Abstract:In case of existing concrete structures, the estimation of the characteristic strength values from limited data is a difficult, but important task. There are currently different commonly used estimation methods available, among which the classical coverage method, a Bayesian procedure with vague prior distributions (as mentioned in EN 1990) and the method described in EN 13791. There exists however currently no comprehensive framework in order to quantify the influence of these concrete strength estimation methods on the safety assessment of existing structures. In order to analyse this effect, a previously developed semi-probabilistic partial factor approach for the evaluation of existing structures is considered herein, namely the Adjusted Partial Factor Method. The influence of the different concrete strength estimation methods on the safety level of existing concrete columns is investigated, considering both the application of unchanged partial factors compared to new structures and partial factors adjusted according to the Adjusted Partial Factor Method. The performance of the different estimation methods are evaluated and compared using Monte Carlo simulations and FORM analyses. The relative performance of the estimation methods seem to be rather independent of the partial factor approach applied, however the Adjusted Partial Factor Approach allows to achieve a coherent performance with respect to a target reliability index and alternative reference period. The performance of the classical coverage method and a Bayesian method with vague prior information are comparable and yield a higher safety level when more than 5 test samples are considered. In case only very few concrete samples are used for the assessment (i.e. 3-5), the EN 13791 yields a comparable safety level, mainly due to the reduced variability with respect to the estimation error. Finally, the analysis also showed that for the investigated situation, taking more than about 8 test samples into account does not lead to an increase in assessed safety level. (C) 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Robustness based evaluation of a concrete frame considering the Eurocode design guidelines

A Multi-Level Structural Assessment Strategy for Reinforced Concrete Bridge Deck Slabs

Structural Robustness Assessment of Concrete Frames Considering Membrane Action Effects

Field Destructive Testing of a Reinforced Concrete Bridge Deck Slab

Influence of Concrete Strength Fractile Estimation on the Safety Level of Existing Structures Assessed Using the Adjusted Partial Factor Method

Influence of Quality Control of Concrete on Structural Reliability: Assessment Using a Bayesian Approach

Influence of Concrete Strength Estimation on the Structural Safety Assessment of Existing Structures

Evaluation of Bayesion Updated Partial Factors for Material Properties in Existing Concrete Structures

An adjusted partial factor method for temporary structures compatible with the Eurocode framework

Robustness evaluation and design of steel and steel‐concrete buildings according to current standards and recent research results

Numerical and Experimental Analysis of a Novel Real-Scale Test Set-Up for the Analysis of Tensile Membrane Actions in Concrete Slabs

Practical Reliability-Based Calculation Tool For The Post-Fire Assessment Of Concrete Beams

Catenary Behaviour in Concrete Slabs: Experimental and Numerical Investigation of the Structural Behaviour

Quantifying the Filtering Effect of Conformity Inspection on the Reliability of Reinforced Concrete Structures

Towards A Reliability-Based Post-Fire Assessment Method For Concrete Slabs Incorporating Information From Inspection

Parametric Study and Reliability-Based Evaluation of Alternate Load Path Design in Reinforced Concrete Slabs

Robustness: a practitioner's perspective

An approach for evaluation of the structural robustness of steel frames

Robustness of a Typical Beam-Column Concrete Structure Exposed to Fire

Conformity Control of Concrete Based on the “Concrete Family” Concept

Towards a Reliability‐based Post‐fire Assessment Method for Concrete Slabs Incorporating Information from Inspection