Abstract:The graph of a Bayesian Network (BN) can be machine learned, determined by causal knowledge, or a combination of both. In disciplines like bioinformatics, applying BN structure learning algorithms can reveal new insights that would otherwise remain unknown. However, these algorithms are less effective when the input data are limited in terms of sample size, which is often the case when working with real data. This paper focuses on purely machine learned and purely knowledge-based BNs and investigates their differences in terms of graphical structure and how well the implied statistical models explain the data. The tests are based on four previous case studies whose BN structure was determined by domain knowledge. Using various metrics, we compare the knowledge-based graphs to the machine learned graphs generated from various algorithms implemented in TETRAD spanning all three classes of learning. The results show that, while the algorithms produce graphs with much higher model selection score, the knowledge-based graphs are more accurate predictors of variables of interest. Maximising score fitting is ineffective in the presence of limited sample size because the fitting becomes increasingly distorted with limited data, guiding algorithms towards graphical patterns that share higher fitting scores and yet deviate considerably from the true graph. This highlights the value of causal knowledge in these cases, as well as the need for more appropriate fitting scores suitable for limited data. Lastly, the experiments also provide new evidence that support the notion that results from simulated data tell us little about actual real-world performance.

Learning Causal Bayesian Networks Based on Causality Analysis for Classification

Learning Cluster Causal Diagrams: an Information-Theoretic Approach

From Undirected Dependence to Directed Causality: A Novel Bayesian Learning Approach

Representing and Inferring Causalities among Classes of Multidimensional Data

A New Ensemble Learning Algorithm Combined with Causal Analysis for Bayesian Network Structural Learning

How do some Bayesian Network machine learned graphs compare to causal knowledge?

Causal Inference and Bayesian Network Structure Learning from Nominal Data

Causal datasheet: An approximate guide to practically assess Bayesian networks in the real world

A Full DAG Score-Based Algorithm for Learning Causal Bayesian Networks with Latent Confounders

Discovery of Causal Rules Using Partial Association.

Causal Associative Classification

Functional Bayesian networks for discovering causality from multivariate functional data

Learning-Function-Augmented Inferences Of Causalities Implied In Health Data

Bayesian Networks for Causal Reasoning in Situation Assessment

BN-Mapping:Visual Analysis of Geospatial Data with Bayesian Network

Fast & Efficient Learning of Bayesian Networks from Data: Knowledge Discovery and Causality

Bayesian Learning of Causal Relationships for System Reliability

Towards Causal Classification: A Comprehensive Study on Graph Neural Networks

Mining Causal Association Rules

Discovering Causal Relations From Cross-Sectional Data

Estimating Causal Effects from Learned Causal Networks