Partial Substitution of Chemical Fertilizers with Manure Alters Soil Phosphorus Fractions and Optimizes Vegetable Production in Alkaline Soil

Shuo Chen,Jiayi Jiang,Lulu Wei,Jilin Lei,Owen Fenton,Karen Daly,Qing Chen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03650340.2021.2018575
2023-01-01
Archives of Agronomy and Soil Science
Abstract:Maintaining phosphorus (P) supply for plants or reducing P mobility is critical to sustainable agricultural production and the environment. However, substituting long-term chemical fertilizer with a fraction of (i.e. partial substitution) manure and its effect on soil P surplus and P fractionation have not been widely studied. An eight-year protected field study with no fertilization (NF), chemical fertilizer substituted with no manure (NS), partial manure (40%, PS), and total manure (100%, TS) combined with multiple P characterization methods were conducted to examine P pools and stability in alkaline soil. NS, PS, and TS have the same input amount of nutrients. It showed that PS treatment lowered the annual P surplus by 6.21% and 11.2% compared with NS and TS, respectively, maintaining optimal P input-output balance and vegetable yields. TS decreased total P-o by 31.9% and stable Ca-associated P by 21.1%, while increased labile organic P, compared with NS. The labile P in PS was at a moderate level compared with NS and TS treatments, which not only maintained the soil labile P pools but also reduced P leaching risk. Therefore, partial substitution of chemical fertilizer with manure leads to an optimal level of nutrients for vegetable production.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?