The Voynich Manuscript was written in a single, natural language

Raj V Ponnaluri
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01611194.2024.2414128
2024-11-13
Cryptologia
Abstract:The Voynich Manuscript (VM), or MS 408, preserved in Yale University's Beinecke Library was acquired by Wilfrid Voynich in 1912. The unreadable, bound vellum folios contain illustrations of plants, astronomical and astrological diagrams, female images, and a large volume of text. Linguists, paleographers, historians, and general enthusiasts have attempted to decipher the text. This work focuses on the morphology of VM, with a focus on the two-language and five-scribe theories of Currier and Davis, respectively. There are two main objectives of this work. One is to examine Currier's claim of two languages drawn from two hands and Davis' paleographic evidence that there were five scribes. The other is to evaluate if VM contains writing in a natural language or just gibberish. Following a comprehensive analysis of word types, token, ranks, characters, placement, and frequencies, this work proceeds to demonstrate that there is no evidence for two 'languages' or dialects. Second, with the aid of Zipf's, Brevity and Heap's laws, this work shows that VM contains natural language, as noted by Landini, Reddy and Knight, and Bowern and Lindemann. Word Token analysis suggests that Scribes 1–4 must have distributed the workload equitably, and that Scribe 5 may have been a late entrant.
mathematics, applied,computer science, theory & methods,history & philosophy of science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?