Theoretical and Structural Understanding of the Different Factors Influencing the Formation of Multicomponent Crystals of 2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic Acid with N-heterocyclic Compounds

Lan Fang,Yiming Ma,Yuntian Xiao,Zhonghua Li,Zhenguo Gao,Songgu Wu,Sohrab Rohani,Junbo Gong
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.cgd.1c01239
IF: 4.01
2022-01-01
Crystal Growth & Design
Abstract:The formation of multicomponent crystals depends on many factors; therefore it is extremely challenging to predict and select the appropriate coformers (CCFs) to prepare functional multicomponent crystals. In this study, we selected the 2,4-dichiorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) molecule and 10 N-heterocyclic compounds with similar structures to investigate the main factors affecting the synthesis of multicomponent crystals. On screening of multicomponent crystals by solution crystallization, we obtained nine b of multicomponent crystals of 2,4-D with different colors, including a hydrate of the 2,4-D-PYE cocrystal. However, 1,3-bis(4-pyridyl)propane (BPP) failed to form multicomponent crystals with 2,4-D using the solution crystallization methods. The influence of CCF on the formation of multicomponent crystals was discussed from three aspects: hydrogen bond donor and acceptor capacity (molecular electrostatic potential (MEP) surface, hydrogen bond acceptor ability h_ema calculated by Molecular Operating Environment software, and interaction site-pairing energy differences (Delta Esite-pair)), thermodynamic enthalpy (the excess enthalpy Delta H-ex), and structural factors (molecular complementarity (MC) and molecular flexibility (Kier flex)). Molecular flexibility is the main reason no multicomponent crystals are formed between BPP and 2,4-D. A logistic regression calculation indicates that the formation of multicomponent crystals of 2,4-D is mainly affected by Delta Esite-pair and MEP values. The cases considered in this study not only expand the crystal structure landscape of the 2,4-D but also provide a reference for the effective prediction and design of multicomponent crystals, in general.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?