Abstract:Replacing long-lived, rarely disturbed vegetation with short-lived, frequently disturbed vegetation is a widespread phenomenon in the Anthropocene that can influence ecosystem functioning and soil development by reducing the abundance of deep roots. We explore how sources and fate of soil CO 2 vary with organic substrate source, abundance of respiring biota (i.e., roots and soil microbes), season, and soil depth. We quantified multiple isotopic signatures of CO 2 (δ 13 C, Δ 14 C, δ 18 O) as well as concentrations and δ 18 O of free O 2 in the upper 5 m of soil at sites where root abundances and soil organic C have been previously quantified: in late-successional forests, cultivated fields, and ~ 80 y old regenerating pine forests growing on previously cultivated land. We hypothesized that soil CO 2 sources would vary across soil depth and land cover, reflecting varying abundances of organic substrates, and seasonally as the dominance of root vs. microbial CO 2 production changes through the year. δ 13 C–CO 2 revealed respiration of C4-derived substrates in cultivated fields particularly during the growing season. This effect was not evident in soils of regenerating pine or older hardwood forests, suggesting that ~ 80 y of pine inputs to reforested soils have been sufficient to dominate microbial substrate selection over any remnant, historic agricultural C4 inputs. Δ 14 C–CO 2 diverged by land use at 3 and 5 m, indicating that more recently-produced photosynthate is available for mineralization in forests compared to cultivated plots, and in late-successional forests compared to regenerating pine forests. At 1.5, 3, and 5 m in forested plots we observed evidence of respiratory demands on soil pore space O 2 . In these soils, we observed declines in [O 2 ] compared to other depths and to the agricultural plots and concurrent increases in δ 18 O of free O 2 , consistent with the idea that roots and heterotrophic soil microbes are more active where photosynthate is more available. The δ 18 O–CO 2 values, a likely proxy for δ 18 O of soil porewater, exhibited 18 O enrichment during the winter, when many sampling wells were flooded, compared to growing season values. These data suggest an isotopically-distinct and laterally-flowing source of CO 2 -laden porewater during winter months. Combined, these datasets document how ~ 80 y of forest regeneration can provide sufficient C inputs to mask any microbial mineralization of decades-old organic inputs, but belowground C inputs still lag those of late successional forests. We also infer that lateral and vertical flows of water can serve as a sink for biotically-generated CO 2 , and that where deep soil [CO 2 ] is lower due to lower root and microbial activities, production of carbonic acid is also diminished. Where reaction rates are weathering limited, a paucity of deep roots imposed by anthropogenic land cover change thus may limit the production of this agent of soil development and the C sink represented by the silicate weathering it can promote. The data suggest deep and persistent effects of the loss of deeply rooted long-lived vegetation on deep soil C storage and transformations that promote acid-dissolution weathering reactions that help form soil itself.

Younger Carbon Dominates Global Soil Carbon Efflux

The age distribution of global soil carbon inferred from radiocarbon measurements

Fast Transit of Carbon Inputs in Global Soil Profiles Regardless of Entering Depth

Most Root-derived Carbon Inputs Do Not Contribute to the Global Bulk Soil Carbon Pool

Beyond bulk: Density fractions explain heterogeneity in global soil carbon abundance and persistence

Most Root-Derived Carbon Inputs Do Not Contribute to Long-Term Global Soil Carbon Storage

Faster Turnover of New Soil Carbon Inputs under Increased Atmospheric Co2

The Knowns, Known Unknowns and Unknowns of Sequestration of Soil Organic Carbon

Global Depth Distribution of Soil Carbon Inputs Inferred from Belowground Net Primary Production and Root Biomass Profiles

A Dual Isotope Approach to Isolate Soil Carbon Pools of Different Turnover Times

Controls and relationships of soil organic carbon abundance and persistence vary across pedo‐climatic regions

Relationships between carbon age and CO2 efflux in agricultural and drainage ditch soils using the thermonuclear bomb pulse

5300‐year‐old soil carbon is less primed than young soil organic matter

Persistent biogeochemical signals of land use-driven, deep root losses illuminated by C and O isotopes of soil CO2 and O2

Global Patterns and Controls of Soil Organic Carbon Dynamics As Simulated by Multiple Terrestrial Biosphere Models: Current Status and Future Directions.

Particle‐Size‐Specific Radiocarbon Constraints Imply an Active Subsoil Organic Carbon Pool

The Carbon Transfer from Plant to Soil is More Efficient in Less Productive Ecosystems

Radiocarbon constraints imply reduced carbon uptake by soils during the 21st century

Climate and Litter C/N Ratio Constrain Soil Organic Carbon Accumulation.

Global stocks and capacity of mineral-associated soil organic carbon

Microbial Activity and Root Carbon Inputs Are More Important Than Soil Carbon Diffusion in Simulating Soil Carbon Profiles