Impact of online closed-book examinations on medical students’ pediatric exam performance and test anxiety during the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic

Jingyan Wu,Ruo Zhang,Wenwei Qiu,Jianqing Shen,Jiuyuan Ma,Yiming Chai,Hao Wu,Liyuan Hu,Wenhao Zhou
DOI: https://doi.org/10.21037/pm-20-80
2021-01-01
Pediatric Medicine
Abstract:Background: Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has upended medical education, and medical students have had to take online courses and examinations during this pandemic. However, little is known about the impact of proctored online closed-book examinations (CBEs) on medical students’ exam performance and test anxiety during the COVID-19 pandemic and the contributing factors. Methods: This prospective study was conducted among all 134 third-year undergraduate medical students from Shanghai Medical College of Fudan University between February 24 and July 10, 2020. Responses to a self-designed 12-item online questionnaire about the impact of online examinations were collected. The final exam scores for classroom examinations in 2019 were collected for comparison. Results: A total of 120 (45 male and 75 female) students with a mean age of 21 years participated in the survey with a 100% response rate. The mean exam scores did not differ by school year, gender, degrees of anxiety and impact groups (P=0.931). Almost 97.5% of medical students experienced test anxiety during online CBEs. Female students (48.0%) were more vulnerable to a negative impact of online CBEs than male students (28.9%) and preferred (68.0%) closed-book classroom or open-book online examinations more than male students did (48.9%) (P=0.003 and P=0.019). The contributing factors included poor adaptation to online examinations (58.5%) and concerns about the unfairness of online examinations (41.5%). Conclusions: Test anxiety was common in students who lacked experience with online CBEs. Although online CBEs did not impact final exam scores, special attention should be paid to female students who are not adapted to online examinations. Sufficient instruction about the exam platform, individual-needs-based simulation tests prior to formal exams, and assurance of fairness during the online examination are beneficial to alleviate the negative impact of online examinations on exam performance and test anxiety. Future studies are needed to confirm these findings.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?