Abstract:Background and objective: Patient-ventilator asynchrony (PVA) is associated with poor clinical outcomes and remains under-monitored. Automated PVA detection would enable complete monitoring standard observational methods do not allow. While model-based and machine learning PVA approaches exist, they have variable performance and can miss specific PVA events. This study compares a model and rule-based algorithm with a machine learning PVA method by retrospectively validating both methods using an independent patient cohort. Methods: Hysteresis loop analysis (HLA) which is a rule-based method (RBM) and a tri-input convolutional neural network (TCNN) machine learning model are used to classify 7 different types of PVA, including: 1) flow asynchrony; 2) reverse triggering; 3) premature cycling; 4) double triggering; 5) delayed cycling; 6) ineffective efforts; and 7) auto triggering. Class activation mapping (CAM) heatmaps visualise sections of respiratory waveforms the TCNN model uses for decision making, improving result interpretability. Both PVA classification methods were used to classify incidence in an independent retrospective clinical cohort of 11 mechanically ventilated patients for validation and performance comparison. Results: Self-validation with the training dataset shows overall better HLA performance (accuracy, sensitivity, specificity: 97.5 %, 96.6 %, 98.1 %) compared to the TCNN model (accuracy, sensitivity, specificity: 89.5 %, 98.3 %, 83.9 %). In this study, the TCNN model demonstrates higher sensitivity in detecting PVA, but HLA was better at identifying non-PVA breathing cycles due to its rule-based nature. While the overall AI identified by both classification methods are very similar, the intra-patient distribution of each PVA type varies between HLA and TCNN. Conclusion: The collective findings underscore the efficacy of both HLA and TCNN in PVA detection, indicating the potential for real-time continuous monitoring of PVA. While ML methods such as TCNN demonstrate good PVA identification performance, it is essential to ensure optimal model architecture and diversity in training data before widespread uptake as standard care. Moving forward, further validation and adoption of RBM methods, such as HLA, offers an effective approach to PVA detection while providing clear distinction into the underlying patterns of PVA, better aligning with clinical needs for transparency, explicability, adaptability and reliability of these emerging tools for clinical care.

Attention-based Convolutional Long Short-Term Memory Neural Network for Detection of Patient-Ventilator Asynchrony from Mechanical Ventilation

Detection of patient-ventilator asynchrony from mechanical ventilation waveforms using a two-layer long short-term memory neural network

An Interpretable Multi-Scale Lightweight Network for Patient-Ventilator Asynchrony Detection During Mechanical Ventilation

An interpretable 1D convolutional neural network for detecting patient-ventilator asynchrony in mechanical ventilation

HADLN: Hybrid Attention-Based Deep Learning Network for Automated Arrhythmia Classification

[A Review on Automatic Detection Algorithm for Patient-Ventilator Asynchrony during Mechanical Ventilation]

Early Detection and Classification of Patient-Ventilator Asynchrony Using Machine Learning.

Identifying Patient–Ventilator Asynchrony on a Small Dataset Using Image-Based Transfer Learning

Automatic classification of patient-ventilator asynchronies with a 1D convolutional neural network: a pilot study

Patient-ventilator asynchrony classification in mechanically ventilated patients: Model-based or machine learning method?

Uncertainty-aware Non-Invasive Patient–ventilator Asynchrony Detection Using Latent Gaussian Mixture Generative Classifier with Noisy Label Correction

Improving detection of patient ventilator asynchrony by deep learning through data augmentation based on modeling of pressure support ventilation

Patient-Ventilator Asynchrony Detection via Similarity Search Methods

A Software Tool for Anomaly Detection and Labeling of Ventilator Waveforms

An adversarial learning approach to generate pressure support ventilation waveforms for asynchrony detection

Patient-Specific ECG Classification with Integrated Long Short-Term Memory and Convolutional Neural Networks

Automated evaluation of typical patient-ventilator asynchronies based on lung hysteretic responses

MetaVA: Curriculum Meta-learning and Pre-fine-tuning of Deep Neural Networks for Detecting Ventricular Arrhythmias based on ECGs

Machine Learning Methods Applied to Predict Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia with Infection via Sensor Array of Electronic Nose in Intensive Care Unit.

A Novel Method to Evaluate Patient-Ventilator Synchrony during Mechanical Ventilation

Detection of Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia in Intensive Care Unit Based on Support Vector Machine