studies suggested that consumers' reactions to price discount are not always positive. Some of them feel skeptical about the magnitude claimed by dealers, or arouse suspicion of the product quality or the motives of the sellers. As a result, the promotional campaigns frequently achieve unexpected outcomes. To form a more comprehensive understanding of consumers' perception about price discount, this paper adopts the framework of price framing effect to explore individuals' different responses in face of the deep price discount. Using empirical data collected from Groupon.com, the current work suggests that discount framing (percent-off vs. amount-off) has a significant impact on consumers' evaluation of the promotion offering. Higher levels of reduction framed with percentage form may be viewed with suspicion about the product quality, thus exerting a negative influence on deal perception. Whereas, promotions phrased in dollar-off format are more likely to be associated with the reduction of monetary sacrifice thus increasing the overall appeal of the product. The results are expected to provide a more clear vision about consumers response to price reduction with different discount framing and help the practitioners to design more efficient promotional tactics.
A Conceptual replication of the differential price framing effect in the field

Sören Köcher,Markus Husemann-Kopetzky,Marie Schirmbeck,Melina Hess,Fabian Gmeindl,Samuel Hess

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11002-023-09690-7

IF: 3.426

2023-07-15

Marketing Letters

Abstract:Across a series of 10 laboratory and online studies, Allard, Hardisty, and Griffin (2019) demonstrated an increased preference for premium, higher-priced products over standard products when consumers were presented with the additional cost of the higher-priced option (i.e., differential price framing; e.g., "for 60 total"); a phenomenon referred to as the differential price framing effect. In this paper, we conceptually replicate this effect in a field experiment that focuses on the application of a differential price framing strategy to a specific product format; namely, multipacks of identical products. Consistent with the differential price framing effect, the present study shows—based on 45,626 add-to-cart events and 30,426 completed product purchases on an online retailer's website—that the choice shares of higher-priced options increase when a differential price framing strategy is used. However, compared to non-consequential add-to-cart activities, this bias is considerably less pronounced in actual purchase patterns.

business
When “More” Seems Like Less: Differential Price Framing Increases the Choice Share of Higher-Priced Options:

Thomas Allard,D. Griffin,David J. Hardisty

DOI: https://doi.org/10.25384/SAGE.C.4574387.V1

2019-07-11

Abstract:Four experiments supported by six supplemental studies show that premium but higher-priced products (e.g., direct flights, larger-capacity data storage devices) are more popular when the additional...

Business,Economics
High Price or Low Price? an Experimental Study on a Markdown Pricing Policy.

Junlin Chen,Yingshuai Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2019.12.001

IF: 6.4

2019-01-01

European Journal of Operational Research

Abstract:This study examines whether strategic customers' behavioral patterns remain consistent in different pricing scenarios under a markdown pricing policy. These customers' decision patterns have been widely discussed because they significantly influence the expected monetary output. Contrary to rational assumptions, the behavioral research literature indicates that customers' behavioral biases manifest in their reference dependency, risk and loss attitudes, and fill rate misperceptions. However, the relationship between behavioral biases and various pricing scenarios has not been carefully examined; accordingly, we conducted laboratory experiments to observe customers' behavioral performance in a series of pricing scenarios to provide pricing suggestions for sellers. Our experimental results demonstrate that behavioral factors reflecting risk and loss attitudes as well as reference dependency can clearly describe customers' behavioral biases. Meanwhile, our estimation shows that the degrees of risk and loss attitude are not constant, but depend on price settings: the lower the full price in the initial period, the higher the degrees of aversion to both risk and loss. Given such behavioral patterns, we suggest that sellers should set their full prices lower than the normative value when the fill rate in period two is low, and set them higher than the normative value when the fill rate in period two is high. (C) 2019 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Dynamic Pricing with Reference Price Dependence

Regis Chenavaz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5018/economics-ejournal.ja.2016-22

2016-01-01

ECONOMICS

Abstract:Abstract A firm that accounts for consumer behavior sets the selling price of a product considering the reference price of consumers. In the literature, a reference price is usually modeled as depending on past selling prices. That is, past selling prices implicitly constrain the current selling price of a product. In this article, the author explicitly measures this constraint with an optimal control framework. He works on the structural properties of a general demand function, which depends on both selling and reference prices. Analytical results prove the following claims. Adjusting reference prices effects increase the price elasticity of demand, the demand function becoming flatter. Thus, the reference price effect weakens the market power of the firm. Also, the reference price effect constitutes a main driver of the dynamics of the selling price. But contrary to intuition, selling price dynamics does not systematically imitate reference price dynamics.
The Framing Effect on Management Accounting Decisions——Illustrated by Transfer Pricing Decisions

Xiong Yanren,Qiu Guanhua

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1003-2886.2007.05.010

2007-01-01

Abstract:For the past few years,two trends have been paid close attention in western management accounting research.Firstly,more and more research methods have emerged and experimental research method has been prominent.Secondly,behavioral and psychological research achievements have been applied to management accounting study.In this article we try to utilize framing effect theory from psychology to study transfer pricing decisions with experimental research method.Our research illustrates that transfer pricing decisions are influenced by framing effect and the dissipation of the effect contributes to decision optimization.Our research develops a new research method for domestic management accounting while contributing to bridge the gap between academia and the practitioner community.
Two-period Pricing Strategy in a Supply Chain with Intertemporal and Horizontal Reference Price Effects.

You Zhao,Rui Hou,Xinggang Luo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03155986.2021.1985903

2021-01-01

INFOR Information Systems and Operational Research

Abstract:In practice, before purchasing products, customers would compare the current price with past observed prices (referred to as the intertemporal reference price effect) and retail prices of other sellers (referred to as the horizontal reference price effect). This study considers a two-period supply chain with one manufacturer who sells a product through two competing retailers. We assume that the manufacturer acts as the Stackelberg game leader, and both retailers act as followers. The manufacturer can quote the same or different wholesale prices for the two retailers, whereas both retailers can employ a pre-announced or responsive pricing strategy. We study the impact of intertemporal and horizontal reference price effects on the selection of pricing formats. Our results show that both retailers and manufacturers can benefit from intertemporal effects. However, the horizontal effect hurts the retailer's profit, but still improves that of the manufacturer. In equilibrium, the manufacturer sets different wholesale prices to retailers who would employ the pre-announced pricing strategy. Finally, we find that the intertemporal reference price effect plays a key role in the pricing strategy equilibrium of the manufacturer and retailers. Our results complement the dynamic pricing strategy literature and provide new managerial implications for supply chain management.
Optimal pricing strategy for new products considering reference price effect in advance selling

Wen Zhang,Yan Zhang,Xujin Pu,Zhenzhen Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/ro/2023102

2023-08-02

RAIRO - Operations Research

Abstract:Previous research has shown that retailers' operations and consumers' purchase choices are significantly influenced by reference prices. This study explores a retailer selling some new products to strategic consumers in advance selling, and addresses the impact of reference price effect on the advance selling strategy and corresponding pricing decisions. Consumers' choices are determined by their purchasing utilities which are dependent on the selling price in current period and the reference price. We first drive optimal selling prices and corresponding profits of the retailer under the scenarios of no advance selling, advance selling without considering the reference price effect, and advance selling with considering the reference price effect, respectively. We find an advance selling strategy is not always beneficial for the retailer. Besides, results present that the retailer benefits from considering reference price effects only if the positive reference effect is relatively high. Finally, numerical studies show that dynamic pricing is dominated by price commitment, which reaches the maximum when positive and negative reference effects parameters are both the highest.

operations research & management science
Research on Closed Loop Supply Chain with Reference Price Effect

Jie Xu,Nan Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10845-015-1038-4

IF: 8.3

2014-01-01

Journal of Intelligent Manufacturing

Abstract:This paper considers a closed loop supply chain with the manufacturer as the Stackelberg leader. The manufacturer faces three different reverse channels, i.e., (1) manufacturer-managed, (2) retailer-managed, or (3) third party-managed channels. The reference price affects the purchase decision of consumers. Based on game theory, we discuss the reference price effect on the performances across three decentralized reverse channels, and examine the impact of reference price parameter (i.e., reference price coefficient in this paper) on optimal strategies. We conclude that higher reference price coefficient results in lower manufacturer and retailer profits. However, the profit of the third party increases in the reference price coefficient. In addition, some meaningful insights can be derived by comparison without the reference price effect in our models. We found that the scenario without reference price effect is generally superior to that with reference price effect.
The Framing Effect of Coupon Value for New Products: an Empirical Study in China

Zhe Zhang,Bin Han

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09593969.2011.652643

2012-01-01

Abstract:Two experiments tested the coupon framing effect with both existing products and new products, whereby the percentage-off format (vs. cents-off format) held an overall advantage in consumers' value perception, thus leading to higher purchase intention. We also found that different product price levels (high vs. low) and product types (physical goods vs. services) moderated this framing effect. Moreover, the context of new products' purchase significantly made this effect more salient than that in existing products. These results could contribute to the guidance of price and promotion strategy for business practitioners, especially in new product launch management.
Strategic Analysis of the Pricing Mechanisms in an Online Book Supply Chain in the Presence of Reference Price Effects

Wenhua Hou,Yuwen Zeng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/jtaer16050084

2021-05-08

Journal of theoretical and applied electronic commerce research

Abstract:(1) Background: A binding recommended retail price has been used in several markets in a variety of forms, and the book market is a typical example. Publishers sell books to online retailers at a unit wholesale discount computed on the cover price. Retailers are then allowed to set the retail price. Therefore, if consumers regard the cover prices as reference points, then they may be more likely to purchase books if retail prices are lower than the cover prices. (2) Methods: We develop a Stackelberg game model for a book supply chain to investigates how reference price effects affect retailers and publisher’s pricing strategies. (3) Results: The results show that retailers will sell printed books at a discount only when the publisher’s wholesale discount rate is not high. Further, as the intensity of the reference price effects increases, (a) the lower boundary of the wholesale discount rate rises, (b) publishers’ profits increase and (c) retailers’ profits increase relative to the level of consumers’ e-books acceptance. (4) Conclusions: This result is related to the fact that the online retailer, such as Amazon and JD.com, like to invoke reference price effects in consumers’ minds by highlighting the printed book’s discount rate.

business
On the Non‐Equivalence of Trade‐ins and Upgrades in the Presence of Framing Effect: Experimental Evidence and Implications for Theory

Mahdi Mahmoudzadeh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/poms.13104

IF: 4.638

2019-10-31

Production and Operations Management

Abstract:Manufacturers of durable goods often buy back older versions of their products from customers to encourage them to switch to improved versions and to create control over product return streams in their closed‐loop systems. Classical models and conventional wisdom have long ignored that the framing of these buyback schemes, whether through trade‐ins or upgrades, can matter for theory. Using the reference‐point shift mechanism, we provide experimental evidence that the alternative frames are not equivalent and that the framing effect induces customers to change which prices they anchor to as their reference points for the price for their current version. We then use the experimental findings to extend a reference‐dependence version of the classical model of trade‐ins and upgrades and show how the behavioral extension modifies key predictions of the classical model and provides predictions more in line with today's durable goods markets.

operations research & management science,engineering, manufacturing
The Impact of Increasing Search Frictions on Online Shopping Behavior: Evidence from a Field Experiment

Donald Ngwe,Kris Johnson Ferreira,Thales Teixeira

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0022243719865516

IF: 6.1

2019-09-22

Journal of Marketing Research

Abstract:Many online stores are designed such that shoppers can easily access any available discounted products. The authors propose that deliberately increasing search frictions by placing obstacles to locating discounted items can improve online retailers’ margins and even increase conversion. The authors demonstrate this using a simple theoretical framework that suggests inducing consumers to inspect higher-priced items first may simultaneously increase the average price of items sold and the overall expected purchase probability by inducing consumers to search more products. The authors test and confirm these predictions in a series of field experiments conducted with a dominant online fashion and apparel retailer. Furthermore, using information in historical transaction data about each consumer, the authors demonstrate that price-sensitive shoppers are more likely to willingly incur search costs when locating discounted items. Our results show that increasing search frictions can be used as a self-selecting price discrimination tool to match high discounts with price-sensitive consumers and full-priced offerings with price-insensitive consumers.

business
The Framing Effects of Multipart Pricing on Consumer Purchasing Behavior of Customized Information Good Bundles

Kim Huat Goh,Jesse C. Bockstedt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1287/isre.1120.0428

IF: 4.9

2013-06-01

Information Systems Research

Abstract:Applying behavioral economic theories, we hypothesize that consumers have sticky reference prices for individual information goods, but their perceived value for customizable bundle offers can be significantly influenced by the framing of a multipart pricing scheme. The potential impacts of these framing effects are measurable changes in consumer behavior and sales outcomes. We conducted a series of behavioral experiments and a large-scale natural field experiment involving actual purchases of customized information good bundles to confirm and analyze the hypothesized effects. The results demonstrate a consumer's willingness to purchase a customized bundle of information goods, the size of the resulting bundling, and the consumer's perceptions of the transaction are each significantly influenced by the design of the multipart pricing scheme. These results hold even when the final price and size of a customized bundle are the same across differing schemes. We discuss the potential tradeoffs in economic outcomes that result from price framing (e.g., likelihood of sale versus size of purchased bundles) and the implications for information good retailers.

information science & library science,management
Agile Pricing: How Online Product Reviews Influence Firm Pricing Strategies

Juan Feng,Xin Li,Michael X. Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2510470

2014-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Prior works offer compelling evidence that on the demand side of the market, user-generated online product reviews play a very important role in informing consumers' purchase decisions. On the supply side, however, the interplay between online product reviews and firm strategies is less understood. We build an analytical model that differentiates products based on consumers' preference for tastes (horizontal differentiation) or quality (vertical differentiation). We show that a monopolistic firm is able to not only manipulate its pricing to influence online product reviews (thus influencing sales), but also adjust pricing dynamically in response to online word-of-mouth. Our model derives rich results on possible price trajectories. To test the analytical predictions, we conduct an empirical study using a panel data of prices and reviews. We adopt a difference-in-differences framework to address the endogeneity challenges. We find evidence that firms adjust pricing in response to online product reviews.
Framing Effect of Coupon Value for Products

Zhang Zhe,Fang Qianrong,Han Bin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-0334.2011.01.006

2011-01-01

Journal of Management Science

Abstract:For existing products and incremental new products,the effect of different discount formats on coupon value was examined by the experimental method.Then empirical study for the framing effect of coupon value of new products was conducted.The results show that frames of coupon value moderate the effect of coupon value.For existing products,two discount formats have no significant difference on the perceived price of low-level products.But for high-level products,there is significant difference on the perceived price between the two discount formats,and the cents-off coupons are more suitable for high-level products.However,the percentage-off coupon is more suitable for physical products and services.For incremental new products,the framing effect is more significant.The percentage-off is more suitable for low-level new products.However,for high-level new products,the high perceived price of the cents-off will enhance consumers′ purchase intention.For new products,two discount formats have no significant difference on the perceived price.But for new services,the purchase intention with the percentage-off will be stronger.Our study is of significant reference value to guidance in the practice of business management.
Dynamic Pricing with Reference Price Effect and Price-Matching Policy in the Presence of Strategic Consumers

Nenggui Zhao,Qiang Wang,Ping Cao,Jie Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01605682.2018.1510809

IF: 3.6

2019-01-01

Journal of the Operational Research Society

Abstract:In this paper, we consider a retailer that sells a product with high storage cost over a two-period horizon. The goal is to investigate the single and combined effects of reference price and price-matching (PM) on the purchasing behavior of consumers and determine how these affect the retailer?s optimal pricing decisions and optimal total discounted revenue. We first present a discrete-time dynamic pricing (DP) model over a two-period horizon with a reference price effect in the presence of strategic consumers. Then we subsequently extended to another DP model in which the retailer implements a PM policy. The results show that under the reference price effect, the retailer?s revenue will always decrease, even when a PM policy is implemented. The PM policy is not always beneficial for the retailer, especially when the discount factor is infinitely close to 1. Second, we propose a model misspecification approach to investigate the effect of the reference price. Furthermore, the value of a PM policy is discussed. We find that the value of a PM policy is generally best when the discount factor is at a threshold value and also that the value of PM is much greater in the presence of strategic purchasing behavior.
Price It High if It is Varied: Perceived Heterogeneity and the Effectiveness of Discount Framing Strategies for Travel Packages

Xia Wei,Shubin Yu,Xi Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/00472875231222263

IF: 8.933

2024-01-01

Journal of Travel Research

Abstract:In recent years, consumers have been confronted with the proliferation of package bundling (i.e., marketing multiple products or services together in a single package at a discounted price) in the tourism industry. This paper aims to investigate how different discount framing strategies affect consumers’ purchase intention of a vacation package. Through four experimental studies, this paper reveals that the perceived heterogeneity of a component influences the effectiveness of different discount framing strategies. In particular, consumers prefer the vacation package in which the high-heterogeneity component is not discounted, while the low-heterogeneity component is discounted. The effect of perceived heterogeneity on purchase intention can be explained by the perceived quality of the component. Therefore, the effect is mitigated when quality assurance cues are present.

Frontiers: Framing Price Increase As Discount: A New Manipulation of Reference Price

When “More” Seems Like Less: Differential Price Framing Increases the Choice Share of Higher-Priced Options

The Illusion of Double‐Discount: Using Reference Points in Promotion Framing

Amount-Off Or Percent-Off? The Influence Of Framing Effect On Consumers' Purchase Decisions For Online Bargains

A Conceptual replication of the differential price framing effect in the field

When “More” Seems Like Less: Differential Price Framing Increases the Choice Share of Higher-Priced Options:

High Price or Low Price? an Experimental Study on a Markdown Pricing Policy.

Dynamic Pricing with Reference Price Dependence

The Framing Effect on Management Accounting Decisions——Illustrated by Transfer Pricing Decisions

Two-period Pricing Strategy in a Supply Chain with Intertemporal and Horizontal Reference Price Effects.

Optimal pricing strategy for new products considering reference price effect in advance selling

Research on Closed Loop Supply Chain with Reference Price Effect

The Framing Effect of Coupon Value for New Products: an Empirical Study in China

Strategic Analysis of the Pricing Mechanisms in an Online Book Supply Chain in the Presence of Reference Price Effects

On the Non‐Equivalence of Trade‐ins and Upgrades in the Presence of Framing Effect: Experimental Evidence and Implications for Theory

The Impact of Increasing Search Frictions on Online Shopping Behavior: Evidence from a Field Experiment

The Framing Effects of Multipart Pricing on Consumer Purchasing Behavior of Customized Information Good Bundles

Agile Pricing: How Online Product Reviews Influence Firm Pricing Strategies

Framing Effect of Coupon Value for Products

Dynamic Pricing with Reference Price Effect and Price-Matching Policy in the Presence of Strategic Consumers

Price It High if It is Varied: Perceived Heterogeneity and the Effectiveness of Discount Framing Strategies for Travel Packages