How Machiavellian Middle Managers Gain Power

Fong T. Keng,Zhiyu Feng,Xiao-Ping Chen,Hu Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2022.178

2022-01-01

Academy of Management Proceedings

Abstract:Middle managers are important to organizations due to their unique position in the organization’s power hierarchy, whereby they need to frequently switch between downward and upward social exchanges. However, there is limited research on how they use their unique positioning to navigate the political landscape. To examine how middle managers leverage different power relations in the organization’s hierarchy to gain greater power, we focus on Machiavellian middle managers due to their tendency to be power-focused, flexible, and responsive to situational demands. Drawing from the Machiavellianism literature and power dependence theory, we theorize and test how and when Machiavellian middle managers “kick down” and “kiss up” to effectively gain power from below and above. Specifically, we theorize that Machiavellian middle managers exhibit abusive supervision towards their subordinates to gain coercive power, while building close guanxi (i.e., interpersonal connection) with their senior manager to obtain relational empowerment. Moreover, we theorize that these parallel positive indirect effects are strengthened when Machiavellian middle managers perceive high threat to hierarchy. Results from a lab experiment and a three-wave, three-source, three-level field study largely provide support for our theoretical model. Overall, our study demonstrates how Machiavellian middle managers are capable of effectively using different forms of social exchange to harness middle power.