The influence of diagnosis quality on the economic feasibility of maintenance strategies for hv components

Wen Cao,Qikai Zhuang,Kai Wu,Dhiradj Djairam,Johan J. Smit

2011-01-01

Abstract:Condition based maintenance (CBM) strategies are widely applied in utility companies instead of time based maintenance (TBM), in order to reduce the maintenance costs. However, the extent of this reduction depends on the quality of the diagnosis. In this paper, we simulate the total lifecycle cost to operate 10000 cable connections for 100 years. Both time-based (i.e. TBM) and condition-based periodic maintenance (i.e. CBM) strategies are applied in the simulation. We assume that the failure probability vs. health condition index relationship satisfies a Weibull distribution estimated from laboratory test data. The diagnostic index is simulated through multiplying the health index h with a factor. This factor is assumed to follow a lognormal distribution with scale parameter η, and this η value indicates the error of diagnosis. From the simulation results, we learn that this diagnosis error indicator η and the cost of diagnosis have more significant influence than the failure loss on the decision between TBM and CBM. In addition, several methods to estimate the η value have been proposed. As a result, a generic process has been established for asset manager to judge whether a diagnosis method can be applied in CBM strategy and create economic profit.