The Interpersonal Effects of Coworker Helping Behavior on Observers:Insights from Social Comparison Theory
NI Dan,ZHENG Xiaoming
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3724/sp.j.1041.2024.01125
2024-01-01
Acta Psychologica Sinica
Abstract:As an important extra-role behavior in the workplace,helping behavior refers to the voluntarily act of caring for others and assisting them with work-related affairs.To date,most studies have focused on the antecedents of helping behavior or its impact on the providers and recipients of help.However,there is limited discussion on the effects of helping behavior on observers.Drawing on social comparison theory and the peer influence literature,this research contends that observed coworker helping behavior influences observers'cognitive and emotional reactions,and ultimately,their behaviors.On the one hand,observers may experience increased indebtedness and shame upon witnessing coworker helping behavior,which can enhance their own helping behavior.On the other hand,observers may experience reduced organization-based self-esteem and pride upon witnessing coworker helping behavior,thereby diminish their own helping behavior.We further investigate the moderating role of observers'initial helping behavior in the effects of observed coworker helping behavior. Hypotheses were tested using a multi-wave survey and three experiments with Eastern and Western samples.Study 1(an initial field survey),participants from a Chinese food supply company were invited to participate.Study 2(an experiment)manipulated observed coworker helping behavior and observers'helping behavior,measuring observers'subsequent feelings of indebtedness toward coworkers and organization-based self-esteem.Study 3(an experiment)manipulated feelings of indebtedness toward coworkers and organization-based self-esteem,then assessed observers'emotions and helping behavior.Study 4(an experiment)manipulated observed coworker helping behavior and observers'helping behavior,then assessed the remaining variables of the model. The above studies supported our hypotheses.Results demonstrated that observed coworker helping behavior is positively related to observers'indebtedness toward coworkers and shame,which in turn,increases their helping behavior.At the same time,observed coworker helping behavior is negatively related to observers'organization-based self-esteem and pride,which in turn,decreases their helping behavior.Additionally,the level of observers'helping behavior moderates the effects of coworker helping behavior.Specifically,when their helping behavior is higher(versus lower),the effects of coworker helping behavior on indebtedness toward coworkers and organization-based self-esteem are weaker. This study contributes to the literature on helping behavior in several ways.First,it introduces the novel perspective of third-party observers,thereby shifting the traditional research focus.Different from the previous studies,this study examines the psychological and behavioral responses of observers to observed coworker helping behavior.Second,this study considers both the positive and negative consequences of observed coworker helping behavior,as well as explains why observed coworker helping behavior is a double-edged sword for observers.Thus,this study provides a more complete picture of the psychological mechanisms by which observed coworker helping behavior affects observers'subsequential behavior.Third,by examining observers'initial helping behavior as a boundary condition,it clarifies the conditions under which observers are more likely to react positively or negatively.This examination provides a deeper understanding of the third party's response to observed coworker helping behavior.