Abstract:Previous research found that people with higher level of psychopathy trait would endorse more to the harmful but beneficial action in traditional moral dilemmas. Three possibilities for this effect were confounded: People with higher psychopathy trait, 1) care more about the beneficial consequences; 2) care less about the “no harm” norms; 3) just prefer action irrespective of consequences and norms. A multinomial processing tree model named “CNI” was developed and claimed to dissociated these three possibilities. Four studies have applied CNI model to study the psychopathy-moral decision relationship. However, the CNI model presupposes the agent sequentially processes consequences-norms-generalized inaction/action preferences, which makes the estimated parameters biased and untenable. More recently, an alternative algorithm named “CAN” was developed based on the same data structure to overcome the limitations of CNI model. We applied CAN algorithm and reanalyzed the raw data of the four studies on psychopathy-moral decision relationship. The results demonstrated that people with higher psychopathy trait have weaker consequences and norms sensitivities, stronger overall action preferences, stronger inaction/action preferences irrespective of norms and consequences, and weaker moral principles obedience. Furthermore, the mediation and moderation reanalysis explorations demonstrated that instrumental harm and moral identity partly mediate the psychopathy-moral decision relationship and that perceived societal standards rather than personal standards when making moral decisions can alleviate the positive effects of psychopathy on overall action preference and action preference irrespective of norms and consequences. Present reanalysis exploration study clarified and deepened our insights on the relationship between psychopathy and moral decisions. Theoretical and methodological implications were also discussed.

Is the More Psychopathic More Concerned with Human Beings Overall? A Data Reanalysis Exploration

Psychopathy and Moral Decision Making: A Data Reanalysis Exploration

Prbm_a_226722 257..266

The Characteristics of Moral Judgment of Psychopaths: The Mediating Effect of the Deontological Tendency.

Psychopathy increases perceived moral permissibility of accidents.

CAN Algorithm: an Individual Level Approach to Identify Consequence and Norm Sensitivities and Overall Action/Inaction Preferences in Moral Decision-Making.

CAN Algorithm: An Individual Level Approach to identify Consequences and Norms Sensitivities and Overall Action/inaction Preferences in Moral Decision-making

Cross-Cultural Examination of Psychopathy Network in Chinese and U.S. Prisoners

Empathy and motivation for justice: Cognitive empathy and concern, but not emotional empathy, predict sensitivity to injustice for others

Exploring the neural correlates of (altered) moral cognition in psychopaths

Social preferences and psychopathy in a sample of male prisoners—a pilot study

Understanding interpersonal relationships and psychopathy

Prediction of dishonest behavior using the CNI model of moral dilemma judgment: a registered report

Examination of associations between psychopathy and neural reinforcement sensitivity theory constructs

Psychopathy and Violence in Criminals

Brain Basis of Psychopathy in Criminal Offenders and General Population

Impact of Antisocial Personality Disorder on Morality and Ethics

Towards understanding atypical social affiliation in psychopathy

Distinct neural activation patterns underlie economic decisions in high and low psychopathy scorers

A network analysis on psychopathy and theoretically relevant personality traits

Neural correlations of the influence of self-relevance on moral decision-making involving a trade-off between harm and reward