Habitat Selection of Sympatric Blue Sheep(pseudois Nayaur)and Red Deer(cervus Elaphus Alxaicus)during Rutting Periods in the Helan Mountains,China
Luo Ying,ZHANG Mingming,LIU Zhensheng,LI Zhigang,Hu Tianhua,WANG Jifei
2010-01-01
Acta Ecologica Sinica
Abstract:Resource partitioning is thought to be differential use of multiple resources,such as food and space. Knowledge about habitat relationships among sympatric herbivores is important to examine resource use. Habitat selection of sympatric blue sheep (Pseudois nayaur) and red deer (Cervus elaphus alxaicus) was studied in the Helan Mountains on the border between Ningxia Moslemism and Inner Mongolia Autonomic region from September to December 2007 and 2008. We collected data by direct observation and examination of fresh sites used by blue sheep and red deer in 15 drainages distributed throughout the study area. Eighteen ecological factors from 177 sites used by blue sheep and 154 sites used by red deer were measured on 21 transects established along the ridge in the whole study area. During rutting seasons,habitat use of blue sheep and red deer differed in most ecological factors,i.e.,vegetation type,landform type,dominant tree,aspect,slope location,shrub density,shrub height,coverage,slope,altitude,distance to water resource,distance to human disturbance,distance to bare rock,hiding cover,and tree height. Compared with habitat selected by red deer,blue sheep selected montane steppe dominated by Ulmus glaucescens,steeper slope,taller trees,less shrubs,taller shrubs,less vegetation cover,lower altitude,sunnier aspects,lower hiding cover,closer to water resource and bare rock. In semi-arid and rugged regions like Helan Mountains,distinct phenology promoted the utilization of different habitats by ungulates. Canonical scores indicated that habitats used by blue sheep were most separated from red deer during rutting periods. The Wilk's lambda exhibited a highly significant difference in blue sheep and red deer habitat selection during rutting periods (Wilk's λ = 0.123,χ2 = 679.172,df = 10,P 0.001). The Fisher linear function discriminated blue sheep habitats is:3.638×trees height+0.242×distance to the nearest trees+7.766×shrub height+0.663×distance to the nearest shrubs+0.232×vegetation coverage+0.191×slope+0.001×distance to water resource+0.008×distance to bare rock+0.307×hiding cover-31.078. The Fisher discriminant function of red deer habitat is:4.850×trees height+0.321×distance to the nearest trees+12.024×shrubs height+0.929×distance to the nearest shrubs+0.192×vegetation coverage+0.482×slope+0.002×distance to water resource-0.001×distance to human disturbance-0.003×distance to bare rock+0.511×hiding cover-50.787. Discriminating variables that improved a stepwise discriminant model included (in order of importance) slope,distance to human disturbance,hiding cover,distance to bare rock,trees height,distance to the nearest trees,distance to water resource,shrubs height,distance to the nearest shrubs,and vegetation coverage. Predicted accuracy of the model in classifying blue sheep and red deer habitats was 99.7%. These results suggested that differences in habitat selection were likely to have contributed to the coexistence of blue sheep with red deer during rutting periods (a period of food scarcity).