Abstract:A fundamental question that has concerned social scientists since Barrington Moore is the political transformations that accompanied agrarian societies’ transitions to modern economy. One paradigmatic case is the peasant-based Communist revolution in China, the causes of which have been the subject of a long-standing debate. Scholars have emphasized peasant proletarianization, Communist leadership in peasant nationalism, the attraction of their socio- economic reforms, their effective mobilization, Nationalists’ failures, and geographical conditions. Based on county gazetteers and administrative records of 154 counties in the most heavily contested region during the crucial years, we conduct the first multivariate local-level analysis of revolution. The results show little support for existing narratives. Instead, they substantiate what we call the “Tocqueville-Fei thesis”, that state centralization in agrarian bureaucratic polities inadvertently facilitated social revolution. The state’s effort to penetrate local communities undermined traditional governance structures, upsetting the balance between the state and local norms/elites and turning state agents into unbridled predators on peasants, which created favorable conditions for the Communists. This study has implications for understanding the modernization of agrarian societies and the dynamics of social change, and casts new light on the long-term trajectory of the state-society relationship in China.

Warlords, State Failures, and the Rise of Communism in China

When Things Were Falling Apart: Tocqueville, Fei Xiaotong and the Agrarian Causes of the Chinese Revolution

Did the Communists Contribute to China’s Rural Growth?

Revolution, State Building, and the Great Famine in China

Appropriation of Land in Southeastern China between the 1920s and the 1940s, with a Discussion of Landlords, Peasants and the Land Revolution

Peasants' Fatalistic Thinking in Chinese Communism: an Analysis of a Rural Family's Oral History

Colonial Legacies and Peripheral Strategies: Social-spatial Logic of China’s Communications Development Since 1840

States and Wars: China's Long March Towards Unity and Its Consequences, 221 BC - 1911 AD

Historical Traumas and the Roots of Political Distrust: Political Inference from the Great Chinese Famine

Changing disaster relief regimes in China: an analysis using four famines between 1876 and 1962

Regional Interactions in Social Responses to Extreme Climate Events: A Case Study of the North China Famine of 1876–1879

The key causes of urban-rural conflict in China

Rural Mobilization in the Chinese Communist Revolution: from the Anti-Japanese War to the Chinese Civil War

Colonial Legacies and Peripheral Strategies Continuity and Transformation of China's Telecom Development Since 1840

Relationship between famine and climatic disasters in China during the Qing Dynasty

Stay hungry, and stay calm in upbeat time: Local leaders' early‐life famine experience and housing sector development in China

Fifty Years of Regional Inequality in China: A Journey Through Central Planning, Reform, and Openness

Communist Revolution as the Origin of the Capitalism in the Red China: The Political Economy of the Private Economy in Zhejiang Province

Legitimizing Ruptures Of Development Trajectories: Party Press Discourse On Rural Society In Transitional China, 1997-2006

Effects of Land Fragmentation on the Governance of the Commons: Theory and Evidence from 284 Villages and 17 Provinces in China

The Emperor Strikes Back: Political Status, Career Incentives and Grain Procurement during China's Great Leap Famine