Abstract:This paper was designed to shed light both on the ways in which teachers respond to student failure attributed to low ability or to low effort and on the ways in which primary school pupils interpret and react to these responses. In Study 1 60 Israeli primary school teachers stated what they would say to and feel about a student presented as failing because of low ability or low effort. As expected, teachers were more likely to respond to the low ability pupil with pity and offers of help and to the low effort student with anger and demands that he/she should have done better. Study 2 then asked 178 3rd and 6th grade children to infer teacher emotion, attributions for student failure, and subsequent achievement behaviours after reading that a teacher responded to a same‐age pupil in one of the following ways: ‘I expect to hear better answers than that from you’; ‘Let's see if someone else can help out’; and ‘Let me help you see where you went wrong so we can work out the answer together’. These responses were derived from Study 1 and were expected to create low effort, ‘helpless’ low ability and ‘constructive’ low ability attributional conditions respectively. The results for Grade 6 were consistent with attribution theory, since children rated teacher anger and effort attributions higher in the low effort than in the helpless low ability condition, and over all conditions greater inferred teacher anger enhanced predictions of subsequent effort by promoting causal attributions of student failure to insufficient effort. In contrast, Grade 3 children inferred greater anger in the low effort condition, but attributed failure to effort in all conditions and inferred teacher anger was directly and negatively correlated with predictions of subsequent effort. In addition, the results indicated that predictions for future achievement strivings were most positive at both ages in the constructive low ability condition. Implications for the development of attributional understandings and for practitioners interested in maintaining motivation after failure are discussed.

Digest Attribution Theory and Learner Motivation : Can Students Be Guided Towards Making More Adaptive Causal Attributions ?

Attribution Theory and Learning Motivation

Exploring the relative contributions of learning motivations and test perceptions to autonomous English as a foreign language learning and achievement

Interface Among Motivation, Strategy Application, Comprehension, and Attribution: an Examination of Taiwanese Adolescent Readers of English-as-a-Foreign-Language

Investigating the Relationships Between Language Mindsets, Attributions, and Learning Engagement of L2 Writers

Expanding the Motivation Construct in Language Learning

The Dual Nature of Motivation: Intrinsic and Extrinsic Drivers in Second Language Learning

THE FACTORS INFLUENCING ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEARNERS' MOTIVATION

Role of Motivation in Learning English Foreign Language on the Academic Achievements of Students in China

Exploring the Moderating Roles of Emotions, Attitudes, Environment, and Teachers in the Impact of Motivation on Learning Behaviours in Students' English Learning

Teacher communications and student interpretations: effects of teacher responses to failing students on attributional inferences in two age groups

A Motivational Story in Hong Kong: Generating Goals for Language Learners and Blended Learning Designers from a Mixed-Method Learning Analytics Approach in English for Academic Purposes

Examining the role of the learner and the teacher in language learning motivation

L2 MOTIVATION: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN PAST ATTRIBUTIONS, THE L2MSS, AND INTENDED EFFORT

Attributions for failure and success at primary school: a person-centered approach to causal dimensions

Language Learning Motivation as a Complex Dynamic System: A Global Perspective of Truth, Control, and Value

Unraveling Motivation in English Language Learning: Insights from Non-EFL University Students

Stimulating learning motivation of middle school students in biology curriculum by means of attribution theory

ATTRIBUTIONS TO FAILURE: THE EFFECTS OF EFFORT, ABILITY, AND LEARNING STRATEGY USE ON PERCEPTIONS OF FUTURE GOALS AND EMOTIONAL RESPONSES

The role of motivation on secondary school students’ causal attributions to choose or abandon chemistry

The Internal Structure of Language Learning Motivation and Its Relationship with Language Choice and Learning Effort