Abstract:We report ALMA observations of the neutral atomic carbon transitions [CI] and multiple CO lines in a sample of $\sim30$ main sequence galaxies at $z\sim1$, including novel information on [CI](2-1) and CO(7-6) for 7 of such normal objects. We complement our observations with a collection of $>200$ galaxies with coverage of similar transitions, spanning the $z=0-4$ redshift interval and a variety of ambient conditions from local to high-redshift starbursts. We find systematic variations in the [CI]/IR and [CI]/high-$J$ ($J=7$) CO luminosity ratios among the various samples. We interpret these differences as increased dense molecular gas fractions and star formation efficiencies in the strongest high-redshift starbursts with respect to normal main sequence galaxies. We further report constant $L'_{\rm [CI]2-1}$/$L'_{\rm [CI]1-0}$ ratios across the galaxy populations and redshifts, suggesting that gas temperatures $T_{\rm exc}$ traced by [CI] do not strongly vary. We find only a mild correlation with $T_{\rm dust}$ and that, generally, $T_{\rm exc} \lesssim T_{\rm dust}$. We fit the line ratios with classical PDR models, retrieving consistently larger densities and intensities of the UV radiation fields in submm galaxies than in main sequence and local objects. However, these simple models fall short in representing the complexity of a multiphase interstellar medium and should be treated with caution. Finally, we compare our observations with the Santa Cruz semi-analytical model of galaxy evolution, recently extended to simulate submm emission. While we confirm the success in reproducing the CO lines, we find systematically larger [CI] luminosities at fixed IR luminosity than predicted theoretically. This highlights the necessity of improving our understanding of the mechanisms regulating the [CI] emission on galactic scales. We release our data compilation to the community.

The Interstellar and Circumgalactic Media at Low and High Redshift As Traced by Atomic Carbon and Carbon Monoxide

Observations of neutral carbon in 29 high-z lensed dusty star forming galaxies and the comparison of gas mass tracers

A Comparative Study of the Ground State Transitions of CO and [C I] as Molecular Gas Tracers at High Redshift

Molecular gas excitation in the circumgalactic medium of MACS1931-26

The properties of the interstellar medium of galaxies across time as traced by the neutral atomic carbon [CI]

ALMACAL X: Constraints on molecular gas in the low-redshift circumgalactic medium

DIISC Survey: Deciphering the Interplay Between the Interstellar Medium, Stars, and the Circumgalactic Medium Survey

The Molecular Gas in Luminous Infrared Galaxies: a New Emergent Picture

The SUPERCOLD-CGM Survey. I. Probing the Extended CO(4-3) Emission of the Circumgalactic Medium in a Sample of 10 Enormous Ly Nebulae at Z 2

New Places and Phases of CO-poor/C I-Rich Molecular Gas in the Universe

The Panchromatic Circumgalactic Medium

The Properties of the Interstellar Medium within a Star-Forming Galaxy at z=2.3

Quantifying Dark Gas

The Circumgalactic Medium of Submillimeter Galaxies. I. First Results from A Radio-Identified Sample

Astrochemistry on Galactic scales

The SUPERCOLD-CGM survey: \\ I. Probing the extended CO(4-3) Emission of the Circumglactic medium in a sample of 10 Enormous Ly$α$ Nebulae at $z\sim2$

$α$-enhanced Astrochemistry: the Carbon cycle in extreme galactic conditions

The origin of cold gas in the Circumgalactic Medium

An investigation of the circumgalactic medium around z~2.2 AGN with ACA and ALMA

The effect of cosmic rays on the observational properties of the CGM